We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Innovation

Data Law and Cybersecurity Lawyers

Flux de chiffres bleus numériques flous en mouvement sur fond sombre représentant la data numérique.
Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin
Baptiste Robelin
Laurent Bidault
Laurent Bidault

Data is now the essential raw material of public action and the fuel of territorial innovation. Whether it is collected or captured to optimise waste management, improve mobility or feed Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems, the "datafication" of our society raises major legal challenges.

NOVLAW Avocats supports public buyers (central government, local authorities), private operators (public service concession holders) and Tech companies in the governance, protection and value creation of their data. At the crossroads of public law, contract law and digital law, we secure your innovation projects.

360° support across the data life cycle

Mastering data is no longer just a matter of GDPR compliance. To protect the interests of local authorities and citizens, our firm works on 4 inseparable pillars:

  1. Governance and Open Data: data sharing and ownership.
  2. Artificial Intelligence: securing AI systems and models, algorithms and compliance (AI Act).
  3. Cybersecurity and hosting: sovereignty and protection against cyberattacks.
  4. Infrastructure (data centres): planning and environmental impact issues.

 

Governance, Data Ownership and Public Procurement

When performing a public contract or a public service concession (DSP), private operators collect large volumes of data across the territory (mobility data, water consumption, parking).

Who owns this data?

Without strict contractual safeguards, local authorities can often find themselves deprived of this strategic information.

NOVLAW Avocats helps you secure and control your data:

  • Ownership and contractual clauses: We draft the clauses of your specifications (CCAP) to guarantee reversibility and the return and transfer of databases to the authority at the end of the contract, in open and interoperable formats.
  • Data of general interest: Since the Digital Republic Act (loi pour une République numérique), data generated by the management of a public service must be made open (Open Data). We ensure that concession holders make this data available so that you can steer your public policies effectively.
  • Pooling and sharing data between local authorities: To roll out shared tools (territorial digital twins, housing or energy observatories), municipalities and their inter-municipal bodies (EPCI) often need to pool their data. We provide the legal framework for these partnerships by drafting data provision and sharing agreements between public bodies, ensuring interoperability and confidentiality.

The inseparable link between Data and Artificial Intelligence (AI)

More and more local authorities are deploying AI systems, such as conversational agents (chatbots) on their websites, or using generative AI systems to help staff draft administrative documents (council resolutions, minutes, analysis of grant applications or planning applications). Yet an AI system's performance is directly linked to the quality of its training data.

The use of these systems by public services entails legal risks (bias, "hallucinations", data leaks) that NOVLAW Avocats helps you manage:

  • Legal project support (AMO) for procuring and supplying AI systems: Buying artificial intelligence should not be approached like buying conventional software. We act as legal advisers to the contracting authority (AMO) when drafting your AI-specific public contracts. In this context, we secure the clauses relating to algorithmic performance guarantees, model explainability, IP rights management and the hosting of training data.
  • Quality and lawfulness of training data: We check that the document corpora used to "feed" in-house AI systems comply with personal data and public data law, in particular by ensuring they contain no non-anonymised sensitive personal data.
  • AI Act compliance: The regulation imposes strict transparency obligations. If you deploy AI to respond to users, we help you draft the mandatory notices informing citizens that they are interacting with a machine.
  • Bringing contracts into compliance: We help senior management draft "AI Ethics Charters" to govern staff's unofficial uses of AI (so-called Shadow AI) and set clear rules of use.

3. Cybersecurity, Hosting and Digital Sovereignty

Local authorities and public institutions have become prime targets for cybercriminals (ransomware paralysing town halls, hospitals and departmental councils). Cybersecurity is no longer a technical option; it is a matter of legal and political resilience.

NOVLAW Avocats secures your IT infrastructure and contracts:

  • Cybersecurity clauses: We build robust security requirements into your IT outsourcing and software services contracts (obligation to report vulnerabilities immediately, regular security audits, deterrent penalties).
  • Hosting and sovereignty: In response to extraterritorial laws (such as the US Cloud Act), many local authorities now require sovereign hosting. We assist you in drafting public contracts requiring data to be hosted exclusively in France or Europe, and with your strategies for migrating to open-source solutions.

Physical infrastructure: Data Centres and Planning

The Cloud is not just virtual. The exponential growth in data volumes and the boom in artificial intelligence require huge physical infrastructure: data centres.

Setting up these "data factories" (hyperscalers) in local areas raises immense environmental, land and energy challenges. Working closely with our Planning Law practice, NOVLAW Avocats advises on:

  • Acceptability and environmental impact: legal analysis of impact assessments, compliance with the Climate and Resilience Act (Zero Net Land Take, ZAN) regarding soil sealing, and integration into planning documents (PLUi).
  • Energy regulation: Data centres raise significant issues in terms of power consumption and cooling. We secure environmental permits (ICPE) and grid connection agreements.
  • Public and sovereign data centre projects: We support local authorities and joint authorities (syndicats mixtes) that choose to build their own small local data centres (a "responsible digital" approach) through real estate structures or global performance contracts.

‍

Frequently asked questions on digital data

Can European hosting or SecNumCloud qualification be required in an AI contract?

Yes, but... provided that the requirement is justified by the subject matter of the contract and proportionate. Article 31 of the SREN Law requires the use of qualified cloud solutions where the data processed are sensitive and their compromise would be likely to undermine public order or public security. The Prime Minister's circular No. 6519/SG of 5 February 2026 on digital public procurement goes further, requiring central government buyers to apply a grid of nine decision criteria, explicitly including digital sovereignty and security. In practice, these requirements come into play at the application stage (SecNumCloud 3.2 qualification or equivalent measures, absence of non-European control), at the tender evaluation stage (security and data location criteria) and in the contract (audit, reversibility, termination in the event of a change of control). The drafting must remain compatible with European competition law and the principle of non-discrimination: be careful, this is where the legal certainty of the contract is won or lost.

Who owns the public data used to train a contractor's AI, and the improved model that results?

This is one of the most common blind spots in AI contracts. In the absence of an express provision, the software vendor may argue that it remains the owner of the model retrained with the authority's data, and freely reuse the performance gains obtained thanks to the public service for the benefit of its other clients, sometimes competitors of the local authority. The CCAP (special administrative clauses) must therefore deal separately with three items: the data supplied by the buyer, the data generated during performance of the contract (annotations, corrections, feedback from staff) and the model parameters resulting from training. The CCAG (general administrative clauses) also provides for clauses to this effect. Reuse of public data for other purposes should be prohibited or strictly controlled, the fate of training datasets at the end of the contract should be provided for, and these provisions should be reconciled with the obligations to publish essential contract data, trade secrets and the GDPR.

Is a territorial digital twin subject to the GDPR and open data obligations?

Frequently, yes, and the two approaches must be reconciled. Where sensors, meters or counting devices make it possible to re-identify individuals (consumption at household level, journeys, images), the GDPR applies and requires an impact assessment, data minimisation and aggregation. At the same time, the data produced by the local authority constitute administrative documents that may be subject to online publication obligations. The practical challenge is therefore to define contractually, at the outset, which data may be disseminated, at what level of granularity, and which are covered by the operator's trade secrets.

Can a contractor refuse to return your data at the end of a public contract?

This is a major risk if the contract has been poorly drafted! To avoid it, the special administrative clauses (CCAP) must include a reversibility clause specifying the format, timeframe and costs (ideally zero) of returning the data and the associated source code.

Must a user be informed that an administrative decision was taken by an AI system?

Yes, this is a strict legal obligation. The French Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration (CRPA) requires the administration to explicitly inform the user when an individual decision is taken on the basis of algorithmic processing.

What rights do individuals have over their personal data?

The GDPR confers several rights on data subjects: the right of access (to obtain a copy of their data), the right to rectification (to correct inaccurate data), the right to erasure (the right to be forgotten), the right to restriction of processing, the right to data portability, the right to object to processing, and the right not to be subject to an automated decision. The controller must respond to requests to exercise these rights within one month.

What regulatory obligations apply to data centre operators in France?

Data centre operators in France are subject to several obligations: GDPR compliance for the personal data they host, the obligations applicable to operators of vital importance (OIV) for critical infrastructure, the requirements of the French Military Programming Act (loi de programmation militaire), environmental regulations (water and energy consumption, carbon footprint), and network security obligations under the NIS2 Directive as transposed into French law.

What GDPR obligations apply to local authorities deploying smart city equipment?

Local authorities deploying smart city equipment (sensors, cameras, connected terminals) must, as data controllers, carry out a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) for high-risk processing, inform residents of the processing carried out, minimise the data collected, limit retention periods, and secure their systems. The CNIL (French data protection authority) may inspect such processing and impose penalties for non-compliance.

What is the US Cloud Act and how does it affect French companies?

The 2018 Cloud Act (Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data Act) allows US authorities to require a US cloud provider to disclose data stored in any country, including France. For French companies using the services of US cloud providers (AWS, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud), this means that their data may potentially be accessible to US authorities, even if it is hosted in Europe. To avoid this risk, it is advisable to opt for SecNumCloud-certified sovereign cloud offerings.

What is SecNumCloud qualification and for whom is it recommended?

SecNumCloud is the framework of ANSSI (Agence Nationale de la Sécurité des Systèmes d'Information, the French national cybersecurity agency) which qualifies cloud computing offerings that guarantee a high level of security and immunity from extraterritorial laws (notably the US Cloud Act). This qualification is recommended for entities handling sensitive data: public administrations, operators of vital importance (OIV), operators of essential services (OSE), and any organisation wishing to guarantee the confidentiality of its strategic data.

What is a personal data breach and what are the obligations in the event of an incident?

A personal data breach is any breach of security leading to the destruction, loss, alteration, unauthorised disclosure of, or unauthorised access to, personal data. In the event of a breach, the data controller must notify the CNIL within 72 hours if the breach is likely to result in a risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals. If the risk is high, the data subjects must also be informed without undue delay.

What is “sovereign” hosting?

Sovereign hosting guarantees that data (stored and processed) is subject only to French and European law. This means not only that the servers (data centres) are physically located in Europe, but also that the company operating them is not subject to foreign laws allowing, in particular, data to be seized without the approval of a European judge.

What is a DPO and when is one mandatory?

The Data Protection Officer (DPO) is responsible for bringing an organisation into compliance with the GDPR. Appointing one is mandatory for: public authorities and bodies; organisations whose core activities consist of regular and systematic monitoring of individuals on a large scale; and organisations processing sensitive data on a large scale (health, political opinions, etc.). Other organisations may appoint a DPO voluntarily.

Is the local authority liable if an AI gives a user false information?

Yes. If a town hall chatbot powered by generative AI provides incorrect information (a “hallucination”) that causes harm to a user (e.g. wrong information about a planning procedure), the local authority may incur administrative liability. Human oversight and limiting the scope of the AI are essential.

What contracts are needed to host data in a data centre?

Hosting data in a data centre requires several contracts to be put in place: a hosting or colocation agreement setting out service levels (SLAs), availability conditions and security obligations; a data processing agreement (DPA) compliant with the GDPR if personal data is hosted; and specific clauses on confidentiality, data reversibility at the end of the contract and liability in the event of an incident.

How can data generated by smart city equipment be used by third parties?

Data generated by smart city equipment (traffic, energy consumption, footfall) may be made publicly available through open data (an obligation for local authorities with more than 3,500 inhabitants), shared with private partners under an innovation partnership or a public service concession, or used in the context of calls for projects. In all cases, personal data may only be shared in anonymised or pseudonymised form.

How can intellectual property in software and databases developed for a local authority be secured?

This is the point most often neglected and the most costly to put right. In the absence of an express clause, the contractor retains its rights and the local authority ends up holding a mere user licence, which is insufficient to develop the solution further, entrust it to a third party or reuse it in another scope. The applicable CCAGs (general administrative terms and conditions), in particular the CCAG-TIC, offer options for licensing or assigning the rights in the results: this choice must be made deliberately in the specific contract documents. Four clauses must be tailor-made: the scope of the rights assigned or licensed (media, duration, territory, right of adaptation), the deposit of source code with an escrow agent, ownership of the databases fed by the area's sensors, and reversibility, i.e. the return of data in open, documented formats when the contract expires.

Is a contract remunerated through the exploitation of urban data a public contract or a concession?

The classification depends on the transfer of operating risk, not on the title chosen by the parties. Where the operator derives a substantial part of its remuneration from exploiting the data produced by the area's equipment, from advertising revenue or from services sold to third parties, and bears the associated uncertainty, the contract falls within the scope of concessions. Conversely, public payment based on performance commitments — network availability, restoration time, reduced consumption — falls within the scope of public contracts, including global performance contracts. These hybrid arrangements call for two precautions: checking that the local authority retains legal control over the area's data, which can only constitute remuneration if its exploitation is lawful and regulated, and checking that the value transferred to the operator has been assessed and factored into the overall economics of the contract.

Flux de chiffres bleus numériques flous en mouvement sur fond sombre représentant la data numérique.
Everything you need to know about innovation law

More resources

More resources

No items found.

Contact our Data and Digital Law experts

Whether you want to secure ownership of your data in dealings with a service provider, audit your IT contracts for cyber risk, or put a legal framework around your Artificial Intelligence projects, NOVLAW is your strategic partner.