Yes. The law on simplifying economic life (loi de simplification de la vie économique) of 26 May 2026 introduced into Article L. 2113-17 of the French Public Procurement Code (code de la commande publique) a mechanism allowing the buyer, in contracts divided into lots for innovative services, to reserve up to 15% of the total value of the lots for young innovative companies within the meaning of Article 44 sexies-0 A of the French General Tax Code (code général des impôts). This lever only has a real effect if it is built in from the moment the contract is divided into lots: lots of an accessible size, proportionate capacity requirements, and payment terms and advances suited to the cash flow of a young business. It is also the route that allows a local area to anchor its local ecosystem in its smart city project, rather than depending on a single integrator.
When they exceed the normal inconveniences of neighbourhood life. Since Law No. 2024-346 of 15 April 2024, this principle has been set out in Article 1253 of the French Civil Code. The court assesses the intensity, frequency, timing and duration of the nuisance, as well as the layout of the premises. No fault on the part of the operator is required, and holding an administrative authorisation does not exonerate it. For noise from business activities, the French Public Health Code (Code de la santé publique) also sets limit values for noise emergence above background levels (Art. R. 1336-6 and R. 1336-7).
Yes. The syndicate may bring legal proceedings to enforce the co-ownership regulations and safeguard the rights relating to the building (Art. 15 of Law No. 65-557 of 10 July 1965). The property manager (syndic) must in principle be authorised to do so by the general meeting, except, in particular, in summary proceedings (référé) (Art. 55 of Decree No. 67-223 of 17 March 1967). Each co-owner who is affected may also act alone in respect of the disturbance they personally suffer.
No, where it affects the common parts or the external appearance of the building. Such works must be authorised by the general meeting by the majority provided for in Article 25 b) of the Law of 10 July 1965. Failing that, the syndicate may ask the court to order the removal of the installation and the reinstatement of the premises, if necessary subject to a daily penalty (astreinte).
Under certain conditions. Article 1253 of the Civil Code excludes liability where three cumulative conditions are met: the activity existed before the complainant moved in, it complies with laws and regulations, and it has continued without any worsening of the disturbance. An establishment that exceeds noise thresholds, or that has changed its activity (a brasserie turned into a music bar, for example), will find it difficult to rely on this.
Yes, below the threshold of €140,000 excluding VAT, if its solution is innovative: the company can approach the buyer and contract directly by negotiation, without a formal procedure. This is not, however, a guaranteed right. The buyer must still choose a relevant offer, make good use of public funds and not systematically contract with the same operator where several offers could meet the need. A file demonstrating the innovative nature of the solution therefore remains the best sales argument.
Since 1 July 2026, the threshold has been €140,000 excluding VAT, up from €100,000 excluding VAT previously. It results from Article 16 of Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on simplifying economic life, which refers to the European threshold applicable to supply and service contracts awarded by central government authorities: the amount will therefore change automatically with each biennial revision. Note that Article R. 2122-9-1 of the French Public Procurement Code has not yet been updated and still refers to €100,000 excluding VAT; it is the statute, which is more recent, that applies.
As far as the public service user is concerned, liability remains with the authority: it cannot hide behind its contractor's malfunction to justify an unlawful decision, and the administrative court will assess the lawfulness of the act, not the quality of the software. Internally, the allocation of liability depends on the contract and on how the parties are classified under the AI Act: an authority that makes the system available under its own name, or substantially modifies it, may switch from deployer to provider status and take on the corresponding obligations. Hence the importance of negotiated clauses on compliance warranties, indemnification and liability caps, as well as a reserved right of recourse in the event of an administrative penalty. As to the timetable: the prohibitions and the AI literacy obligation have applied since February 2025 and the transparency obligations since August 2026, while the Digital Omnibus regulation adopted in June 2026 postponed the obligations relating to high-risk systems to 2 December 2027 (Annex III) and 2 August 2028 (Annex I). Note, however, that this postponement is a preparation period, not an exemption.
Yes, but... provided that the requirement is justified by the subject matter of the contract and proportionate. Article 31 of the SREN Law requires the use of qualified cloud solutions where the data processed are sensitive and their compromise would be likely to undermine public order or public security. The Prime Minister's circular No. 6519/SG of 5 February 2026 on digital public procurement goes further, requiring central government buyers to apply a grid of nine decision criteria, explicitly including digital sovereignty and security. In practice, these requirements come into play at the application stage (SecNumCloud 3.2 qualification or equivalent measures, absence of non-European control), at the tender evaluation stage (security and data location criteria) and in the contract (audit, reversibility, termination in the event of a change of control). The drafting must remain compatible with European competition law and the principle of non-discrimination: be careful, this is where the legal certainty of the contract is won or lost.
This is one of the most common blind spots in AI contracts. In the absence of an express provision, the software vendor may argue that it remains the owner of the model retrained with the authority's data, and freely reuse the performance gains obtained thanks to the public service for the benefit of its other clients, sometimes competitors of the local authority. The CCAP (special administrative clauses) must therefore deal separately with three items: the data supplied by the buyer, the data generated during performance of the contract (annotations, corrections, feedback from staff) and the model parameters resulting from training. The CCAG (general administrative clauses) also provides for clauses to this effect. Reuse of public data for other purposes should be prohibited or strictly controlled, the fate of training datasets at the end of the contract should be provided for, and these provisions should be reconciled with the obligations to publish essential contract data, trade secrets and the GDPR.
In practice, the CCAGs (general administrative clauses), including the CCAG-TIC (for information and communication technology contracts), were not designed for AI systems: they must be supplemented in the CCAP (special administrative clauses). Six families of clauses deserve particular attention. First, the allocation of roles under the AI Act: the contractor must be contractually identified as the provider and undertake to supply the technical documentation, the instructions for use and the information enabling the public deployer to fulfil its own obligations. Next, performance, with measurable indicators (error rate, false positive rate, robustness requirements) rather than mere best-efforts commitments. Then come human oversight and traceability (logging, explainability of outputs), the regime governing data and intellectual property, the management of changes to the model (a substantial update must not silently degrade the service or alter the legal classification of the system) and, finally, reversibility: return of data, configurations and annotation sets, and an enforceable exit plan.
Buying an AI system means anticipating, from the moment the need is defined, what no conventional software specification provides for: the classification of the system under the AI Act, the nature and origin of the training data, the expected level of performance and how it is measured, and the division of roles between provider and deployer. The choice of procedure is also a key structuring decision: prior market sourcing, the innovation partnership, the research and development public contract or the direct award of innovative purchases, whose threshold was raised to €140,000 excluding VAT by the law on simplifying economic life of 26 May 2026, do not meet the same needs or carry the same risks. The State Purchasing Directorate (Direction des achats de l'État) and DINUM have also published a dedicated guidance sheet on the responsible purchasing of AI solutions, which offers sourcing questions and sample clauses. Our firm provides legal assistance to contracting authorities (AMO) across this entire chain, from defining the need to notification of the contract.
The two regimes overlap. The original elements modelled are protected by copyright, and the model may be classified as a work of collaboration where several contributors have taken part in it, with the consequence that it must be exploited by common agreement between the co-authors. At the same time, the model constitutes a structured database: anyone who has made a substantial investment in its creation or verification may rely on the producer's sui generis right, which protects against the extraction or reuse of a substantial part of the contents, regardless of any originality. Contractual clauses should expressly refer to both legal bases.
Only within the limits of the rights assigned to it. The model incorporates creations protected by copyright, the rights to which remain with their authors unless otherwise agreed. However, the assignment granted for the purposes of construction does not necessarily cover operation and maintenance, modification of the building or feeding a digital twin. In a public contract, although the CCAG determines the scope of these rights, they need to be specified and adapted in the contract documents. It is therefore essential to list, from the tender stage, the subsequent uses envisaged: facility management and maintenance, extension, sale of the asset, open data.
There is no compulsory BIM policy, but standard policies do not always cover the risks specific to the process: the BIM management role, loss or corruption of the model, damage to data hosted on the collaborative platform, infringement of intellectual property rights. Checks on insurance certificates should therefore focus on three points: the effective insurability of the contractor's BIM role, the existence of professional liability cover for non-consequential intangible loss, and cyber cover for the common data environment.
No, not as such. The ten-year guarantee under Article 1792 of the Civil Code covers damage affecting a construction work that compromises its soundness or renders it unfit for its intended purpose: a digital model is not a construction work, and a mere modelling inconsistency with no physical manifestation does not fall within this regime. On the other hand, a design error revealed by the model and materialised in the completed building falls squarely within the builders' statutory guarantees. The model therefore changes not so much the liability regime as the way in which the defect and the party responsible for it are proven.
The dividing line is fundamental and is regularly scrutinised by the courts. A subsidy responds to an initiative put forward by the beneficiary, which the local authority chooses to support; a public contract meets a need defined by the local authority, in return for a price. Where the public body drafts the specifications, sets the deliverables and supervises performance, the payment is treated as a public contract, with the well-known consequences if there has been no competitive tendering. In practice, a smart territory project almost always combines several sources: funding from national or European calls for projects, financing from ADEME or the Banque des Territoires, a contribution from a private operator, operating revenue. Each building block must be legally classified in its own right: it is the overall structure, not the intention, that determines the applicable regime.
The French Public Procurement Code allows a contract for innovative works, supplies or services to be concluded without prior advertising or competitive tendering below a threshold raised to €140,000 excluding VAT by Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on simplifying economic life. The mechanism is well suited to the first building blocks of a smart territory project: new types of sensors, a hypervision module, a simulation software component. The exemption is not, however, a blank cheque. The buyer must be able to demonstrate that the purchase is genuinely innovative — under Article L. 2172-3 of the French Public Procurement Code, new or significantly improved works, supplies or services are innovative — and comply with the principle of the proper use of public funds. A memo analysing the innovative nature of the purchase, kept in the tender file, secures the contract in the event of a challenge.
The time limit for lodging an appeal on points of law (pourvoi en cassation) against a judgment of an Administrative Court of Appeal is two months from notification of the court's decision. However, this time limit is reduced to 15 days where the case concerns summary proceedings (référé).
The same as for any restaurant: safety standards for establishments open to the public (ERP), food hygiene and a licence to sell alcohol. The health pass, which required checks at the entrance, was abolished in 2022. What sets a shopping centre restaurant apart is above all contractual: the lease often imposes opening hours aligned with those of the centre, a contribution to common service charges and to the traders' association, and sometimes a variable rent based on turnover. These clauses should be negotiated before signing.
Yes, decisions of sports federations approved by the State can be challenged before the administrative court, insofar as these federations exercise public authority prerogatives (management of licences, organisation of competitions, disciplinary matters). On the other hand, purely private decisions of a federation fall within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts. The French National Olympic and Sports Committee (CNOSF) operates a mandatory prior conciliation procedure for certain sports disputes.
<p>Yes, the licence forms part of the business (fonds de commerce) and may be sold by the liquidator. Check that it is still valid: a category 3 or 4 drinking establishment that has been closed for more than five years is deemed to have ceased to exist and its licence can no longer be transferred; in liquidation, this period is extended until the proceedings are closed (French Public Health Code (CSP), Art. L. 3333-1).</p>
The cost depends on the stage: formal notice, application for a court-appointed expert in summary proceedings, or action on the merits. You also need to allow for official reports by a commissaire de justice (judicial officer) and the deposit towards the expert's fees, set by the court. A fee agreement is drawn up before any work begins. In co-ownership buildings, collective action allows costs to be shared among the co-owners.
A third-party challenge does not in itself have suspensive effect, but it opens the way to an application for suspension in summary proceedings (référé-suspension), in which urgency is presumed in the case of a planning authorisation (Article L. 600-3 of the French Planning Code (code de l'urbanisme)), a presumption the Conseil d'État has just extended to the withdrawal of an authorisation (CE, 17 June 2026, No. 513099). This presumption remains rebuttable: the court has, for example, already accepted that the public interest in the deployment of renewable energy may rule out urgency (CE, 17 January 2024, No. 467572). Proper and continuous posting of the permit on site, recorded by a commissaire de justice (judicial officer), remains the first line of protection: it starts the two-month time limit running. Finally, a defect is not necessarily fatal: the permit may be regularised during the proceedings by an amending permit, including in the light of new rules or circumstances (CE, 23 October 2025, Commune de Montriond, No. 492924).
Decree No. 2026-302 of 21 April 2026 created a special litigation regime for environmental projects of strategic importance. Challenges are brought directly before the administrative court of appeal, which has jurisdiction at first and last instance (Article R. 311-5 of the French Code of Administrative Justice), its judgment being open only to an appeal on points of law. The court rules within ten months. The challenge must be notified to the author of the decision and to the beneficiary within fifteen clear days, failing which it is inadmissible, and a prior administrative appeal does not extend the time limit. The regime covers in particular photovoltaic installations of at least 5 MW, hydroelectric installations of at least 1 MW, onshore wind, anaerobic digestion, grid connection works, transport infrastructure of more than €5 million excluding VAT and projects of major national interest. The regime only applies to acts adopted on or after 1 July 2026. If the project is not strategic, the first-instance administrative court (tribunal administratif) has jurisdiction.
Every situation deserves a clear and pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.