HomePublic law
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Public law

Public Property and Public Real Estate Law Lawyer

Vue du Vieux-Port de Marseille avec la cathédrale et le fort Saint-Jean sous un ciel bleu clair.
Contents
Our specialists
Maïté Cano
Maïté Cano
Laurent Bidault
Laurent Bidault

Laurent Bidault and Maïté Cano, partners in public law and real estate law.

The management, occupation and development of real estate owned by public bodies are subject to complex legal rules, governed mainly by the General Code of Public Property (Code général de la propriété des personnes publiques, CGPPP).

At the crossroads of public law, construction law and real estate law, NOVLAW Avocats advises local authorities, the State, public institutions and private operators (developers, companies, associations) throughout France.

The firm draws on its multidisciplinary expertise to secure your contractual arrangements, optimise the management of public property and defend your interests in the event of litigation.

Understanding public property law

The assets of a public body fall into two broad categories, subject to very different legal regimes:

  • The public domain: This comprises property assigned to direct use by the public or to a public service (provided it has been specially adapted for that purpose). Such property is inalienable and imprescriptible, which affects, among other things, the choice of contractual arrangement used to develop the domain or to authorise its occupation and operation.
  • The private domain: This includes all other property, which is managed according to rules similar to those of private law, although subject to specific administrative constraints.

The boundary between these two domains is often blurred, and a specialist lawyer is needed to classify the property legally and determine the applicable rules or the appropriate contractual arrangement.

Understanding public real estate law

A genuinely cross-cutting field, public real estate law lies at the crossroads of administrative law and private real estate law. It governs all real estate transactions involving a public body or subject to public authority prerogatives. In particular, it covers:

  • Land acquisitions and disposals: Purchases by private agreement, exercise of the urban (DPU) or commercial pre-emption right, and compulsory purchase (expropriation) procedures in the public interest.
  • Public construction: Operations under public project ownership, off-plan sales (Vente en l’État Futur d’Achèvement, VEFA) to public bodies, building leases, off-plan leases (Bail en l’État Futur d’Achèvement, BEFA) and property development contracts.
  • Conventional asset management: Commercial, professional or residential leases entered into by (or with) a public body over its private domain.

Mastering public real estate law requires dual expertise (public and private), which NOVLAW Avocats cultivates every day to provide pragmatic support to public developers as well as private developers and builders.

What is the role of a lawyer in public real estate law and public property law? NOVLAW’s expertise in public domain and real estate law

Our firm acts at every stage in the life of public assets, in both advisory and litigation matters.

1. Land audit and classification of property

Before any development project or disposal, it is crucial to secure the legal status of the land.

We assist you with:

  • The analysis and legal classification of property (public domain or private domain).
  • Managing decommissioning and declassification procedures to allow the disposal of property from the public domain.
  • Procedures for delimiting the public domain (alignment, boundary marking).

2. Asset development and contractual arrangements

Private occupation of the public or private domain requires a specific legal title.

Our team assists you in choosing, negotiating and drafting the contract best suited to your economic or development project:

3. Competitive tendering and selection of occupants

The granting of occupation titles that allow economic exploitation is subject to transparency and publicity requirements.

  • For public bodies: Securing the selection procedure, drafting the publicity notices and the consultation documents (similar to our work in public procurement).
  • For private companies: Support in preparing the application file and analysing the risks of the proposed contract.

4. Public property and real estate litigation

In the event of a dispute, our team represents you before the administrative and civil courts:

  • Proceedings for the eviction of occupants without right or title (urgent interim relief, known as référé mesures utiles).
  • Disputes relating to the amount, revision or recovery of occupation fees.
  • Defence or prosecution in matters of contraventions de grande voirie (offences against the public domain).
  • Disputes arising from the refusal to renew, or the early termination of, an agreement.
  • Expropriation and pre-emption litigation.

Further reading: our legal insights

Read our lawyers’ analyses of real estate and public domain contractual arrangements:

Examples of our firm’s work

Our pragmatic approach is illustrated by assignments recently entrusted to our lawyers:

  • For a metropolitan authority: Strategic and legal support for the decommissioning and declassification of former industrial brownfield sites as part of a major urban renewal project.
  • For an industrial group: Support in drafting and negotiating a BEA (administrative long-term lease) for the occupation of an industrial site.
  • For a public institution: Setting up a competitive tendering procedure for the operation of commercial premises, and drafting the CODPs.

Frequently asked questions on public property

Can a trader claim a business (fonds de commerce) on public property?

Historically, case law prohibited it. Since the Pinel Law of 2014, it has been possible to create a business (fonds de commerce) on public property under certain strict conditions, in particular the express agreement of the public body that owns the property.

What is the right of retrocession?

If the local authority wishes to change the purpose or use of the property within 5 years of its acquisition, it must inform the former owner and offer them priority to acquire it. If the former owner declines, the local authority must inform the ousted prospective buyer named in the declaration of intention to sell (déclaration d'intention d'aliéner), and offer them priority to acquire the property.

What is the right to compel purchase (droit de délaissement)?

The right to compel purchase (droit de délaissement) is the right given to the owner of a property subject to a public utility easement (a reserved site in the local urban plan or PLU, an expropriation zone) to require the public authority to purchase the property. This right enables the owner to escape a deadlock caused by the public constraint weighing on their property. The authority then has one year in which to decide on the acquisition.

What is the public domain and what are its legal characteristics?

The public domain comprises all property belonging to a public entity (the State, local authorities, public institutions) and allocated to direct public use or to a public service. Its main characteristics are inalienability (it can only be sold after declassification) and imprescriptibility (it cannot be acquired by prescription). Private use of the public domain requires an occupancy permit (temporary occupation authorisation, concession).

What is expropriation in the public interest?

Expropriation is the procedure whereby the State or a public authority can compel an owner to transfer their real property for the purposes of a public interest project (transport infrastructure, public facilities, etc.). It takes place in two phases: the administrative phase (declaration of public utility and transferability order) and the judicial phase (expropriation order and determination of compensation by the expropriation judge). The compensation must cover all direct, material and certain loss caused by the expropriation.

Is competitive tendering always mandatory for occupying the public domain?

No. Although the 2017 Ordinance introduced a principle of prior advertising and competitive selection for economic occupations, there are exemptions (emergencies, particular characteristics of the project, short extensions).

Can the public authority terminate a temporary occupation authorisation (AOT) before it expires?

Yes, the public entity always has a right of unilateral termination on grounds of public interest. However, such termination generally entitles you to compensation. NOVLAW will assist you in negotiating and quantifying your loss.

What is the right of pre-emption?

The right of pre-emption is the power given to a local authority (or to a dedicated body) to acquire, as a priority and within certain previously defined areas, property being disposed of, with a view to carrying out operations in the public interest.

How can the public domain be occupied for private use?

Private occupation of the public domain requires an occupancy permit issued by the public body that manages the domain. This permit may take the form of a temporary occupation authorisation (AOT), a precarious occupancy agreement or a concession of use. In return, the occupier must pay a public domain fee. The permit is, in principle, precarious and revocable, unless specific contractual commitments provide for compensation in the event of early withdrawal.

How can a fee for occupation of the public domain be challenged?

If you consider that the fee is disproportionate to the benefits it provides, it is possible to lodge a request for reconsideration (recours gracieux), then to bring the matter before the competent administrative court. A lawyer can help you check the method used by the administration to calculate the occupation fee (fixed part, variable part).

How can you avoid being locked in to your provider on a digital twin?

Reversibility must be prepared at the specification stage, never at the end of the contract. Four levers should be activated: requiring open, interoperable formats rather than a proprietary format; the documented provision of APIs and data schemas; a detailed reversibility clause setting out the timetable, format and cost of returning the data, as well as support for the incoming provider; and, where appropriate, escrow of the source code. The CCAG-TIC (general administrative terms and conditions for IT and communication contracts) provides a useful framework, provided it is supplemented by provisions specific to the operation.

How can a pre-emption decision be challenged?

The owner and the ousted buyer may attempt to challenge the pre-emption decision. Before bringing litigation, it is possible to lodge a prior informal appeal (recours gracieux) with the holder of the pre-emption right within 2 months of notification of the decision. If the informal appeal is rejected by the holder, a contentious appeal must then be lodged with the administrative court within 2 months.

Vue du Vieux-Port de Marseille avec la cathédrale et le fort Saint-Jean sous un ciel bleu clair.

Contact our public domain and public real estate law experts

Whether you are a public authority seeking to optimise the management of its assets or a company wishing to set up on the public domain, NOVLAW Avocats puts its expertise at your service.