


Maître Laurent Bidault and Maître Maïté Cano, partners specialising in public business law.
The organisation and management of local public services lie at the heart of public action in France. Given the demand for performance, the imperatives of the ecological transition and of energy, industrial and digital sovereignty, and budgetary constraints, choosing the right management model is a major strategic issue.
NOVLAW Avocats supports its clients — local authorities, public operators and private companies — on all issues relating to the creation, delegation and performance of public services.
What is a public service delegation (DSP)?
A public service delegation (Délégation de Service Public, which falls within the category of concession contracts) is a contract by which a public body entrusts the management of a public service for which it is responsible to a public or private operator.
The key feature of a DSP lies in how the operator is paid. Unlike a public contract, where the company receives a fixed price from the authority, in a DSP the operator’s remuneration is substantially linked to the results of operating the service. This means that the operator bears the operating risk (user demand risk, commercial risk or technical risk).
{{cta-inject-1}}
We assist local authorities and delegating authorities in designing the legal engineering best suited to their legal, economic and political objectives:
NOVLAW Avocats acts at every stage of the life cycle of public service concession contracts and DSPs, in particular as legal project management assistant (AMO), and also advises the economic operators to which services are delegated:
Managing network infrastructure requires highly specialised legal engineering.
Maître Laurent Bidault and Maître Maïté Cano have developed strong expertise in supporting public and private stakeholders in these highly technical sectors:
Water and sanitation
The water cycle is subject to constant legislative change (NOTRe Act, transfers of powers).
We can assist you, for example, with:
Public transport and mobility
Mobility is a sector undergoing major regulatory and technological change for Mobility Organising Authorities (AOM) and operators:
Digital and telecommunications infrastructure
Developing connected territories and bridging the digital divide depend on key infrastructure. We support local authorities and operators, for example, with:
Other network activities (waste, energy, heating)
In the event of a dispute, NOVLAW AVOCATS defends your interests pragmatically before the administrative courts:
Managing a network-based public service often involves major infrastructure issues.
Discover our complementary areas of expertise:
Yes, but... provided that the requirement is justified by the subject matter of the contract and proportionate. Article 31 of the SREN Law requires the use of qualified cloud solutions where the data processed are sensitive and their compromise would be likely to undermine public order or public security. The Prime Minister's circular No. 6519/SG of 5 February 2026 on digital public procurement goes further, requiring central government buyers to apply a grid of nine decision criteria, explicitly including digital sovereignty and security. In practice, these requirements come into play at the application stage (SecNumCloud 3.2 qualification or equivalent measures, absence of non-European control), at the tender evaluation stage (security and data location criteria) and in the contract (audit, reversibility, termination in the event of a change of control). The drafting must remain compatible with European competition law and the principle of non-discrimination: be careful, this is where the legal certainty of the contract is won or lost.
This is one of the most common blind spots in AI contracts. In the absence of an express provision, the software vendor may argue that it remains the owner of the model retrained with the authority's data, and freely reuse the performance gains obtained thanks to the public service for the benefit of its other clients, sometimes competitors of the local authority. The CCAP (special administrative clauses) must therefore deal separately with three items: the data supplied by the buyer, the data generated during performance of the contract (annotations, corrections, feedback from staff) and the model parameters resulting from training. The CCAG (general administrative clauses) also provides for clauses to this effect. Reuse of public data for other purposes should be prohibited or strictly controlled, the fate of training datasets at the end of the contract should be provided for, and these provisions should be reconciled with the obligations to publish essential contract data, trade secrets and the GDPR.
In France, the management of public drinking water and sanitation services falls within the competence of municipalities or their groupings (EPCI). These authorities may run the service directly in-house (régie) or delegate it to a private operator through a public service delegation (DSP). Since the NOTRe Law of 2015, the transfer of these competences to communities of municipalities (communautés de communes) and urban communities (communautés d'agglomération) has been mandatory.
Public service in France rests on three fundamental principles: continuity (the service must operate without interruption), equality (all users must be treated equally in comparable situations) and mutability or adaptability (the service must evolve in line with the needs of the community and technical progress). In addition to these three 'Rolland's laws', there are the principles of neutrality and secularism (laïcité), as well as accessibility for people with disabilities.
Yes, provided that it strictly meets the in-house criteria laid down in Articles L. 2511-1 et seq. of the French Public Procurement Code for contracts, and L. 3211-1 for concessions: the local authority must exercise over the company a control similar to that which it exercises over its own departments, the company must carry out more than 80% of its activity for its public shareholders, and its capital must not include any direct private participation. Similar control is the criterion most often undermined: a minority shareholder without effective representation on the decision-making bodies does not exercise it. A second point of vigilance is the corporate purpose: in 2018 the Conseil d'État held that a local authority could not hold shares in an SPL whose corporate purpose exceeded its own competences, before Law No. 2019-463 of 17 May 2019 relaxed the rule by requiring only one competence in common. For a cross-cutting project — roads, energy, water, waste, digital — the drafting of the corporate purpose and the make-up of the shareholding deserve a prior audit.
Under a public contract, the operator is paid a fixed price by the public authority and bears no risk in relation to the operation of the service. The distinction therefore lies mainly in the method of remuneration and the transfer of economic risk.
An SPL allows local authorities to entrust the management of a public service to a public limited company in which they hold all the share capital, without having to put it out to competition with the private sector (the “in-house” principle, or quasi-régie). It is a powerful tool for network-based activities or urban development.
A public service delegation (DSP) is a service concession contract for the performance of a public service (transport, water, sanitation, waste). The delegatee operates the service at its own risk, bearing an operating risk, unlike under a public contract.
An energy distribution concession is a contract whereby a granting authority (a municipality or an energy syndicate) delegates to an operator (Enedis for electricity, GRTgaz for gas) the management and operation of the distribution networks. These concessions are governed by the French Energy Code and are subject to standard specifications laid down by decree. They generally run for 30 years, and the granting authority is responsible for supervising the concessionaire.
An industrial and commercial public service (Service Public Industriel et Commercial, SPIC) is a public service managed using methods similar to those of the private sector and financed mainly by charges paid by its users (water, transport, waste management). By contrast, an administrative public service (Service Public Administratif, SPA) is financed mainly through taxation and is entirely governed by public law. The distinction is important: disputes relating to SPICs fall in principle within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts, whereas those concerning SPAs fall within that of the administrative court.
No, local authorities are free to choose how they manage these services. While several municipalities are opting to return to direct public management for political reasons and to control costs, delegated management (DSP) remains a very widespread and entirely lawful model for benefiting from the technical expertise of the major private water operators.
A local authority may be held liable before the administrative court for fault in the exercise of its powers (mismanagement of public property, unlawful issuance of a building permit, failure to maintain roads, etc.). The victim must establish fault, loss and a causal link between the two. A prior formal notice is sometimes necessary before bringing legal proceedings.
In the event of a disagreement over a water bill, the subscriber must first contact their operator's customer service and ask for the meter to be checked. If the dispute persists, they may refer the matter to the water mediator or, for services run directly by the municipality (régie), to the mayor and then to the administrative court. To challenge an administrative decision (refusal of connection, excessive charges), a prior request for reconsideration (recours gracieux) is recommended before bringing any legal action.
Nothing prohibits it in principle, but three limits apply. Confidentiality, first: Article L. 2132-1 of the French Public Procurement Code (code de la commande publique) prohibits the buyer from disclosing confidential information submitted by candidates. Uploading technical proposals to a consumer generative AI tool whose terms of use allow inputs to be reused therefore exposes the buyer to a clear breach of trade secrets: this is the central risk of shadow AI in purchasing departments. Second, the principles of public procurement: freedom of access, equal treatment and transparency require the buyer to retain control over, and understanding of, the tool it uses, and to ensure that algorithmic pre-screening does not systematically disadvantage certain types of operator. Finally, the decision must remain a human one: AI-assisted analysis cannot on its own constitute the choice of the successful tenderer, and the rejection of a tender must remain reasoned and explainable before the court. Drafting an internal policy on the use of AI can be the first step towards securing the process.
Reversibility must be prepared at the specification stage, never at the end of the contract. Four levers should be activated: requiring open, interoperable formats rather than a proprietary format; the documented provision of APIs and data schemas; a detailed reversibility clause setting out the timetable, format and cost of returning the data, as well as support for the incoming provider; and, where appropriate, escrow of the source code. The CCAG-TIC (general administrative terms and conditions for IT and communication contracts) provides a useful framework, provided it is supplemented by provisions specific to the operation.
The SEMOP (single-purpose semi-public company) has one decisive feature: a single competitive procedure covers both the selection of the economic operator shareholder and the award of the contract, whether a public contract, a concession or a public service delegation. The contract notice must therefore describe at the same time the subject matter of the contract, the draft articles of association and the shareholders' agreement. The local authority holds between 34% and 85% of the capital, the operator at least 15%, and the company may not carry on any activity other than that of the single contract concluded with its public shareholder. The arrangement works well for a clearly defined connected urban service — a charging network, smart water management, connected street lighting. As the constitutional documents are produced before the partner is chosen, any imprecision regarding governance, qualified majorities or exit clauses comes at a cost throughout the life of the contract.
The three semi-public vehicles follow distinct rationales. The local semi-public company (SEM, Articles L. 1521-1 et seq. of the General Local Authorities Code, CGCT) brings together public shareholders, holding between 50% and 85% of the capital, and at least one private shareholder, with a minimum of seven shareholders: as a private-law operator, it must go through a competitive procedure to be awarded a contract. The local public company (SPL, Article L. 1531-1 of the CGCT), wholly owned by at least two local authorities, can by contrast be awarded contracts without advertising or competitive tendering under the in-house (quasi-régie) conditions. The SEMOP (Articles L. 1541-1 et seq. of the CGCT) is a single-contract company, automatically dissolved when that contract ends. For a smart city: the SPL for a long-term data infrastructure steered by the public sector, the SEMOP for a specific service requiring the input of an industrial partner, and the SEM for long-term, multi-project equity backing.
Yes. Article R. 3125-2 of the Public Procurement Code requires sixteen days between the sending of the rejection notification and the conclusion of the concession contract, reduced to eleven days where it is sent electronically to all interested candidates. An unsuccessful candidate for a concession or a public service delegation therefore has the same window in which to apply to the court for pre-contractual interim relief.

Whether you are a local authority reviewing your options for a management model or a private operator preparing a bid for a complex DSP, NOVLAW secures your projects.