


NOVLAW Avocats assists its clients in all disputes between policyholders and insurers. We defend our clients before all courts throughout France and help resolve disputes concerning:
• Compensation issues: assessment of the loss and determination of insurance payouts;
• Management of technical claims: damage assessment and the involvement of experts;
• Litigation: we pursue remedies and compensation proceedings on behalf of our clients in all sectors, particularly in construction and building works.
We can act before a dispute arises, during negotiations or to defend our clients in court.
The most common disputes we handle include:
• Disputes over an insurer’s refusal to provide cover under the policy;
• Disputes over a refusal to pay compensation or insufficient compensation;
• Litigation concerning false statements made by the policyholder when taking out the policy;
• Issues relating to the general and/or special conditions of the insurance policy;
• Wrongful termination of the insurance policy;
• Problems concerning an accident report form (constat amiable);
• Negotiation and renegotiation of insurance policies.
{{cta-inject-1}}
There is no compulsory BIM policy, but standard policies do not always cover the risks specific to the process: the BIM management role, loss or corruption of the model, damage to data hosted on the collaborative platform, infringement of intellectual property rights. Checks on insurance certificates should therefore focus on three points: the effective insurability of the contractor's BIM role, the existence of professional liability cover for non-consequential intangible loss, and cyber cover for the common data environment.
No, not as such. The ten-year guarantee under Article 1792 of the Civil Code covers damage affecting a construction work that compromises its soundness or renders it unfit for its intended purpose: a digital model is not a construction work, and a mere modelling inconsistency with no physical manifestation does not fall within this regime. On the other hand, a design error revealed by the model and materialised in the completed building falls squarely within the builders' statutory guarantees. The model therefore changes not so much the liability regime as the way in which the defect and the party responsible for it are proven.
Subrogation is the mechanism whereby the insurer, having compensated its policyholder, is substituted for the policyholder in their rights and actions against the party responsible for the damage. In practice, after paying the indemnity, the insurer can bring a recourse action against the liable third party or that party's insurer to recover the sums paid. The policyholder must not do anything that might compromise this subrogated recourse, failing which they may lose all or part of their compensation.
The ten-year guarantee (garantie décennale) is a statutory liability borne by every builder (contractor, architect, project manager) for 10 years from acceptance of the works. It covers damage that compromises the structural integrity of the building or renders it unfit for its intended purpose (serious cracks, water ingress, collapses). To invoke it, the project owner must send the builder concerned a formal notice by registered letter describing the defects, then bring proceedings before the judicial or administrative court if the builder does not comply with the request.
In insurance matters, legal action against an insurer is time-barred 2 years after the event giving rise to it. If a claim is refused, it is advisable first to send a written complaint to the insurer and then to refer the matter to the insurance ombudsman before bringing court proceedings. The two-year limitation period is mandatory: once it has expired, any action is inadmissible.
Decennial insurance is compulsory civil liability insurance for any builder (contractor, architect, project manager, engineering consultancy) involved in a construction project. For 10 years from acceptance of the works, it covers damage that compromises the structural soundness of the building or renders it unfit for its intended purpose. It must be taken out before work starts on site, failing which criminal penalties apply.

Insurance law: disputes, refusals to pay compensation, insurance cover. Assert your rights and obtain compensation suited to your situation.