HomePublic
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Public law

Administrative mediation: resolving your disputes amicably

Deux personnes se serrant la main au-dessus d'une surface en bois, signe d'accord ou de salutation.
Contents
Our specialists
Maïté Cano
Maïté Cano

Strategic summary: Given the complexity of administrative litigation, mediation offers an alternative to going to court. It combines the legal certainty of a solution negotiated between the parties with the flexibility of an amicable process, protecting the interests of your organisation.

Why choose administrative mediation for your disputes?

Whether you are a local authority or a business, going before the administrative courts often means lengthy proceedings (2 to 3 years on average) and the uncertainties of litigation.

Administrative mediation allows you to regain control over the outcome of the dispute. It is particularly effective in the following areas:

  • Public contracts and concessions: settlement of final statements of account (DGD) or performance disputes (unforeseen difficulties, additional works, delay penalties, etc.).
  • Planning and development: disputes relating to building permits.
  • Civil service: handling disputes between public employees and/or their line management.
  • Administrative liability: settlement of compensation for losses

How is mediation set up?

Mediation can be initiated at any time:

  1. Out-of-court (conventional) mediation: before any legal action, to avoid going to court.
  2. Court-ordered (judicial) mediation: at the initiative of the judge or the parties, either before proceedings begin or while they are already under way.

What is administrative mediation?

Administrative mediation is an alternative dispute resolution (ADR) method for resolving a dispute between a member of the public (individual or business) and a public body. Under the guidance of a neutral and independent mediator, the parties work together to find a negotiated solution without waiting for a court decision.

Why choose mediation?

Mediation offers strategic advantages that conventional litigation cannot provide:

  • Control over timing: mediation generally lasts between 3 and 6 months, whereas a case before an administrative court can take between 16 and 24 months.
  • Confidentiality: the discussions and the final agreement are confidential. This is a significant advantage for a company's brand image or an elected official's reputation.
  • Control over the outcome: in mediation, the solution is found by the parties, who build an agreement tailored to their dispute.
  • Freedom to take part: the parties are free to take part in mediation or to withdraw from the process.
  • Legal certainty: the mediation agreement can be approved by the court.
  • Protection of your interests: mediation interrupts the time limits for bringing legal proceedings. If mediation fails, the parties can pursue the dispute before the court.

The tangible benefits for decision-makers

Timescales

  • Conventional litigation: several years
  • Administrative mediation: a few months (often less than 6 months)

Cost

  • Conventional litigation: expert costs and high legal fees
  • Administrative mediation: controlled, shared costs

Outcome

  • Conventional litigation: an imposed decision, with a winner and a loser
  • Administrative mediation: a solution chosen by the parties, in a win-win approach

Relationship

  • Conventional litigation: permanent breakdown of the relationship
  • Administrative mediation: future partnerships preserved

‍

How our firm can help:

Our lawyers can assist you throughout the out-of-court or court-ordered mediation process.

Administrative mediation cannot be improvised. Our firm's involvement ensures the lawfulness of the settlement (compliance with public policy and the prohibition on gratuitous payments by public bodies).

  1. Risk assessment: we analyse your chances of success in court in order to define a coherent negotiation strategy.
  2. Support during mediation: we attend mediation meetings with you and assist you in negotiating the agreement.
  3. Support in negotiating an agreement: translating your concerns into legal solutions and assessing the lawfulness of the solution reached by the parties.
  4. Drafting the agreement: we formalise the mediation agreement or settlement agreement and, where necessary, apply for its approval by the administrative court to make it enforceable.

Our partner Maître Maïté CANO can also act as a mediator in a dispute.

A graduate of the Institut de Formation à la Médiation et à la Négociation (IFOMENE) at the ICP in Paris, she acts as a mediator in administrative disputes, appointed by the administrative court or by the parties.

She is also one of the founding members of the Association des Médiateurs Administratifs (AMA), whose purpose is to promote administrative mediation.

In this role, she acts with complete impartiality and neutrality to:

  • Restore dialogue between the parties.
  • Structure discussions and guarantee confidentiality.
  • Help a mutually acceptable solution to emerge, with complete impartiality.

Expertise & Contact

Led by Maître Maïté CANO, our firm has developed an outstanding practice in alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Our approach combines the rigour of public law with principled negotiation techniques.

Frequently asked questions on mediation

What is the effect on time limits for bringing a claim?

Initiating mediation interrupts the time limits for bringing legal proceedings and suspends limitation periods. This makes it possible to preserve one's rights if the mediation fails.

What is mediation and how does it differ from going to court?

Mediation is an amicable method of dispute resolution in which a neutral and impartial third party, the mediator, helps the parties to find a solution to their dispute themselves. Unlike a judge, the mediator does not impose a decision: it is for the parties to reach an agreement. Mediation is quicker, less expensive and more confidential than court proceedings. An agreement reached through mediation can be approved by the court so as to give it the same enforceability as a judgment.

Is mediation mandatory before bringing certain legal actions?

Yes, in certain cases an attempt at amicable settlement is mandatory before bringing a case before the court. Since the decree of 11 December 2019, an attempt at conciliation, mediation or a participatory procedure has in principle been mandatory for disputes of less than €5,000 before the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire). In administrative law, a mandatory prior administrative appeal (RAPO) is required in certain types of dispute before any application to the administrative court.

Is the public administration allowed to settle disputes?

Yes. Article L. 213-1 of the French Code of Administrative Justice expressly authorises the use of mediation for disputes falling within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts.

Is a mediation agreement final?

A mediation agreement may take the form of a settlement agreement (protocole transactionnel) which, once signed and, where applicable, approved by the court, has the force of res judicata between the parties and brings the dispute to a definitive end. A mediation agreement is not necessarily a settlement agreement.

How does court-ordered mediation work?

Court-ordered mediation is ordered by the judge during court proceedings, with the parties' consent. The judge appoints a mediator and sets the duration of the assignment (generally 3 months, renewable). Mediation sessions take place outside the court, in a confidential setting. If the parties reach an agreement, it is submitted to the judge for approval. If no agreement is reached, the court proceedings resume their normal course.

Deux personnes se serrant la main au-dessus d'une surface en bois, signe d'accord ou de salutation.

A project or a dispute? Contact us

Every situation deserves a clear, pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.