

The digitalisation of the construction sector and the emergence of smart territories are profoundly transforming the practices of project owners, project managers and contractors. The move to digital modelling (BIM) and digital twins raises major legal challenges at the crossroads of construction law, public procurement and intellectual property.
NOVLAW Avocats is a pioneer in providing legal support for this digital transition. We secure your projects to guarantee control over your data, clarify responsibilities and structure your public design-and-build contracts.
A BIM project or the creation of a digital twin is not merely a technical (software) challenge. Above all, these are collaborative processes that require rigorous contractual engineering (drafting a BIM agreement, intellectual property clauses, allocation of liability in the event of errors in the model).
The NF ISO 19650 standard defines BIM (building information modelling) as the use of a shared digital representation of a built asset to facilitate design, construction and operation processes and to form a reliable basis for decision-making.
It is not a particular digital tool or application; it is a collaborative process in which the various parties involved in a construction project (project owner, project management assistant, project manager, contractors, inspection body) work together to design, build and even operate a structure around a digital model.
BIM is therefore a collaborative and evolving process throughout the design, construction and/or operation of a structure.
It results in a digital model providing a three-dimensional representation of the structure, incorporating the technical information and data supplied by each party during the construction project.
The digital model is developed and refined during the design phase of the structure; it then serves as a reference during the construction phase and is fed and supplemented with the construction project data provided by the various parties involved.
The digital model of the structure is particularly essential during the operation phase: the project owner or operator then has a simplified, immediate representation of all the data relating to the structure.
{{cta-inject-1}}
While BIM applies to a single building or infrastructure, the collaborative approach now extends to much larger scales:
NOVLAW assists you in structuring the data-sharing agreements and global contracts needed to deploy these territorial models.
A digital twin is a virtual, evolving and dynamic replica of a facility or territory, fed in real time by data from the field (IoT sensors, smart meters, traffic).
As a genuine decision-support tool (crisis simulation, energy optimisation), the creation of a digital twin raises complex sovereignty issues:
NOVLAW is at the heart of legal scholarship on BIM. Maître Laurent Bidault is the author of the reference work Le droit de la construction publique en BIM (public construction law and BIM), published on 24 November 2021 by Éditions Le Moniteur.

This book is both legal and practical, covering all the issues raised by a BIM project and including sample contract clauses, lessons learned and testimonials. It is a genuine “guide” both for adopting a BIM approach and for managing a BIM project, whether at the programming, design, construction or operation stage of a structure (building, infrastructure, etc.).
NOVLAW Avocats advises its clients (project owners, project managers, engineering firms, consultancies, contractors) on all the legal questions and issues raised by BIM:
The two regimes overlap. The original elements modelled are protected by copyright, and the model may be classified as a work of collaboration where several contributors have taken part in it, with the consequence that it must be exploited by common agreement between the co-authors. At the same time, the model constitutes a structured database: anyone who has made a substantial investment in its creation or verification may rely on the producer's sui generis right, which protects against the extraction or reuse of a substantial part of the contents, regardless of any originality. Contractual clauses should expressly refer to both legal bases.
Only within the limits of the rights assigned to it. The model incorporates creations protected by copyright, the rights to which remain with their authors unless otherwise agreed. However, the assignment granted for the purposes of construction does not necessarily cover operation and maintenance, modification of the building or feeding a digital twin. In a public contract, although the CCAG determines the scope of these rights, they need to be specified and adapted in the contract documents. It is therefore essential to list, from the tender stage, the subsequent uses envisaged: facility management and maintenance, extension, sale of the asset, open data.
There is no compulsory BIM policy, but standard policies do not always cover the risks specific to the process: the BIM management role, loss or corruption of the model, damage to data hosted on the collaborative platform, infringement of intellectual property rights. Checks on insurance certificates should therefore focus on three points: the effective insurability of the contractor's BIM role, the existence of professional liability cover for non-consequential intangible loss, and cyber cover for the common data environment.
No, not as such. The ten-year guarantee under Article 1792 of the Civil Code covers damage affecting a construction work that compromises its soundness or renders it unfit for its intended purpose: a digital model is not a construction work, and a mere modelling inconsistency with no physical manifestation does not fall within this regime. On the other hand, a design error revealed by the model and materialised in the completed building falls squarely within the builders' statutory guarantees. The model therefore changes not so much the liability regime as the way in which the defect and the party responsible for it are proven.
Frequently, yes, and the two approaches must be reconciled. Where sensors, meters or counting devices make it possible to re-identify individuals (consumption at household level, journeys, images), the GDPR applies and requires an impact assessment, data minimisation and aggregation. At the same time, the data produced by the local authority constitute administrative documents that may be subject to online publication obligations. The practical challenge is therefore to define contractually, at the outset, which data may be disseminated, at what level of granularity, and which are covered by the operator's trade secrets.
It is in fact particularly well suited to them: having a single contractor simplifies the governance of the model and the chain of responsibility. Three points require contractual vigilance. First, the definition of the need must describe the expected BIM uses without locking in the technical solution, otherwise competition may be restricted. Second, as the model serves as the basis for performance commitments, its deliverables must be aligned with the performance objectives of the global contract. Finally, the allocation of rights over the data must be set from the tender stage, since all output is concentrated with a single operator.
These three documents follow one another in time and do not have the same scope. The BIM charter is a strategic document internal to the project owner: it sets out its ambitions, use cases and digital organisation, before any specific project. The BIM specifications translate these requirements into a given project and form part of the tender file. Finally, the BIM agreement is drawn up by the selected contributors to organise their collaboration in practice; it evolves at each stage of the project life cycle. In practice, only the last two are intended to become contractual.
The question of ownership of the BIM digital model is complex because French law does not yet fully regulate it. In principle, the digital model may be classified as a work of collaboration protected by copyright, which means that all contributors (lead designer, engineering firms, contractors) may claim rights over the data they have produced. It is therefore essential to specify contractually, in the BIM agreement or BIM protocol, the rights of each contributor over the model and its data.
To secure a BIM project in private real estate, it is advisable to put in place: a BIM agreement signed by all contributors, specifying roles, the expected levels of development (LOD/LOG) and the uses of the model; a technical BIM protocol describing the software, file formats and exchange arrangements; and specific clauses in the design team (maîtrise d'œuvre) and contractor agreements setting out the conditions for delivery, use and ownership of the digital data.
A BIM model is generally static: it represents the “as-built” state of the construction. A digital twin goes further: it is dynamic and connected to reality in real time (via sensors) in order to model the live behaviour of the building or city (temperature, user flows, wear of materials).
In the event of a BIM-related dispute on a real estate project, the first step is to identify the party responsible for the error on the basis of the signed BIM agreement and BIM protocol. If these documents are inadequate or absent, the ordinary rules of contractual liability apply. A court-appointed expert assessment may be needed to reconstruct the process by which the model was produced. It is advisable to call on a specialist lawyer at the first signs of disagreement in order to preserve evidence and organise the litigation strategy.
Reversibility must be prepared at the specification stage, never at the end of the contract. Four levers should be activated: requiring open, interoperable formats rather than a proprietary format; the documented provision of APIs and data schemas; a detailed reversibility clause setting out the timetable, format and cost of returning the data, as well as support for the incoming provider; and, where appropriate, escrow of the source code. The CCAG-TIC (general administrative terms and conditions for IT and communication contracts) provides a useful framework, provided it is supplemented by provisions specific to the operation.
The model itself bears no liability: liability always attaches to the party that produced, validated or misused the incorrect data. The most common scenario is incorrect data — an incorrectly sized duct, for example — incorporated into the shared model and then used during construction, resulting in remedial work and a delay on site. The BIM agreement is decisive here, as it identifies the author of each object, the expected level of information and the validation channels. Without such traceability, the dispute is settled under the ordinary rules of contractual liability, with the risk of liability being diluted between the project manager (maître d'œuvre), design consultants, contractors and the BIM manager, and of a lengthy court-appointed expert assessment to reconstruct the model's production chain. A lack of interoperability between the tools used by the various parties can also lead to liability being shared.
A BIM manager has no legal status: their liability depends entirely on the content of their assignment. If they merely provide methodological assistance to the project owner, their liability is contractual and generally involves an obligation of means (best-efforts obligation). If, on the other hand, they are involved in the design or technical choices for the building, whether they qualify as a contractor (locateur d'ouvrage) within the meaning of Article 1792-1 of the Civil Code, and therefore whether the statutory guarantees apply, becomes debatable. Hence the importance of precisely defining their assignment, their contractual position and the extent of their insurance cover before the project begins.
Yes, to a certain extent... Article R. 2132-10 of the Public Procurement Code (code de la commande publique) allows the buyer to require the use of electronic building information modelling tools. However, this option comes with a counterpart: as long as these tools are not generally available, the buyer must offer alternative means of access, so as not to restrict access to public procurement. In practice, the BIM requirement is reflected in the consultation rules, the BIM specifications and the award criteria, the wording of which must remain proportionate to the subject matter of the contract.
At present, BIM is not yet mandatory for all construction projects in France. However, it is increasingly encouraged, and required by certain public project owners, particularly in project management (maîtrise d'œuvre) or works contracts. The RE2020 environmental regulations and building energy performance targets are also pushing stakeholders to adopt digital tools such as BIM.
Yes, where the contract's specific documents so provide. The 2021 general administrative terms and conditions (CCAG) for works and for project management define the BIM specifications, the BIM component of the project owner's brief, and the BIM agreement, which describes the organisation, roles and data exchange arrangements. Their place in the hierarchy of contract documents differs: under the CCAG for works, the BIM specifications rank after the contractor's technical offer, whereas under the CCAG for project management they rank higher. This order of priority, which may be departed from, determines the applicable rule in the event of a conflict between documents.

Whether you are a public buyer seeking to require BIM in a global contract, or a tech company structuring a territorial digital twin, NOVLAW protects your interests.