HomeReal estate
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Real estate

Construction Dispute? Defend Your Rights and Obtain Compensation

Quatre ouvriers en gilets réfléchissants et casques étudient des plans et un ordinateur sur une table en bois.
Contents
Our specialists in
Construction Law
Maïté Cano
Maïté Cano
Laurent Bidault
Laurent Bidault

What is construction law?

Construction law covers all the legal rules governing every stage in the creation of a building or structure, from design to handover, as well as the liabilities of the various parties involved. It is a branch of private law, attached to civil law and more specifically to real estate law.

Construction law is divided into two main branches:

Private construction law:

It governs relations between the various private parties involved in a construction project: the project owner (owner, developer), the project manager (architect, engineering firm) and construction companies.

It covers in particular the drafting and performance of contracts (project management contracts, works contracts, off-plan sales (VEFA), building leases, BEFA, emphyteutic leases, property development contracts), builders’ liability for defects or delays, construction insurance, etc.

Public construction law:

It covers planning rules and the administrative authorisations required to build (building permits, prior declarations of works, planning certificates).

It also deals with building safety, health and accessibility rules.

Finally, and above all, it covers contracts, in particular public works contracts.

What does a construction lawyer do?

A lawyer specialising in construction law plays a crucial role in supporting clients and defending their interests throughout a construction project, whether at the planning stage, during the works or after handover.

The lawyer’s work may include the following:

Legal advice and assistance for a successful project:

  • Before construction: We advise on the project’s feasibility (analysis of planning rules, building permits, obtaining administrative authorisations), contract drafting (project management contracts, works contracts, public contracts), compulsory insurance, etc.
  • During construction: We assist our clients (project owners, project managers, architects, contractors, insurers) in monitoring the works, handling any disputes with contractors, contract changes and abandoned building sites.
  • After construction: We step in where there are defects, losses, disputes relating to statutory warranties (completion warranty, two-year warranty, ten-year warranty) or disputes over additional services and works (statement of claim).

Representing and defending your interests:

  • Amicable negotiation: Before any litigation, we always seek amicable solutions to disputes with other construction stakeholders (contractors, architects, etc.).
  • Construction litigation: disputes relating to defects, delays, non-conformities and the liability of the various parties.
  • Planning litigation: challenges to building permits and refusals of authorisation.
  • Public procurement litigation: disputes relating to the award, performance or termination of public contracts.
  • Expert assessment proceedings: appointment of court experts to assess damage or defects, and support during the expert assessment.

Expertise and drafting of documents:

  • Drafting documents: We assist our clients in drafting contracts, formal notices, writs of summons, etc.
  • Project owner assistance: supporting the project owner in defining its needs, selecting contractors and consultants, managing the project, etc.

‍

{{cta-inject-1}}

Before construction: protect your interests with a pre-works survey application (référé préventif)

Construction works can cause damage, typically in the form of cosmetic defects, equipment malfunctions or defects affecting structures more broadly, including those of neighbouring buildings. Let NOVLAW Avocats assist you with a référé préventif to protect yourself against such damage.

The référé préventif is a procedure that allows project owners to anticipate the consequences of damage that construction works may cause to neighbouring buildings, and to protect themselves against unfounded compensation claims that might be brought against them.

The référé préventif is brought before the tribunal judiciaire (civil court) before the works begin. The President of the court is asked, in summary proceedings, to appoint a court expert who will visit the project site to record the condition of the site and of the buildings neighbouring the future works. The record of condition drawn up by the expert will help you avoid any dispute over the prior condition of neighbouring buildings once the works are completed. The court expert may also recommend any protective and preventive measures needed to prevent damage that the planned works might cause.

Pay particular attention to drafting your contractors’ and subcontractors’ contracts

A construction project is a large-scale undertaking requiring the involvement of several contractors and subcontractors. The parties involved are professionals from various building trades.

The most common are the project manager, architects, construction companies and various technical specialists.

A subcontractor, for its part, is a contractor to which a main contractor entrusts all or part of the works it was due to carry out.

To secure your works and ensure a good working relationship with your contractors and subcontractors, it is essential that construction processes, deadlines, the tasks of the various contractors and subcontractors and their responsibilities be set out in contracts drafted by a professional before the construction project begins.

To this end, NOVLAW Avocats draws on its expertise to help you draft your contractors’ and subcontractors’ contracts, taking your situation into account and protecting your interests as fully as possible.

We apply the rigorous contractual engineering needed to protect your projects.

Take care at the acceptance of works

In construction law, acceptance of works (réception) is the process by which the project owner accepts, with or without reservations, the works carried out by the contractor and the works companies.

It must result from the project owner’s unequivocal intention to accept the works.

Acceptance of the works brings the construction contract between the project owner and the builder to an end, and marks the starting point of all the statutory warranties available to the project owner.

Acceptance of the works does not always proceed amicably.

It is often the source of numerous disputes.

To help you avoid disputes or manage them where necessary, we can support you throughout the acceptance process, in particular by attending acceptance meetings with you and supporting you in amicable and contentious proceedings.

Builders’ warranties and liabilities

Several warranties allow builders to be held liable after acceptance of the works. Essentially, the following liabilities can be distinguished:

  • The completion warranty (garantie de parfait achèvement), which allows the project owner to have the builder remedy defects reported at acceptance or within the following year, within one year of the acceptance date.
  • The proper functioning warranty (garantie de bon fonctionnement), which requires builders to guarantee the project owner against hidden defects affecting equipment that can be separated from the structure, such as a hot water tank or shutters, for two years after acceptance.
  • The ten-year (decennial) liability, which allows the builder to be held liable for 10 years after acceptance of the works for any damage that compromises the structure’s soundness or renders it unfit for its intended purpose.

If you notice defects after your building has been handed over, NOVLAW Avocats, with its command of the various construction warranties and the procedures for enforcing them, can assist you in asserting your rights and obtaining compensation for your loss.

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on construction law

Is specific insurance required for a BIM project?

There is no compulsory BIM policy, but standard policies do not always cover the risks specific to the process: the BIM management role, loss or corruption of the model, damage to data hosted on the collaborative platform, infringement of intellectual property rights. Checks on insurance certificates should therefore focus on three points: the effective insurability of the contractor's BIM role, the existence of professional liability cover for non-consequential intangible loss, and cyber cover for the common data environment.

Is the digital model covered by the ten-year builder's guarantee (garantie décennale)?

No, not as such. The ten-year guarantee under Article 1792 of the Civil Code covers damage affecting a construction work that compromises its soundness or renders it unfit for its intended purpose: a digital model is not a construction work, and a mere modelling inconsistency with no physical manifestation does not fall within this regime. On the other hand, a design error revealed by the model and materialised in the completed building falls squarely within the builders' statutory guarantees. The model therefore changes not so much the liability regime as the way in which the defect and the party responsible for it are proven.

What is the liability of the project manager (maître d'œuvre) and when can it be invoked?

The project manager (maître d'œuvre: architect, engineering consultancy) is responsible for the design and supervision of the works. They may be held liable: for 10 years for defects covered by the ten-year guarantee (garantie décennale); for 2 years for defects covered by the two-year guarantee (proper functioning of separable equipment); at any time for design or supervision faults that have caused loss. Bringing a claim against the project manager often requires a prior court-appointed expert assessment to establish liability.

What is the ten-year guarantee (garantie décennale) and how can it be invoked?

The ten-year guarantee (garantie décennale) is a statutory liability borne by every builder (contractor, architect, project manager) for 10 years from acceptance of the works. It covers damage that compromises the structural integrity of the building or renders it unfit for its intended purpose (serious cracks, water ingress, collapses). To invoke it, the project owner must send the builder concerned a formal notice by registered letter describing the defects, then bring proceedings before the judicial or administrative court if the builder does not comply with the request.

What is the completion guarantee (garantie de parfait achèvement) in a public works contract?

The completion guarantee (garantie de parfait achèvement) is a statutory obligation that runs for one year from acceptance of the works. During this period, the contractor is required to remedy all defects reported by the project owner, whether noted at acceptance or having appeared during the following year. This guarantee applies regardless of fault-based liability.

What is an application for a court-appointed expert (référé expertise) in construction matters and when should it be used?

The référé expertise is an urgent court procedure for obtaining the appointment of a court expert to record construction defects, determine their causes and identify who is liable, even before proceedings on the merits are brought. It is advisable to use it as soon as significant defects appear, in particular to preserve evidence and avoid claims becoming time-barred. The court expert's assessment generally serves as the basis for amicable negotiations or subsequent legal action.

What is decennial (ten-year) insurance and who is required to take it out?

Decennial insurance is compulsory civil liability insurance for any builder (contractor, architect, project manager, engineering consultancy) involved in a construction project. For 10 years from acceptance of the works, it covers damage that compromises the structural soundness of the building or renders it unfit for its intended purpose. It must be taken out before work starts on site, failing which criminal penalties apply.

Quatre ouvriers en gilets réfléchissants et casques étudient des plans et un ordinateur sur une table en bois.
Everything you need to know about real estate law

More resources

More resources

No items found.

A project or dispute in construction law?

Construction law: defects, delays, building site disputes. Defend your rights and secure your construction projects effectively.