HomeBusiness law
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Business law

Insolvency proceedings lawyer

Place urbaine avec allée en gravier, bordée de bancs, de topiaires sphériques et de parterres fleuris devant des immeubles haussmanniens au coucher du soleil.
Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin
Baptiste Robelin

Lawyer specialising in insolvency proceedings and the restructuring of businesses in difficulty

From Roman law to the Act of 13 July 1967, the purpose of the law governing businesses in difficulty was to punish the defaulting debtor: it was a law of bankruptcy. The law has evolved considerably since then. Today, the law on businesses in difficulty gives priority to rescuing and restructuring companies. This has given rise to the concepts of anticipation, safeguard, reorganisation and liquidation, which organise insolvency proceedings into out-of-court and court-supervised phases.

Depending on the company’s economic situation, it is now possible to seek an amicable resolution of its difficulties (I), to safeguard a company that is not yet in a state of cessation of payments, i.e. insolvent (II), to place it in judicial reorganisation where it is (III), or to place it in judicial liquidation where its financial position is irretrievably compromised (IV).

Baptiste Robelin, a lawyer specialising in insolvency law, assists businesses in difficulty. Follow our advice on:

Conditions, formalities, procedure: follow our step-by-step advice to guide your company successfully through insolvency proceedings.

Avocat procédures collectives

Amicable resolution of difficulties

Amicable resolution involves the intervention of a third party: an ad hoc agent (mandataire ad hoc) or a conciliator.

The ad hoc mandate: an original procedure for businesses in difficulty

Any business in difficulty whose current assets are sufficient to cover all of its liabilities may apply for an ad hoc mandate.

A business experiencing difficulties without being in a state of cessation of payments may therefore ask the president of the Commercial Court (Tribunal de commerce, for a commercial or craft business) or the president of the Judicial Court (Tribunal judiciaire, in other cases) to appoint an ad hoc agent.

Only the debtor may file this application. The debtor may also propose the name of an agent. However, it is the president of the court who determines the agent’s assignment (which may be legal, economic or financial in nature), its duration and the agent’s fees (in agreement with the debtor). The debtor may not propose a person who has received remuneration from them during the previous 24 months, unless that person acted as an ad hoc agent or as a court-appointed officer other than a plan implementation supervisor (commissaire à l’exécution du plan).

Likewise, the debtor may not propose a serving lay commercial judge, or one who has left office within the last 5 years.

The decision appointing the ad hoc agent is not made public, except for notification to the statutory auditor, if one has been appointed. The debtor is under no obligation to disclose information.

The ad hoc agent is bound by confidentiality and takes an objective approach. The agent’s role is to analyse and assess the debtor’s situation, and to identify and negotiate with creditors in order to obtain a payment schedule, debt write-offs or financial support for the debtor.

Where negotiations fail, the agent invites the debtor to ask the court for a payment period of up to two years.

Strictly speaking, the ad hoc mandate is not an “insolvency proceeding” (procédure collective), but it is an original mechanism for dealing with businesses in difficulty.

Conciliation: a consensual and confidential method for dealing with businesses in difficulty

To open conciliation proceedings, the debtor must be experiencing legal, economic or financial difficulties. These difficulties must be actual or foreseeable, and the debtor must not have been in a state of cessation of payments for more than 45 days. Conciliation proceedings may be brought before the Commercial Court or the Judicial Court, depending on the nature of the debtor’s professional activity, and only the debtor may apply. The court will only grant the application if no conciliation has taken place in the previous 90 days.

The debtor may propose the name of the conciliator under the same conditions as for the ad hoc mandate. Idem for fees.  The conciliator is appointed for a period of 4 months, which may be extended by reasoned decision, provided that the total duration does not exceed 5 months. During this period, the conciliator must carry out their assignment confidentially. Like the ad hoc agent, the conciliator seeks to obtain for the debtor debt write-offs, a payment schedule or refinancing through the sale of certain business lines. In addition, at the debtor’s request, the conciliator may be tasked with preparing a plan for the partial or total sale of the business, with a view to the subsequent opening of insolvency proceedings.

The agreement reached may be either acknowledged or approved by the court.

  • In the first case, the president of the court, on a joint application by the parties, acknowledges their agreement and makes it enforceable, without it being made public. The agreement has the effects the parties give it. It may include specific clauses (such as negative pledges or return-to-better-fortune clauses). The agreement may fail if the debtor falls into cessation of payments or if its clauses are not complied with.
  • In the second case, approval (homologation) of the agreement entails its publication. The application must come from the debtor, who must show not only that they are not in a state of cessation of payments, or that the agreement brings it to an end, but also that the agreement resolves the company’s difficulties without infringing the rights of non-signatory creditors. In fine, the president of the court hears, among others, the conciliator, the creditors and the employee representatives before ruling. The main effect of approval is that, if the conciliation turns into judicial liquidation proceedings, creditors who made concessions are granted priority ranking.

Failure of the agreement may lead to the opening of judicial safeguard proceedings if the company is not in a state of cessation of payments or, where applicable, to the opening of judicial reorganisation or liquidation proceedings.

Here again, conciliation is not strictly speaking an insolvency proceeding: it is an original, consensual and confidential method of dealing with businesses in difficulty. Restructuring practitioners generally use these methods as part of a debt negotiation strategy to clear liabilities.

Baptiste Robelin, a lawyer specialising in insolvency law, assists businesses in difficulty with all amicable procedures: ad hoc mandate and conciliation.

Take advice from a specialist firm and choose an experienced adviser to help you overcome your company’s difficulties and to support you through restructuring and debt negotiation.

Judicial safeguard proceedings for a business in difficulty

Judicial safeguard proceedings are opened at the debtor’s request. They are mainly conditional on the debtor not being in a state of cessation of payments and on the existence of difficulties that the debtor is unable to overcome. The aim is to facilitate the reorganisation of the company so that it can continue its business, preserve jobs and clear its liabilities.

Judicial safeguard proceedings apply to debtors who are natural persons carrying on an independent or liberal professional activity on a regular, lawful and non-occasional basis. They also apply to debtors that are legal entities governed by private law (commercial or civil companies), with the exception of de facto partnerships and public-law entities.

The competent commercial or judicial court is the one with jurisdiction over the debtor’s registered office or business address, in the case of domestic proceedings. Where the proceedings are international (i.e. the debtor has assets in France and in other European Union countries), proceedings are opened in the country where the debtor has its centre of main interests.

Before delivering the judgment opening judicial safeguard proceedings, the judge hears the debtor, the representatives of the works council or the staff delegates, and any other person whose evidence may be useful.

If it turns out that the debtor faces serious difficulties justifying judicial safeguard, the opening judgment records that the debtor is not in a state of cessation of payments. An observation period then begins (lasting 6 months, renewable twice), the purpose of which is to take a snapshot of the company, plan for the future, assess the past and rebuild the company’s cash position. In practical terms, this means drawing up a detailed assessment of the company’s position and taking the necessary restructuring measures, based on the exact amount of its debts. To this end, a supervising judge (juge-commissaire) is appointed to ensure the proper conduct of the proceedings and to protect the interests at stake. A creditors’ representative (mandataire judiciaire) and a judicial administrator (administrateur judiciaire) are appointed, respectively, to represent the collective interest of creditors and to assist with the administrative management of the company (without the debtor losing control of its business).

The opening judgment is published in the BODACC (the official bulletin of civil and commercial notices) and in a legal notices journal. From the date of publication, there is a 10-day period in which to challenge the opening judgment.

During this observation period, the debtor’s liabilities are frozen. As a rule, this freeze prohibits the debtor from paying any debt that arose before the opening judgment, except debts relating to certain transactions in financial instruments, maintenance and wage claims, and the set-off of related claims.

The exceptions also include payment of creditors who hold a right of retention or who benefit from a security trust (fiducie-sûreté) or a leasing arrangement (crédit-bail). It is also a principle that the freeze prohibits the debtor from paying any debt arising after the opening judgment.

This freeze is accompanied by a ban on individual proceedings by creditors against the debtor, its co-obligors and guarantors. As additional rules, the freeze halts the accrual of interest on the debtor’s debts (only for those with a term of more than 1 year), halts the registration of security interests over property, and preserves the original maturity of claims not yet due on the date of the opening judgment.

As they can neither take action against the debtor nor register security interests, creditors must, after being notified of the opening judgment, file their claims within 2 months of that notification, failing which they will be time-barred (i.e. they will not take part in the distribution of payments).

The filing of claims makes it possible to assess the liabilities. On the basis of this assessment, the report of the court-appointed officers and the existence of a serious prospect of safeguarding the company, the court, in consultation with the debtor, adopts a safeguard plan setting out the company’s recovery prospects. However, if the evidence shows that the company is in a state of cessation of payments, the court may, at the end of the observation period, decide to convert the safeguard proceedings into judicial reorganisation or liquidation proceedings.

With safeguard proceedings, unlike the ad hoc mandate and conciliation, we truly enter the realm of insolvency law: this is a judicial method, under the aegis of the commercial court, for dealing with businesses in difficulty.

Here again, it is best to seek the advice of a lawyer specialising in insolvency proceedings and restructuring.

Avocat procédures collectives bis

Judicial reorganisation proceedings for a business in difficulty

Cessation of payments is the condition for opening judicial reorganisation proceedings. It describes the legal status of a debtor who is unable to pay its due and payable debts (its liabilities) out of its available cash (its assets).

Traders, craftspeople, farmers and private-law legal entities in a state of cessation of payments may apply to the Commercial Court or the Judicial Court for the opening of judicial reorganisation proceedings. This application must be made no later than 45 days after the cessation of payments, where no conciliation proceedings have been opened.

Unlike judicial safeguard proceedings, where only the debtor may apply for their opening, the opening of reorganisation proceedings may be requested:

  • By the debtor, who files a declaration of cessation of payments;
  • By a creditor, by means of a summons;
  • At the request of the public prosecutor (procureur de la République), by way of application.

Once the matter has been referred to it, the court examines the company’s situation and delivers a judgment opening judicial reorganisation, which sets the date of cessation of payments and the length of the observation period, and appoints the court-appointed officers (creditors’ representative or judicial administrator). The opening judgment is published and may be challenged under the same conditions as the judgment opening safeguard proceedings.

During the observation period, creditors, faced with the freeze on liabilities, must file their claims. This process ultimately makes it possible to determine to what extent the business can continue trading.

Like judicial safeguard proceedings, reorganisation proceedings must enable the company to be rescued, its business and jobs to be maintained, and its liabilities to be cleared. Reorganisation involves an economic and social assessment. To this end, the creditors’ representative and, where appropriate, the judicial administrator are appointed by the court.

To carry out this task, they are entrusted with the management of all or part of the company, alone or together with the debtor, under the supervision of a supervising judge appointed by the court.

For creditors, the consequences of opening judicial reorganisation proceedings are the stay of proceedings and the halting of interest. The company director’s remuneration is reassessed.

A social restructuring plan may be provided for if redundancies on economic grounds are urgent, unavoidable and essential during the observation period.

Judicial reorganisation proceedings may result, among other outcomes, in the adoption of a reorganisation plan, the partial or total sale of the company, or an order for judicial liquidation if the company’s economic situation is irretrievably compromised at the end of the observation period.

However, the company may also secure financing that allows it to continue trading and pay off its creditors. In that case, the judicial reorganisation proceedings come to an end.

Judicial reorganisation is the insolvency proceeding par excellence, the flagship method for dealing with businesses in difficulty. It is the best-known procedure and the one most widely used by lawyers specialising in insolvency proceedings and by restructuring specialists.

Judicial liquidation proceedings for a business in difficulty

Judicial liquidation proceedings are also conditional on the debtor being in a state of cessation of payments (trader, craftsperson, farmer or private-law legal entity). However, the aim is no longer to assess the company’s viability but to organise its liquidation. In practical terms, this is the situation where the company faces serious difficulties leading to the cessation of its business, to the point that its situation is irretrievably compromised. In such a case, a fresh start is clearly impossible.

Liquidation proceedings come into play when all safeguard and reorganisation plans have failed to produce the expected positive effects. The opening of liquidation proceedings may then be requested by the debtor, by a creditor or by the public prosecutor. The application is made to the Commercial Court or the Judicial Court, depending on the debtor’s legal form. The judge delivers the opening judgment after approving the application to open liquidation. This opening judgment has immediate consequences for the company and its business.

First and foremost, the freeze on liabilities results in a stay of proceedings and the halting of interest. In addition, the irretrievably compromised nature of the debtor’s situation justifies the cessation of the company’s business, the termination of employees’ contracts of employment, all claims against the debtor becoming due, and the divestment of the manager from their functions.

As the debtor is divested, a creditors’ representative is appointed to conduct the proceedings as liquidator. In place of the debtor, the liquidator thus exercises the debtor’s rights and actions in respect of its assets, manages the company (where business continues temporarily), sells the assets, dismisses the employees and verifies the claims. This applies throughout the judicial liquidation proceedings. A supervising judge is also appointed to ensure the proper conduct of the proceedings and to protect the interests at stake.

The duration of liquidation is not subject to a fixed time limit. It may range from several years to 12 months for a small company with no real estate assets. In that case, the rules for simplified liquidation proceedings apply.

In any event, the main purpose of liquidation lies not in its duration, but in paying off the creditors, who are organised in a pyramid-like hierarchy.

It is mainly for these reasons that the court orders the closure of the liquidation: either because all liabilities have been paid, or because the liquidator has sufficient assets to pay off the creditors, or, finally, because liquidation operations have become impossible due to insufficient assets.

This closure brings the company’s existence to an end. No proceedings may be brought against the debtor, except in cases of tax fraud, concealment of assets, or criminal or personal sanctions.

As with reorganisation, it is ultimately possible in liquidation proceedings to adopt a plan for the partial or total takeover of the business. In this way, the business is taken over and jobs are preserved. However, it is rare for judicial reorganisation proceedings that have failed and been converted into judicial liquidation to result in a partial or total sale when the situation is irretrievably compromised.

Although judicial liquidation is not intended to enable the recovery of the business in difficulty, it is certainly the best-known and most feared insolvency proceeding among debtors. Unfortunately, it is also the antechamber of sanctions where the director is at fault (particularly in the case of liquidation with insufficient assets).

Here again, it is best to seek the advice of a restructuring and insolvency specialist to avoid the pitfalls.

Baptiste Robelin, a lawyer specialising in insolvency law, assists businesses in difficulty with safeguard, judicial reorganisation and judicial liquidation proceedings. Follow our advice to help you overcome your company’s difficulties. Our specialist firm supports you at every stage of your company’s restructuring.

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on insolvency proceedings

No FAQs yet
Place urbaine avec allée en gravier, bordée de bancs, de topiaires sphériques et de parterres fleuris devant des immeubles haussmanniens au coucher du soleil.
Everything you need to know about business law

More resources

More resources

No items found.

A project or a dispute? Contact us

Every situation deserves a clear and pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.