HomeReal estate
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy

Lawyer specialising in franchise law

Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin
Baptiste Robelin

Franchising is not governed by any specific regulation. Its form and content are freely determined by the parties, subject to the general rules of law, commercial contract law, case law and the European Code of Ethics for Franchising. The franchise agreement is therefore a complex contract that can take different forms (distribution, service or production franchise). It is important for the parties to be advised by a specialist lawyer at every stage of the franchise, both when negotiating and when drafting the clauses.

The Ordinance of 10 February 2016, which came into force on 1 October 2016, reformed French contract law and applies to all franchise agreements concluded since that date. In particular, it introduced two key rules governing the relationship between franchisor and franchisee:

  • Article 1171 of the Civil Code deems unwritten any clause that creates a significant imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties to a standard-form contract (contrat d'adhésion), a category into which a franchise agreement may fall depending on the circumstances.
  • Article 1195 of the Civil Code (hardship doctrine) allows the franchisee, as well as the franchisor, to request a renegotiation of the contract, and then its revision or termination by the court, if an unforeseeable change of circumstances at the time of conclusion makes performance excessively onerous for one of the parties.

Understanding the franchise agreement

What are the franchisor's pre-contractual obligations?

Article L330-3 of the Commercial Code requires the franchisor to provide the prospective franchisee, at least 20 days before the contract is signed or any payment is made under the franchise agreement, with the draft contract and a Pre-contractual Information Document (DIP) containing, in particular:

  • key information about the company (legal form, share capital, identity of the manager, etc.);
  • the list of subsidiaries and branches;
  • an overview of the national and local market for the business sector;
  • the term of the contract and its conditions;
  • the amount of investment to be made by the future franchisee before starting operations.

The franchisee therefore has a 20-day cooling-off period between receipt of the DIP and signature. If this period is not observed, the franchisee may seek to have the contract annulled.

What is a franchise pre-contract?

A pre-contract, also known as a reservation agreement, may precede the franchise agreement where a sum of money is required before the contract is finally signed.

The pre-contract must set out the obligations of the franchisor and the franchisee, as well as the services in return for which the reservation fee has been paid.

It is advisable to include in the pre-contract a clause providing for full or partial reimbursement of the sums paid by the franchisee should the deal fall through for reasons beyond its control, or even in the event of withdrawal.

What are the essential elements of a franchise agreement?

Under a franchise agreement, the franchisor undertakes to pass on its know-how to a franchisee, granting it the use of a trade mark and, where applicable, supplying it with goods. In return, the franchisee undertakes to operate this know-how and trade mark in exchange for a royalty. There are three main forms:

  • the production franchise agreement: provision of know-how for manufacturing a product sold under the franchisor's trade mark;
  • the service franchise agreement: sale of a service under the franchisor's trade mark and instructions;
  • the distribution franchise agreement: sale of products under the franchisor's brand name.

Two elements are essential to its validity:

Know-how. Under EU Regulation 330/2010, the know-how passed on to the franchisee must be secret, useful to the franchisee, and sufficiently identified and described to enable it to verify that it is secret and useful.

The reputation of the distinctive signs. The trade mark and brand name passed on to the franchisee must be widely known to the public. The Commercial Chamber of the Cour de cassation (9 October 1990) held that a lack of reputation of the distinctive signs may justify challenging the contract, subject to an exception for newly created brands (Cass. com., 12 July 1993).

Key clauses to negotiate carefully:

  • Know-how transfer clause: the list of elements the franchisor must pass on throughout the contract, beyond the initial training alone.
  • Intellectual property clause: the franchisor grants a licence to use its trade mark and commercial attributes, strictly defined by the contract.
  • Assistance clause: it specifies how the franchisor will support the franchisee (information, advice, visits, etc.).
  • Territorial exclusivity clause (optional): guarantees the franchisee freedom from competition within a given geographical area.
  • Supply clause: governs the suppliers from which the franchisee must source its products.
  • Entry fees and royalties: the entry fee (initial lump-sum fee) is fixed, while the royalty is calculated on turnover.
  • Non-compete clause: prohibits the franchisee from carrying on a competing business during and/or after the contract.
  • Stock buy-back clause: governs what happens to goods still held by the franchisee at the end of the contract.

Further reading: What is a DIP in franchising? · The obligations of the franchisor and the franchisee

Who owns the franchisee's customer base?

The Cour de cassation (27 March 2002) settled the question: the franchisee necessarily has its own customer base because, even though it benefits from customers drawn by the reputation of the franchisor's brand, those customers are also drawn by the franchisee's own work and activity.

The customer base is therefore attached both to the franchisor's brand (as with fast-food outlets and hotels) and to the franchisee's work (as with hair salons, for example).

Who is liable if the franchisee fails?

The franchisee is commercially independent of the franchisor: it is therefore responsible for its business if it fails and must pay its own debts, unless it can prove that the franchisor interfered in the management of its business to the point of becoming its de facto manager.

Advantages and disadvantages of franchising

Advantages for the franchisee:

  • benefiting from a proven business model;
  • drawing on the reputation of the franchisor's brand;
  • adapting the distribution of goods and services.

Disadvantages:

  • entry fees that can be high;
  • recurring royalties payable to the franchisor;
  • the obligation to follow the franchisor's instructions and specifications.

Novlaw Avocats: recognised expertise in franchising

Supporting franchisors in developing their network

We assist brands seeking to replicate their concept and build a national or regional network: legal structuring of the franchise network, trade mark protection, drafting of contractual documentation, protection of know-how and support with franchisee recruitment.

Assisting franchisees with setting up

Opening a franchised restaurant, bar or hotel involves many steps: negotiating the commercial lease, acquiring the business (fonds de commerce), setting up the operating company, obtaining the necessary licences and bringing the premises into regulatory compliance.

Commercial leases: dedicated expertise

The premises are often the main asset of a franchised outlet. Baptiste Robelin has been handling the negotiation and management of commercial leases for more than fifteen years, which enables the firm to anticipate issues relating to the permitted use under the lease, works, service charges, renewals, sales of businesses and disputes between landlords and operators.

In-depth knowledge of the hospitality sector

The firm regularly advises restaurateurs, hoteliers, bar operators, coffee shops, bakeries and fast-food chains on drinks licences, administrative authorisations, public building (ERP) standards, food hygiene, extraction systems and the operating constraints specific to premises open to the public.

Publications and teaching (author, trainer)

Author of the practical guide to opening, running and selling a hotel, café or restaurant published by Le Moniteur, and a lecturer at schools and organisations specialising in the hospitality sector, Baptiste Robelin regularly advises restaurateurs, hoteliers and franchise networks on their development projects.

Mistakes to avoid when negotiating a franchise agreement

Negotiating a franchise agreement is a decisive step for the success of the project. Many of the difficulties encountered by franchisors and franchisees stem from an insufficient review of the contractual documents before signing.

Entering into an unbalanced contract between franchisor and franchisee

One of the most common mistakes is signing a franchise agreement without checking whether the respective obligations of the franchisor and the franchisee are genuinely balanced. In practice, some contracts impose numerous constraints on the franchisee (high royalties, exclusive supply obligations, mandatory investments, strict standards, broad non-compete clauses), while the franchisor's commitments remain relatively limited.

Yet the very essence of a franchise agreement is partnership. In return for the royalties paid by the franchisee, the franchisor must in particular pass on genuine, proven know-how, provide ongoing assistance, run the network, build the brand's reputation and make available the tools needed to operate the concept.

An excessive imbalance can give rise to disputes and weaken the contractual relationship. The obligations imposed on each party, as well as the penalties for breach, should therefore be examined carefully. Some clauses can be negotiated before signing in order to restore a better economic and legal balance between franchisor and franchisee.

A lawyer specialising in franchise law can identify unbalanced clauses, assess their practical consequences and, where possible, have them amended before the contract is concluded.

Failing to review the Pre-contractual Information Document (DIP) thoroughly

Before any signature, the franchisor must provide the prospective franchisee with a Pre-contractual Information Document (DIP) in accordance with Article L. 330-3 of the Commercial Code. This document must include information on the franchisor, its experience, its network, the state of the market and development prospects.

A common mistake is to treat the DIP as a mere administrative formality. In fact, it is an essential document for assessing the viability of the project and the risks of the proposed investment.

Underestimating the franchisee's financial obligations

The entry fee usually represents only part of the real cost of a franchise. The franchisee must also take into account:

  • periodic royalties;
  • advertising contributions;
  • initial investments;
  • fit-out costs;
  • supply obligations;
  • training expenses.

A thorough financial analysis is essential before making any commitment.

Overlooking territorial exclusivity clauses

The contract must state whether or not the franchisee has exclusivity over a defined geographical area.

Some networks grant strong territorial exclusivity, while others reserve the right to open new outlets or develop online sales in the same area. These factors can have a direct impact on the profitability of the project.

Ignoring the clauses on leaving the network

Most franchise disputes arise when the contractual relationship comes to an end.

The following should be examined carefully:

  • the termination conditions;
  • the renewal arrangements;
  • post-contractual non-compete clauses;
  • non-reaffiliation clauses;
  • the consequences of termination for the operation of the outlet.

For the franchisor: neglecting the protection of know-how

Know-how is one of the pillars of the franchise agreement. Know-how that is insufficiently documented or poorly protected can weaken the entire network and make it harder to defend the franchisor's interests in the event of a dispute.

How Novlaw Avocats supports you in franchising

Novlaw Avocats supports franchisors and franchisees at every stage of their development, from setting up the network to resolving any disputes.

Setting up and structuring franchise networks

We assist entrepreneurs who wish to develop their business through franchising.

Our work covers in particular:

  • a preliminary audit of the concept;
  • trade mark protection;
  • documenting the know-how;
  • drafting the operations manual;
  • putting the contractual documentation in place;
  • defining the network development strategy.

Drafting the DIP and the franchise agreement

The legal security of the network depends largely on the quality of its contractual documents.

The firm drafts or updates:

  • the Pre-contractual Information Document (DIP);
  • the franchise agreement;
  • area reservation agreements;
  • master franchise agreements;
  • supply agreements;
  • the network's charters and internal rules.

Assisting franchisees before signing

We help prospective franchisees carry out a full review of their project.

Our role includes:

  • checking that the DIP is compliant;
  • analysing the contract clauses;
  • identifying legal risks;
  • negotiating certain provisions;
  • securing the terms of entry into the network.

Cross-disciplinary expertise in business law

Franchising draws on many complementary areas of law.

Our firm also advises on:

  • commercial leases;
  • company law;
  • sales of businesses;
  • trade mark law;
  • commercial contracts;
  • commercial litigation.

This comprehensive approach allows us to offer particularly thorough support to franchise stakeholders.

Handling franchise disputes

Franchising is often viewed from the perspective of business development. Yet when the relationship deteriorates, the stakes quickly become contentious and can threaten the economic balance of the network or the survival of the outlet. It is precisely in these situations that Novlaw's experience makes the difference.

Unlike some advisers who only step in when contracts are drafted or negotiated, the firm handles commercial litigation before the courts and courts of appeal on a daily basis. This experience allows us to anticipate, from the contractual stage onwards, the difficulties that may arise and to draft more robust contracts designed to withstand a potential dispute.

We support our clients at every stage of a dispute, from the first amicable negotiations to the most complex court proceedings. We do not abandon our clients when difficulties arise: we remain at their side for as long as necessary to defend their interests and find the most effective solution.

The firm handles disputes relating in particular to:

  • breaches of pre-contractual obligations;
  • claims for annulment or termination of the franchise agreement;
  • challenges based on an incomplete, inadequate or misleading DIP;
  • wrongful termination of contractual relationships;
  • disputes concerning the know-how passed on or the franchisor's assistance;
  • breaches of non-compete, confidentiality or non-reaffiliation clauses;
  • challenges relating to royalties, territorial exclusivity or use of the trade mark.

This dual expertise in advisory work and litigation is one of Novlaw's main strengths. Our knowledge of the strategies deployed before the courts enables us not only to defend our clients effectively in the event of a dispute, but also to prevent many risks upstream when structuring and developing the franchise network.

‍

‍

‍

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

FAQ – Franchise law

Can a lawyer get involved even before the franchise agreement is signed?

Yes. Indeed, this is one of the most useful stages at which to do so. The lawyer can audit the DIP (pre-contractual disclosure document), analyse the franchise agreement, negotiate certain clauses, identify legal and financial risks, and secure the prospective franchisee's investment or the development of the franchisor's network.

What is the difference between a franchise agreement and a distribution agreement?

A franchise agreement rests on three essential elements: a trade mark, know-how and ongoing assistance. Under a standard distribution agreement, the distributor generally markets a supplier's products without necessarily benefiting from structured know-how or ongoing support.

What happens at the end of a franchise agreement?

When the agreement expires, the franchisee must generally stop using the trade mark, return confidential documents and comply with any post-contractual clauses provided for in the agreement. The conditions for renewal depend on the contractual terms.

What is the usual term of a franchise agreement?

Most franchise agreements are concluded for a term of between five and ten years. This term generally allows the franchisee to recoup its initial investment and develop its business.

What are the sanctions if the pre-contractual disclosure document (DIP) is incomplete or misleading?

An incomplete, inaccurate or false DIP may render the franchisor liable. Depending on the circumstances, the franchisee may claim damages, or even seek the annulment of the agreement where it can show that its consent was vitiated.

Can the franchisee challenge the royalties claimed by the franchisor?

Yes, in certain situations. In particular, the franchisee may challenge royalties that do not comply with the agreement or that are claimed in breach of the franchisor's commitments. Each situation requires an analysis of the agreement and of the relationship between the parties.

Can the franchisor terminate the franchise agreement?

Yes. The franchisor may terminate the agreement in the event of a serious breach by the franchisee of its contractual obligations, in particular non-payment of royalties, damage to the network's image, misuse of the know-how or unfair competition.

Can the franchise agreement include a non-compete clause?

Yes. A non-compete clause may be valid during the performance of the agreement and after its expiry, provided that it is limited in time and space and proportionate to the protection of the network's know-how.

Can the franchisee sell their business (fonds de commerce)?

In principle, yes. However, the franchise agreement often contains approval clauses allowing the franchisor to control the identity of the buyer and the conditions for continuing the franchise agreement.

Can the franchisor open another outlet nearby?

It all depends on the terms of the agreement. Some agreements grant the franchisee territorial exclusivity, while others allow the franchisor to set up other establishments freely. A detailed analysis of the agreement is essential to determine the extent of this protection.

Does the franchisee own its customer base?

Yes. Contrary to some common misconceptions, the customer base belongs in principle to the franchisee, who runs their business as an independent trader. This independence is one of the fundamental characteristics of the franchise agreement.

Can the franchisor require the franchisee to use specific suppliers?

Yes, within certain limits. The agreement may provide for exclusive or approved-supplier purchasing where this obligation is justified by the protection of the know-how, the network's image or the quality of the products and services offered. Such clauses must, however, comply with competition law.

Is the franchisee required to follow the network's methods?

Yes. The franchisee undertakes to apply the network's know-how and procedures in order to ensure the uniformity of the brand. However, the franchisor cannot impose such a degree of control that the franchisee would lose its legal and economic independence.

Must the franchisor provide assistance throughout the term of the agreement?

Yes. Assistance is one of the essential elements of the franchise agreement. Its content varies from network to network, but it generally includes help with opening the outlet, training, commercial support, management advice and ongoing operational support.

Is the franchisor under an obligation to ensure the success of the franchisee's project?

No. The franchisor does not guarantee the franchisee's economic success. However, it must provide honest and fair information before the agreement is signed and provide the assistance stipulated in the agreement. It may be held liable for misleading information or for breaches of its contractual obligations.

What are the franchisee's main obligations?

The franchisee must operate the network's concept in accordance with the standards set by the franchisor, respect the know-how passed on, preserve the brand's image, pay the royalties provided for in the contract and contribute to the development of the network. The franchisee is also bound by a duty of confidentiality regarding the know-how communicated.

How do you set up a franchise network?

Setting up a franchise network involves, in particular, formalising transferable know-how, protecting the brand, drafting a franchise agreement that complies with the regulations, preparing a pre-contractual disclosure document (DIP) and organising support for future franchisees. Assistance from a lawyer helps to secure each stage of the network's development.

Can I leave a franchise network before the end of the contract?

Whether you can leave a network depends on the terms of the contract and the circumstances of the case. Early termination may give rise to liability on the part of the party that initiates it. Before making any decision, it is advisable to have the contract reviewed in order to assess the financial and litigation risks.

Does Novlaw Avocats advise restaurant and hotel franchises?

Yes. The firm regularly acts for franchisors and franchisees in the restaurant, café, bar and hotel sectors and, more broadly, in the hospitality sector (CHR). This expertise makes it possible to address not only franchise-related issues but also questions of commercial leases, businesses (fonds de commerce), licences, administrative authorisations and the regulations applicable to establishments open to the public.

What are the main disputes in franchising?

Disputes frequently concern breaches of pre-contractual disclosure obligations, claims for annulment of the contract, challenges relating to the know-how passed on, wrongful termination, post-contractual non-compete clauses and disagreements over the support provided by the franchisor.

What are the franchisor's main obligations?

The franchisor must, in particular, make available to the franchisee a brand that is in use and protected, pass on substantial, secret and identified know-how, provide support throughout the term of the contract and provide a Pre-contractual Disclosure Document (DIP) that complies with the regulations. The franchisor must also ensure that the network's consistency and image are preserved.

Does a franchisee need a lawyer?

Involving a lawyer is strongly recommended before making any commitment. Franchisees often invest substantial sums and commit for several years. A review of the DIP and the contract makes it possible to identify legal and financial risks before signing.

Does a franchisor need a lawyer?

Yes. A lawyer assists the franchisor with the legal structuring of the network, drafting the franchise agreement, preparing the DIP, protecting know-how, managing relations with franchisees and handling disputes. Legal support at an early stage helps to secure the network's development.

What is the difference between a franchise and a trade mark licence?

A franchise generally involves passing on know-how, ongoing support and the operation of a proven concept. A trade mark licence, by contrast, mainly allows the use of a trade mark in return for a royalty, without necessarily including know-how or operational support.

Can a franchise agreement be annulled?

A franchise agreement can be annulled in certain situations, in particular where the franchisee's consent was vitiated or where the DIP contained inaccurate, incomplete or misleading information. Each situation nevertheless requires an in-depth legal analysis of the documents and the circumstances of the signing.

Can a franchise agreement be negotiated?

Yes. Contrary to popular belief, many clauses can be negotiated before signing. In particular, it is possible to discuss certain provisions relating to territorial exclusivity, renewal conditions, supply obligations, turnover targets or the financial guarantees required by the franchisor.

How much does it cost to instruct a franchise law lawyer?

Fees vary depending on the assignment. A simple review of the DIP or the franchise agreement will generally cost less than full support including negotiation of the contract, setting up the company, finding commercial premises or handling litigation. Novlaw Avocats offers services tailored to the needs of franchisors and franchisees.

What is a DIP (Pre-contractual Disclosure Document)?

The DIP is a document that the franchisor must provide to the prospective franchisee at least 20 days before the contract is signed or any sum of money is paid. It contains essential information about the network, its history, its financial position, the relevant market and the terms of the contract. An incomplete or misleading DIP may, in some cases, justify the annulment of the franchise agreement.

Why consult a lawyer before signing a franchise agreement?

A franchise agreement creates significant obligations for both the franchisee and the franchisor. Before signing, a lawyer can review the clauses relating to the term of the contract, royalties, territorial exclusivity, sales targets, non-competition and the conditions for leaving the network. A prior review often helps to avoid costly disputes.

What are the main types of litigation in franchising?

Disputes frequently concern: breaches of the pre-contractual duty of disclosure; claims for annulment of the contract; disputes relating to know-how; early termination; non-compete clauses; challenges relating to royalties; breaches of the obligation to provide support; conflicts between franchisors and franchisees over territorial exclusivity.

A project or a dispute? Contact us

Every situation deserves a clear and pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.