HomeInnovation
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Innovation

Innovative public procurement lawyers: securing and leveraging innovation

Couloir moderne avec grandes baies vitrées courbes, bancs blancs fixés au mur et poubelles métalliques sous la rambarde.
Contents
Our specialists in
Public Innovation
Laurent Bidault
Laurent Bidault

Innovative procurement: our legal services

Laurent BIDAULT and his team are a genuine strategic partner for public authorities and businesses wishing to embark on innovation projects or bring them to fruition. At the crossroads of public procurement law and new technology law, NOVLAW Avocats secures your purchases of innovative solutions.

Innovative public procurement

The Code de la commande publique (Public Procurement Code) offers new tools to make it easier for innovative companies (start-ups, SMEs) to access public contracts, and to allow contracting authorities to acquire the best technologies without the burden of a conventional call for tenders (in particular through the innovative procurement scheme without competitive tendering below the €140,000 excl. VAT threshold).

Our support: 4 strategic areas of work

Our work and support for innovation in the public sector fall into four areas.

1st area: advice and strategy for innovation stakeholders

  • Legal characterisation of the innovation
  • Determining the most suitable and relevant contract (conventional public contract, innovative contract, global contract, R&D contract, innovation partnership, concession, etc.) according to the nature of the project and its objectives.
  • Determining the most appropriate procedure or purchasing technique: negotiation, competitive dialogue, framework agreement, dynamic purchasing system.
  • Determining the legal vehicle for the project: association, economic interest grouping (GIE), public interest grouping (GIP), SEM, SEMOP, SPL, joint purchasing group or consortium agreement.
  • Securing procedures with regard to public procurement rules and the specific features of innovative public procurement (definition of award criteria, drafting of contract documents, intellectual property, data security, etc.).
  • Incorporating innovation-specific aspects: intellectual property, data management and security, commercialisation of the innovation, confidentiality, reversibility, innovation funding (State aid).

2nd area: project owner support and drafting of contract documents

  • Preparing and drafting the contract, its schedules (specifications) and the tender documents.
  • Drafting articles of association, grouping and consortium agreements, and non-disclosure agreements.
  • Assistance with negotiations and the finalisation of contracts;
  • Monitoring contract performance.

3rd area: defending your interests

4th area: legal monitoring, publications and training

What is innovation within the meaning of public procurement law?

Innovation is essentially defined as a good, product, works or service that is new or significantly improved compared with what already exists.

More specifically, the Oslo Manual, drawn up by the OECD, defines innovation as the implementation of a new or significantly improved product (good or service) or process, a new marketing method or a new organisational method in business practices, workplace organisation or external relations.

In addition, a common and essential feature of all categories of innovation is that it must have been implemented.

This condition is important because, when planning an innovative purchase, the contracting authority will need to assess whether the solution already exists or does not yet exist, i.e. whether it would still require development or research.

Carrying out market studies and sourcing can prove particularly useful.

The Oslo Manual definition was incorporated into the 2014 European Directives on public procurement, as well as into the Code de la commande publique.

Article L. 2172-3 of the Code de la commande publique provides that “works, supplies or services that are new or significantly improved are considered innovative. The innovative nature may consist in the implementation of new production or construction processes, a new marketing method or a new organisational method in the company's business practices, workplace organisation or external relations”.

Which contracts can be used to acquire innovation?

The choice of contractual vehicle will depend mainly on the stage of development of the solution and its degree of maturity.

If the solution is still under development, the contracting authority should favour a research and development (R&D) contract or a pre-commercial procurement arrangement, allowing it to purchase R&D services and co-develop the solution with its partner.

If the solution is operational, the contracting authority may acquire it either through an innovative public contract or, if the value of the solution exceeds €140,000 excl. VAT, following a conventional procedure.

If the solution does not exist or requires significant co-development between the company and the contracting authority, the latter may also use an innovation partnership, which makes it possible to include in a single contract both the R&D and the acquisition of the solution developed through that R&D.

Other factors must be taken into account to determine the right contractual vehicle, in particular:

  • The level of collaboration envisaged between the contracting authority and the company;
  • The contracting authority's level of knowledge of the market;
  • How precisely the need is defined and how complex it is for the contracting authority to define it;
  • The contracting authority's budgetary constraints and deadlines.

Ultimately, it is essential to analyse the needs and stakes of each project carefully in order to choose the most suitable contract and encourage the acquisition of high-performing innovative solutions.

What is an innovative public contract?

Article R. 2122-9-1 of the Code de la commande publique allowed contracting authorities to acquire innovative works, supplies and services with an estimated value below €100,000 excl. VAT without prior advertising or competitive tendering. Since 1 July 2026, Article 16 of Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on the simplification of economic life has raised this threshold to €140,000 excl. VAT, an amount indexed to the European threshold applicable to supply and service contracts awarded by central government authorities. Article R. 2122-9-1 has not yet been brought into line with this change.

To use this scheme, three main conditions must be met:

  • The solution must be innovative
  • The value of the need must be below €140,000 excl. VAT.
  • The contracting authority must take care to choose a relevant offer, make good use of public funds and not systematically contract with the same company where several offers could meet the need.

In practical terms, for the contracting authority, the usual threshold of €60,000 excl. VAT, below which there is no obligation to advertise or put the contract out to competition, is raised to €140,000 excl. VAT for innovative purchases.

Once the contracting authority has established that the solution is innovative, it can acquire it directly, by private agreement.

For businesses, access to public contracts is made easier: they do not need to go through a call for tenders and can freely approach public buyers and sell them their solution.

How can you tell whether a solution is eligible for the innovative public procurement scheme?

An innovative solution is one that is new or significantly improved: if no other solution of this type exists on the market, this is already a good indication that the solution is innovative.

Next, it is useful to refer to the set of indicators developed by the French Ministry of the Economy (Guide).

This involves asking questions about the solution and the company offering it:

  • Does the solution exist on the market?
  • Does the solution exist in the public sector?
  • Has the solution obtained patents, labels or awards relating to innovation?
  • Does the solution improve a “traditional” process or service?
  • Does the solution help control environmental impacts?
  • Does the solution meet a new need?
  • What is the solution's level of maturity?
  • Is the company part of an innovation ecosystem (cluster, competitiveness cluster, incubators)?

Contractual and regulatory tools to support public innovation

Contracting authorities can use the contractual tools provided for in the Code de la commande publique: R&D contract, innovation partnership, innovative contract, public contract.

Outside the public procurement framework, and therefore with greater flexibility and freedom, contracting authorities can stimulate innovation by launching calls for expressions of interest (AMI, calls for projects, innovation competitions or pilot projects, award of grants).

Note: the organisation of these initiatives is not regulated, provided that it does not conceal a public contract.

Finally, there are support mechanisms at European and national level, as well as tax schemes: research tax credit, innovation tax credit.

A win-win partnership between innovative companies and public sector clients

What are the benefits of innovative public procurement for public buyers?

Innovative public procurement gives public buyers access to new, high-performing solutions.

In this respect, it helps improve the quality of public services.

More generally, it stimulates innovation and economic growth.

Moreover, by positioning itself as a player in innovation, the public body enhances the attractiveness of its area.

What are the benefits of innovative public procurement for businesses?

Innovative public procurement provides access to new markets and to the public sector, sometimes in a more streamlined way.

In this respect, public procurement can be a source of funding for the company and for the research and development of new solutions.

Finally, it enables companies to work and collaborate with public buyers to test and deploy their solutions in the public sector.

Couverture du magazine Contrats Publics n°265 de juin 2025, dossier sur intelligence artificielle et achats publics, enjeux, vigilance et perspective.
AI and public procurement: challenges, vigilance and outlook
Couverture du magazine Contrats Publics, numéro 239 de février 2023, avec un dossier sur l'innovation dans la commande publique détaillant les caractéristiques, outils, procédures et adaptation des contrats.
Innovation in public procurement
Couverture du livre intitulé Guide des achats publics innovants par Laurent Bidault, avec une illustration montrant des personnages et une grue symbolisant l'innovation et la collaboration.
Guide to innovative public procurement
Couverture d'un dossier d'experts sur la commande publique intitulé Réussir ses achats publics innovants, avec une main tenant une ampoule allumée et l'autre main tenant une pile de pièces entourée d'engrenages.
Succeeding in innovative public procurement
Frequently asked questions on public innovation

Can a start-up sell directly to a public buyer without a call for tenders?

Yes, below the threshold of €140,000 excluding VAT, if its solution is innovative: the company can approach the buyer and contract directly by negotiation, without a formal procedure. This is not, however, a guaranteed right. The buyer must still choose a relevant offer, make good use of public funds and not systematically contract with the same operator where several offers could meet the need. A file demonstrating the innovative nature of the solution therefore remains the best sales argument.

What is the threshold for buying an innovative solution without advertising or competitive tendering?

Since 1 July 2026, the threshold has been €140,000 excluding VAT, up from €100,000 excluding VAT previously. It results from Article 16 of Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on simplifying economic life, which refers to the European threshold applicable to supply and service contracts awarded by central government authorities: the amount will therefore change automatically with each biennial revision. Note that Article R. 2122-9-1 of the French Public Procurement Code has not yet been updated and still refers to €100,000 excluding VAT; it is the statute, which is more recent, that applies.

Are variants now permitted by default in public contracts?

Yes. The new Article L. 2151-2 of the French Public Procurement Code, in force since 28 May 2026, reverses the previous approach: variants are permitted unless the buyer states otherwise, in both formalised and adapted procedures. This is a direct lever for innovation, since operators can propose an alternative solution that performs better than the base solution. In return, the buyer must set clear minimum requirements and a method for comparing tenders.

Does young innovative company status automatically make a solution innovative?

No, not since 3 May 2025. The presumption introduced by the 2024 Finance Act was abolished by the DDADUE Act of 30 April 2025, as it did not comply with European law. Since 28 May 2026, however, the new Article L. 2113-17 of the French Public Procurement Code has made it possible to reserve up to 15% of the value of the lots of an innovative contract divided into lots for young innovative companies. As this mechanism follows a logic that has already been struck down, documenting the innovative nature of the services remains essential.

Can a local authority acquire an innovative solution without competitive tendering?

Yes, up to €140,000 excluding VAT since 1 July 2026, provided that the innovative nature of the solution acquired can be demonstrated. This threshold derives from Article 16 of Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on the simplification of economic life, which does not set any amount but refers to the European threshold applicable to supply and service contracts awarded by central government authorities: it will therefore change with each biennial revision, and Article R. 2122-9-1 of the French Public Procurement Code still refers to the former amount of €100,000 excluding VAT. The innovative nature must be documented before the contract is awarded, as it is the condition for using the mechanism and the first point of vulnerability in the event of a challenge. Above this threshold, the innovation partnership under Article L. 2172-3 or the negotiated procedure under Article R. 2124-3 of the same Code offer suitable routes.

Can sourcing disqualify a company that took part in it?

No. Preliminary market consultation is expressly authorised by Article R. 2111-1 of the French Public Procurement Code. A company that was consulted is excluded only if its participation gave it access to information creating a distortion of competition that cannot be remedied by other means (Articles R. 2111-2 and L. 2141-8). The buyer must therefore keep a record of its exchanges, ensure that all candidates have the same level of information and respect business secrecy. A gap of a few weeks between the end of sourcing and the launch of the tender is recommended.

After an innovative public contract, can the buyer contract again with the same company to roll out the solution more widely?

Not automatically. The €140,000 (excluding VAT) threshold does not allow for large-scale deployment: above it, an advertising and competitive tendering procedure is, in principle, required again. Relying on the exception based on technical reasons or exclusive rights remains possible, but it is interpreted strictly. The safeguard must be anticipated from the first contract: securing intellectual property rights and reversibility clauses that allow the solution to be used independently of the contractor, so as to avoid any situation of dependency.

Who owns the intellectual property rights in the solution developed?

Nothing is automatic: the allocation is negotiated and must be set out in the contract. The European Commission recommends leaving the rights with the supplier, unless there is an overriding public interest, while reserving for the buyer sufficient rights of use and adaptation, a conditional right to grant licences and appropriate publication rights. This allocation determines the buyer's autonomy, the conditions for re-tendering, pooling with other buyers and the company's business model. It should be anticipated from the needs definition stage.

Research and development contract or innovation partnership: how to choose?

It all depends on what you want to acquire. The R&D contract under Article L. 2512-5 makes it possible to fund research work by direct award, but subject to two alternative conditions that are strictly interpreted: the buyer must not acquire exclusive ownership of the results, or must not fully fund the service. It does not cover the purchase of the final solution. The innovation partnership under Article L. 2172-3, by contrast, combines the R&D phase and the subsequent acquisition in a single contract, without re-tendering the partner.

How can the innovative nature of a solution be justified, and what are the risks in the event of an error?

The classification is the buyer's responsibility, and the buyer must be able to demonstrate it. Beyond the set of indicators published by the Legal Affairs Directorate (direction des affaires juridiques), it is strongly advisable to draw up a formal qualification note to be placed on file: state of the market, comparison with existing solutions, patents or labels obtained, level of maturity, membership of an innovation ecosystem. Failing this, a contract awarded without competition is exposed to pre-contractual or contractual interim relief proceedings (référé précontractuel or contractuel) for breach of the advertising and competitive tendering obligations.

Does the innovative procurement scheme apply to the lots of a contract divided into lots?

Yes. An innovative lot may be awarded without advertising or competitive tendering where its value is below €140,000 excluding VAT for works and €80,000 excluding VAT for supplies or services. An additional limit applies: the cumulative value of these lots must not exceed 20% of the total estimated value of all the lots. This mechanism makes it possible to introduce an innovative component into a larger project without weakening the overall procedure.

Couloir moderne avec grandes baies vitrées courbes, bancs blancs fixés au mur et poubelles métalliques sous la rambarde.

A public procurement project or dispute?

Get expert legal support for your public innovation projects: legal certainty, strategy and implementation.