

NOVLAW Avocats, and in particular Bruno Guillier, assists clients in civil service law, in both advisory and litigation matters.
This body of law, which departs from the French Labour Code, governs all relationships between public employers and their staff (civil servants and public-law contract staff) in the central government, local government and hospital civil services. Disputes between them do not fall within the jurisdiction of the employment tribunals (conseils de prud’hommes) but specifically within that of the administrative courts.
{{cta-inject-1}}
The loi n°83-634 du 13 juillet 1983, known as the Le Pors Act, sets out the general provisions applicable to civil servants. It forms Title I of the general civil service regulations. Each of the three branches was then implemented by laws forming the various titles of the general regulations.
defined by the loi n°84-16 du 11 janvier 1984 (Title II), covers posts in:
– central government departments (the ministries’ central services);
– the State’s devolved services (State functions at regional and departmental level, and posts in public educational institutions).
defined by the loi n°84-53 du 26 janvier 1984 (Title III), covers staff of:
– local authorities (municipalities, départements, regions);
– inter-municipal bodies (EPCI);
– public institutions.
defined by the loi n°86-33 du 9 janvier 1986 (Title IV), covers posts in the following institutions:
– public hospitals;
– public retirement homes;
– public or publicly run institutions under departmental child welfare services;
– public institutions for minors or adults with disabilities or special needs;
– public or publicly run social accommodation and rehabilitation centres.
The order must be manifestly unlawful and liable to seriously compromise a public interest. A manifestly unlawful order is one whose illegality is obvious. An order seriously compromises a public interest where it runs counter to the law or to a general principle, or requires an unlawful or discriminatory act. These two conditions are cumulative: to be entitled to disobey an order, both conditions must be met.
Protection is limited and depends on the court recognising that the order was manifestly unlawful and seriously compromised a public interest. These conditions are very rarely met. However, if a civil servant faces serious and imminent danger to their life or health, they may exercise their right of withdrawal (droit de retrait) and leave their post.
No, disobedience is rare because of the strict conditions governing this right and the risk of sanctions faced by any official who disobeys without sufficient justification.
Although military discipline takes precedence, the duty of military personnel to obey their superiors cannot be absolute. Article L. 4122-1 of the French Defence Code provides that military personnel may not be ordered to perform, and may not perform, acts contrary to the law, the customs of war and international conventions.
Strictly speaking, there is no right to disobey, but rather a duty to disobey in specific circumstances originally defined by case law and now by statute. Article L. 121-10 of the French General Civil Service Code (Code général de la fonction publique) provides that every public official must comply with the instructions of their superior, unless the order given is manifestly unlawful and liable to seriously compromise a public interest.
Ethical or moral reasons may justify disobedience, but such cases are rare and difficult to justify legally. These reasons must meet the conditions laid down by law and recognised by the courts, namely a manifestly unlawful order that seriously compromises a public interest.

Get expert support in civil service law: careers, disciplinary sanctions, disputes and the defence of public employees or public bodies.