HomeInnovation
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Innovation

Smart Cities and Territories Lawyer

Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin
Baptiste Robelin
Laurent Bidault
Laurent Bidault

For a long time, the "Smart City" was seen as a purely technological showcase reserved for the largest cities. Today, the concept has become widespread and matured, giving way to the reality of Connected and Smart Territories. From villages to metropolitan areas, the digital transition has become a pragmatic lever serving the ecological transition, the optimisation of resources and social cohesion.

However, deploying IoT sensors, connected street lighting or a digital twin requires breaking down the silos between traditional administrative departments.

NOVLAW Avocats advises local authorities, public inter-municipal bodies (EPCI) and joint associations (syndicats mixtes), as well as partner companies and project sponsors, on the legal, institutional and contractual engineering of their smart territory projects.

The 3 legal pillars of the Smart Territory

To succeed and protect the authority's interests, legal support for a "Smart" project must secure three dimensions at once:

  1. Governance: Who leads the project and how can departmental silos be broken down?
  2. Contractual engineering: How can innovation be procured (global performance contracts, public service concessions, partnerships)?
  3. Control of data: How can the territory's intangible assets be collected, protected and exploited (hypervisor, digital twin)?

Governance and project delivery structures

A smart territory project by nature involves multiple areas of competence (roads, energy, water, waste management, digital infrastructure). NOVLAW Avocats helps you define the most appropriate institutional governance to carry this cross-cutting approach:

  • Institutional engineering and pooling: Setting up cooperation structures (open or closed joint associations, purchasing groups) to carry a project across a living area or a département.
  • Public-private delivery vehicles: Structuring local public companies (SPL), semi-public companies (SEM) or single-purpose semi-public companies (SEMOP) dedicated to running the smart city and managing local digital services.

Contractual structures and public procurement

Deploying a connected territory can require substantial investment and a strong capacity for technical innovation from the private sector.

We help you choose and secure the most effective contractual structure:

  • The global performance contract (MGP): This is the flagship tool of the smart city. It combines capital investment (e.g. renovating and connecting the street lighting network) with quantified performance commitments (a drastic reduction in energy consumption) over time.
  • Public service delegation (DSP) and concessions: To entrust the development, financing and operation of a smart service linked to a more traditional public service (connected parking, charging point network, smart water management) to a private operator bearing the operating risk.
  • Procurement of innovation: Securing your innovative contracts, R&D contracts and innovation partnerships to co-develop new technological solutions, from the research & development (R&D) phase through to large-scale deployment.

Urban Data, Hypervisors and Digital Twins

The value of a smart territory lies in its ability to collect, cross-reference and analyse data, particularly from public spaces. Local authorities are now equipping themselves with centralisation platforms (hypervisors) and digital twins (dynamic virtual replicas of the city used to simulate the impact of public policies: traffic, flooding, heat islands).

Our firm safeguards the sovereignty of your data policy:

  • Sovereignty, reversibility and interoperability: Drafting contractual clauses requiring the use of open standards (APIs) and setting up a strict reversibility process for data and source code.
  • Governance of the urban hypervisor: Framing data-sharing agreements between the authority, its concession holders (water, transport, waste) and major digital players. The aim: to make data a genuine local public infrastructure.
  • GDPR compliance and Open Data: Reconciling the use of monitoring devices in public spaces, such as smart cameras or IoT sensors, with strict respect for citizens' privacy.

Infrastructure, Public Space and Cybersecurity

The connected territory takes material and physical form in public space, which is why we advise on:

  • Occupation of the public domain: Drafting public domain occupation agreements (CODP) for the deployment of IoT sensors, connected street furniture or micro data centres.
  • Cybersecurity of urban systems: A hyper-connected territory is a vulnerable territory. We build cybersecurity clauses into your public contracts to protect critical infrastructure (water networks, traffic lights, hypervisors) against cyberattacks, in line with European (NIS 2 Directive) and French regulations.

‍

Frequently asked questions on smart cities

Can part of an innovative public contract be reserved for start-ups and young innovative companies?

Yes. The law on simplifying economic life (loi de simplification de la vie économique) of 26 May 2026 introduced into Article L. 2113-17 of the French Public Procurement Code (code de la commande publique) a mechanism allowing the buyer, in contracts divided into lots for innovative services, to reserve up to 15% of the total value of the lots for young innovative companies within the meaning of Article 44 sexies-0 A of the French General Tax Code (code général des impôts). This lever only has a real effect if it is built in from the moment the contract is divided into lots: lots of an accessible size, proportionate capacity requirements, and payment terms and advances suited to the cash flow of a young business. It is also the route that allows a local area to anchor its local ecosystem in its smart city project, rather than depending on a single integrator.

Can European hosting or SecNumCloud qualification be required in an AI contract?

Yes, but... provided that the requirement is justified by the subject matter of the contract and proportionate. Article 31 of the SREN Law requires the use of qualified cloud solutions where the data processed are sensitive and their compromise would be likely to undermine public order or public security. The Prime Minister's circular No. 6519/SG of 5 February 2026 on digital public procurement goes further, requiring central government buyers to apply a grid of nine decision criteria, explicitly including digital sovereignty and security. In practice, these requirements come into play at the application stage (SecNumCloud 3.2 qualification or equivalent measures, absence of non-European control), at the tender evaluation stage (security and data location criteria) and in the contract (audit, reversibility, termination in the event of a change of control). The drafting must remain compatible with European competition law and the principle of non-discrimination: be careful, this is where the legal certainty of the contract is won or lost.

What specific clauses should be included in a public contract for an AI system?

In practice, the CCAGs (general administrative clauses), including the CCAG-TIC (for information and communication technology contracts), were not designed for AI systems: they must be supplemented in the CCAP (special administrative clauses). Six families of clauses deserve particular attention. First, the allocation of roles under the AI Act: the contractor must be contractually identified as the provider and undertake to supply the technical documentation, the instructions for use and the information enabling the public deployer to fulfil its own obligations. Next, performance, with measurable indicators (error rate, false positive rate, robustness requirements) rather than mere best-efforts commitments. Then come human oversight and traceability (logging, explainability of outputs), the regime governing data and intellectual property, the management of changes to the model (a substantial update must not silently degrade the service or alter the legal classification of the system) and, finally, reversibility: return of data, configurations and annotation sets, and an enforceable exit plan.

Subsidy, call for projects or public contract: how can urban innovation be funded?

The dividing line is fundamental and is regularly scrutinised by the courts. A subsidy responds to an initiative put forward by the beneficiary, which the local authority chooses to support; a public contract meets a need defined by the local authority, in return for a price. Where the public body drafts the specifications, sets the deliverables and supervises performance, the payment is treated as a public contract, with the well-known consequences if there has been no competitive tendering. In practice, a smart territory project almost always combines several sources: funding from national or European calls for projects, financing from ADEME or the Banque des Territoires, a contribution from a private operator, operating revenue. Each building block must be legally classified in its own right: it is the overall structure, not the intention, that determines the applicable regime.

How can an innovative solution be purchased without advertising or competitive tendering?

The French Public Procurement Code allows a contract for innovative works, supplies or services to be concluded without prior advertising or competitive tendering below a threshold raised to €140,000 excluding VAT by Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on simplifying economic life. The mechanism is well suited to the first building blocks of a smart territory project: new types of sensors, a hypervision module, a simulation software component. The exemption is not, however, a blank cheque. The buyer must be able to demonstrate that the purchase is genuinely innovative — under Article L. 2172-3 of the French Public Procurement Code, new or significantly improved works, supplies or services are innovative — and comply with the principle of the proper use of public funds. A memo analysing the innovative nature of the purchase, kept in the tender file, secures the contract in the event of a challenge.

Is a territorial digital twin subject to the GDPR and open data obligations?

Frequently, yes, and the two approaches must be reconciled. Where sensors, meters or counting devices make it possible to re-identify individuals (consumption at household level, journeys, images), the GDPR applies and requires an impact assessment, data minimisation and aggregation. At the same time, the data produced by the local authority constitute administrative documents that may be subject to online publication obligations. The practical challenge is therefore to define contractually, at the outset, which data may be disseminated, at what level of granularity, and which are covered by the operator's trade secrets.

Is BIM compatible with a global contract or a design-and-build contract?

It is in fact particularly well suited to them: having a single contractor simplifies the governance of the model and the chain of responsibility. Three points require contractual vigilance. First, the definition of the need must describe the expected BIM uses without locking in the technical solution, otherwise competition may be restricted. Second, as the model serves as the basis for performance commitments, its deliverables must be aligned with the performance objectives of the global contract. Finally, the allocation of rights over the data must be set from the tender stage, since all output is concentrated with a single operator.

How can several local authorities pool the purchase of a hypervisor or digital twin?

An urban hypervisor or digital twin only makes sense at the scale of a catchment area: pooling is as much a technical requirement as a budgetary one. A purchasing group (groupement de commandes, Articles L. 2113-6 et seq. of the French Public Procurement Code) allows several buyers to award a single contract together, on the basis of a founding agreement that appoints a coordinator and allocates roles, signing arrangements and the financial burden. A central purchasing body (Articles L. 2113-2 et seq.) allows a buyer — often a joint energy syndicate or a département — to acquire or award contracts on behalf of other local authorities, which benefit from them without running their own procedure. A purchasing group requires converging needs and a common timetable; a central purchasing body offers more flexibility to join but locks in the technical solution to a greater extent. An open joint syndicate (syndicat mixte ouvert) remains the most robust vehicle for supporting shared digital infrastructure over the long term.

How can a solution be trialled (POC, demonstrator) before being rolled out across the whole territory?

Three routes coexist and can be combined. Upstream, the sourcing provided for in Article R. 2111-1 of the French Public Procurement Code allows the local authority to consult operators and carry out market studies before launching the procedure, provided that competition is not distorted: the relevant information must then be communicated to all candidates. Next, a research and development contract may, subject to conditions relating to ownership of the results and funding, fall within the exclusions of Article L. 2512-5. Finally, the demonstrator may form the first phase of an innovation partnership or a global performance contract. The classic mistake is to accept a 'free' POC offered by a manufacturer: in addition to the risk of it being reclassified as an irregular contract, the trial creates a technical dependency that distorts subsequent competitive tendering.

Can a local authority entrust its smart city project to its local public company (SPL) without competitive tendering?

Yes, provided that it strictly meets the in-house criteria laid down in Articles L. 2511-1 et seq. of the French Public Procurement Code for contracts, and L. 3211-1 for concessions: the local authority must exercise over the company a control similar to that which it exercises over its own departments, the company must carry out more than 80% of its activity for its public shareholders, and its capital must not include any direct private participation. Similar control is the criterion most often undermined: a minority shareholder without effective representation on the decision-making bodies does not exercise it. A second point of vigilance is the corporate purpose: in 2018 the Conseil d'État held that a local authority could not hold shares in an SPL whose corporate purpose exceeded its own competences, before Law No. 2019-463 of 17 May 2019 relaxed the rule by requiring only one competence in common. For a cross-cutting project — roads, energy, water, waste, digital — the drafting of the corporate purpose and the make-up of the shareholding deserve a prior audit.

What GDPR obligations apply to local authorities deploying smart city equipment?

Local authorities deploying smart city equipment (sensors, cameras, connected terminals) must, as data controllers, carry out a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) for high-risk processing, inform residents of the processing carried out, minimise the data collected, limit retention periods, and secure their systems. The CNIL (French data protection authority) may inspect such processing and impose penalties for non-compliance.

Which contract should be chosen: a Global Performance Contract (MGP) or a DSP?

If the local authority finances the equipment and pays the company to achieve an energy savings target (e.g. thermal renovation and building automation of public buildings), the MGP is the appropriate contract. If the company earns most of its remuneration by commercially operating the service for users (bearing the risk relating to usage levels), a DSP is the right choice.

What is a smart city and what legal issues does it raise?

A smart city is a city that uses digital technologies and data to optimise its urban services (transport, energy, waste, security). From a legal standpoint, it raises major issues: protection of residents' personal data (GDPR compliance), security of critical infrastructure, governance of the algorithms used in public decision-making, ownership of the data generated, and open data obligations.

What is a “digital twin” and who owns it?

A digital twin is a dynamic 3D model of the city, fed in real time by data from the area. It can serve as a decision-making tool for elected officials. Legally, it raises complex intellectual property issues: the local authority must ensure, through its public contracts, that it holds the rights to use this model and that it has full ownership of the databases that feed it.

How can data generated by smart city equipment be used by third parties?

Data generated by smart city equipment (traffic, energy consumption, footfall) may be made publicly available through open data (an obligation for local authorities with more than 3,500 inhabitants), shared with private partners under an innovation partnership or a public service concession, or used in the context of calls for projects. In all cases, personal data may only be shared in anonymised or pseudonymised form.

How can you avoid being locked in to your provider on a digital twin?

Reversibility must be prepared at the specification stage, never at the end of the contract. Four levers should be activated: requiring open, interoperable formats rather than a proprietary format; the documented provision of APIs and data schemas; a detailed reversibility clause setting out the timetable, format and cost of returning the data, as well as support for the incoming provider; and, where appropriate, escrow of the source code. The CCAG-TIC (general administrative terms and conditions for IT and communication contracts) provides a useful framework, provided it is supplemented by provisions specific to the operation.

How can intellectual property in software and databases developed for a local authority be secured?

This is the point most often neglected and the most costly to put right. In the absence of an express clause, the contractor retains its rights and the local authority ends up holding a mere user licence, which is insufficient to develop the solution further, entrust it to a third party or reuse it in another scope. The applicable CCAGs (general administrative terms and conditions), in particular the CCAG-TIC, offer options for licensing or assigning the rights in the results: this choice must be made deliberately in the specific contract documents. Four clauses must be tailor-made: the scope of the rights assigned or licensed (media, duration, territory, right of adaptation), the deposit of source code with an escrow agent, ownership of the databases fed by the area's sensors, and reversibility, i.e. the return of data in open, documented formats when the contract expires.

How is the competitive tendering for a SEMOP dedicated to a smart urban service conducted?

The SEMOP (single-purpose semi-public company) has one decisive feature: a single competitive procedure covers both the selection of the economic operator shareholder and the award of the contract, whether a public contract, a concession or a public service delegation. The contract notice must therefore describe at the same time the subject matter of the contract, the draft articles of association and the shareholders' agreement. The local authority holds between 34% and 85% of the capital, the operator at least 15%, and the company may not carry on any activity other than that of the single contract concluded with its public shareholder. The arrangement works well for a clearly defined connected urban service — a charging network, smart water management, connected street lighting. As the constitutional documents are produced before the partner is chosen, any imprecision regarding governance, qualified majorities or exit clauses comes at a cost throughout the life of the contract.

SEM, SPL or SEMOP: which company should carry a smart territory project?

The three semi-public vehicles follow distinct rationales. The local semi-public company (SEM, Articles L. 1521-1 et seq. of the General Local Authorities Code, CGCT) brings together public shareholders, holding between 50% and 85% of the capital, and at least one private shareholder, with a minimum of seven shareholders: as a private-law operator, it must go through a competitive procedure to be awarded a contract. The local public company (SPL, Article L. 1531-1 of the CGCT), wholly owned by at least two local authorities, can by contrast be awarded contracts without advertising or competitive tendering under the in-house (quasi-régie) conditions. The SEMOP (Articles L. 1541-1 et seq. of the CGCT) is a single-contract company, automatically dissolved when that contract ends. For a smart city: the SPL for a long-term data infrastructure steered by the public sector, the SEMOP for a specific service requiring the input of an industrial partner, and the SEM for long-term, multi-project equity backing.

Is a contract remunerated through the exploitation of urban data a public contract or a concession?

The classification depends on the transfer of operating risk, not on the title chosen by the parties. Where the operator derives a substantial part of its remuneration from exploiting the data produced by the area's equipment, from advertising revenue or from services sold to third parties, and bears the associated uncertainty, the contract falls within the scope of concessions. Conversely, public payment based on performance commitments — network availability, restoration time, reduced consumption — falls within the scope of public contracts, including global performance contracts. These hybrid arrangements call for two precautions: checking that the local authority retains legal control over the area's data, which can only constitute remuneration if its exploitation is lawful and regulated, and checking that the value transferred to the operator has been assessed and factored into the overall economics of the contract.

What is an innovation partnership and when should it be used in a smart city project?

Governed by Article L. 2172-3 and Articles R. 2172-20 to R. 2172-32 of the French Public Procurement Code, the innovation partnership is the only contract that covers, within a single contract, the research and development phase and the acquisition of the resulting solutions, without a new competitive procedure. It requires that the need cannot be met by solutions already available on the market, a condition that must be documented upstream. It is the go-to tool for co-developing a solution that does not yet exist: a traffic management algorithm, a predictive model for heat islands, an interoperability component between water, energy and mobility networks. Its success depends on the contractual architecture: division into successive phases, quantified interim objectives, the option to terminate or reduce the number of partners at each stage, and a clear allocation of intellectual property rights.

Contact our connected territories experts

Whether you are a local authority (metropolitan authority, EPCI, energy syndicate) seeking to structure your first smart territory master plan, or a consortium of companies preparing a bid for an urban hypervisor, NOVLAW secures your project.