

Pre-contractual interim relief (référé précontractuel) is an urgent remedy before the administrative court that allows an unsuccessful bidder to challenge an irregular award procedure before the contract is signed.
Pre-contractual interim relief is used to challenge the award procedure for a public contract (public procurement contract, concession, public service delegation), i.e. the outcome of a call for tenders.
Its purpose is to challenge the award procedure for a public contract before the contract is signed, in order to sanction breaches of advertising and competitive tendering obligations.
Pre-contractual interim relief is governed by Articles L.551-1 et seq. of the Code de justice administrative (Code of Administrative Justice).
The main stages of pre-contractual interim relief proceedings are as follows:
Notification that the bid has been rejected and analysis of the reasons for rejection. There is no time to lose, as pre-contractual interim relief must be sought before the contract is signed.
Where appropriate, a request for further information from the contracting authority. If the reasons given for rejecting the bid are insufficient, the bidder may ask the contracting authority for further information on the grounds that led to the rejection. Note: it is advisable to apply to the interim relief judge at the same time, as the requested information may be provided only after the contract has been signed.
This request for information is not a mere formality: handled well, it determines the strength of the application. Our guide on the unsuccessful bidder's right to information explains what to ask for and within what time limits, and our article on remedies following the rejection of a bid in public procurement reviews all the options.
Drafting the application. To be admissible, the application must set out factual and legal grounds and arguments, and must demonstrate irregularities in the procedure linked to the rejection of the bid (standing to bring proceedings).
Filing the application with the competent administrative court. The application must be filed before the contract is signed.
Notifying the application to the contracting authority: the application and supporting documents must be sent to the contracting authority that launched the award procedure, so that it suspends signature of the contract until the judge has ruled.
Proceedings: the contracting authority and the successful bidder are invited to respond to the application. The applicant may then reply.
Hearing: the parties present their arguments orally and may provide further details and clarification on the disputed points. The investigation closes at the end of the hearing before the interim relief judge.
Judge's decision: having examined the parties' arguments, the judge gives a decision. The judge may dismiss the application if no irregularity is found, or order the annulment of all or part of the award procedure if irregularities are established.
A lawyer plays an essential role in pre-contractual interim relief proceedings.
Legal advice: the lawyer advises clients on their rights and obligations in the contract award process, analysing the tender documents (DCE), the company's bid, the reasons for rejecting bids and the procedure itself.
Preparing the application: the lawyer helps the client prepare the action, in particular by drafting the application for pre-contractual interim relief, gathering documents and evidence, and drafting the appropriate legal arguments in support of the claim.
Conduct of the proceedings: the lawyer ensures compliance with time limits, procedural rules and legal and regulatory requirements throughout the proceedings, so that the client's interests are properly protected.
Representation in court: the lawyer represents the client before the competent administrative court throughout the proceedings and at the hearing.
Pre-contractual interim relief may be sought by persons "who have an interest in concluding the contract and who are likely to be harmed by the alleged breach".
In particular, a bidder whose bid has been rejected has standing to act. This may also be an excluded competitor, i.e. a company that was unable to submit an application.
The applicant must show that the irregularities committed by the contracting authority are directly linked to the rejection of its bid.
Note: showing standing is not enough. Since the Smirgeomes case law, only a breach likely to have harmed you can usefully be relied on; a defect with no bearing on your chances of winning the contract will be disregarded. This condition, which often decides the outcome of the application, is discussed in our analysis of harm to interests in pre-contractual interim relief.
Pre-contractual interim relief must be sought before the contract is signed.
In formal procedures, the contracting authority must observe a 16-day period (the standstill period) between notification of the rejection of the bid and signature of the contract. This period is reduced to 11 days where notification is sent electronically.
It is during this period that the unsuccessful bidder must apply to the pre-contractual interim relief judge.
Note: in the adapted procedure (MAPA), the public contracting authority is not required to observe this period, so the unsuccessful bidder must act very quickly.
The applicant must notify its application to the public contracting authority.
To pinpoint the right moment to act, see our guide pre-contractual interim relief: when to act in public procurement?
To challenge the award procedure for public contracts, concessions or public service delegations, the applicant may rely on breaches committed by the public body (contracting authority or contracting entity), such as:
• Advertising irregularities: irregular contract notice (AAPC), irregular or incomplete advertising media, etc.
• Competitive tendering irregularities: unlawful award criteria or sub-criteria, changes to the criteria, errors in the evaluation of bids, manifest error of assessment, refusal by the outgoing contractor to provide information needed for the competition, unequal treatment of bidders, error of assessment regarding the application or bid, discriminatory performance conditions, selection of an irregular bid, etc.
Other types of illegality are not sanctioned by the pre-contractual interim relief judge.
Several of these breaches are analysed in detail on our website: the distortion of bids and how the judge reviews it, the wrongful rejection of a bid deemed irregular, the case of a technical bid deemed non-compliant with the CCTP (technical specifications) and, for public service delegations, the irregularity of a bid assessed on its actual content .
The pre-contractual interim relief judge of the administrative court sanctions breaches of advertising and competitive tendering obligations.
The interim relief judge may:
• Order the public contracting authority to comply with its obligations;
• Suspend the contract award procedure or the implementation of any related decision;
• Annul the contract award procedure or any related decision, or even remove clauses or requirements intended to appear in the contract;
• Annul only part of the procedure.
The judge may issue injunctions to the public contracting authority, order it to suspend the implementation of any decision relating to the award, or impose a provisional penalty payment (astreinte).
An interim relief order may be appealed before the Conseil d'État.
Where the contract has already been signed, it is possible, under certain conditions, to apply to the contractual interim relief judge (référé contractuel), or to bring an action before the court challenging the validity of the contract (Tarn-et-Garonne action).
In this context, it is possible to obtain the suspension of the performance of the contract, or even its annulment.
It is also possible to bring a claim for compensation for the loss suffered as a result of being unlawfully excluded from a public contract.
For an overview of the remedies available depending on when the judge is involved, see our guide on how to challenge a public contract or a call for tenders, as well as our article on contractual interim relief (référé contractuel).
When the deadline is counted in days, the support of a lawyer specialising in public procurement law often makes the difference between an admissible application and a dismissed one. The lawyer's role covers the entire process: analysing the procedure and the reasons for rejection, assessing standing in light of the Smirgeomes case law, selecting the grounds that will genuinely be effective (and setting aside those that will not succeed), drafting the application and gathering evidence, then representing the company at the hearing before the interim relief judge.
The competent administrative court depends on where the public contracting authority has its seat.
That is why the firm acts before all French administrative courts from its offices in Paris, Lyon and Lille: whether your dispute falls within the jurisdiction of your own region or elsewhere, your case is handled regardless of distance.
The firm assists both unsuccessful bidders challenging award procedures and contracting authorities and project owners wishing to secure their tender procedures upstream, in particular through project owner support (AMO) engagements. Concerned that a procedure may be irregular?
Contact our team without delay: every day counts before the contract is signed.
The firm has published a series of analyses (in French) on the various aspects of pre-contractual interim relief and the remedies available before the contract is signed:
Maître Laurent Bidault is a member of the Paris Bar and founding partner of Novlaw Avocats. He practises public business law, covering public procurement law, public contracts and concessions as well as award litigation (pre-contractual interim relief). A recognised trainer for Le Moniteur, La Gazette des Communes and the CFPA, he is the author of three books on public business law and numerous specialist publications (Contrats Publics, Le Moniteur du BTP, BJCP).
View Laurent Bidault's full profile · All his publications
Yes, through routes that differ depending on the nature of the scheme. Where the procedure falls within public procurement, pre-contractual interim relief (référé précontractuel) is available before the contract is signed. In other cases, the rejection is an administrative decision that may be challenged by an action for annulment (recours pour excès de pouvoir), the court's review then focusing in particular on compliance with the rules of the call for projects, equal treatment of candidates and the absence of any manifest error of assessment.
The interim relief judge rules, in principle, within twenty days of the application (Article R. 551-5 of the French Code of Administrative Justice), following an adversarial but accelerated investigation. Throughout this period, the signing of the contract remains suspended.
It all comes down to timing. Pre-contractual interim relief (référé précontractuel) is available before the contract is signed: it is the most effective remedy, as the application automatically suspends signature. Contractual interim relief (référé contractuel), on the other hand, is only available after signature, within strict time limits (31 days following publication of the contract award notice, or 6 months otherwise) and with more limited effects.
Yes, provided that competitive tendering was required. Be careful, however: under a MAPA, no standstill period is imposed on the buyer, so the contract may be signed very shortly after the rejection decision — unless the buyer has itself committed to a period in the consultation documents, in which case it is bound to observe it. The unsuccessful bidder must therefore act without any delay, before the contract is concluded.
Pre-contractual interim relief is no longer available: the options are then contractual interim relief (référé contractuel), an action challenging the validity of the contract (Tarn-et-Garonne action) or a claim for damages. The choice depends on the applicable time limits and the seriousness of the irregularities identified.
Only breaches of advertising and competitive tendering obligations: insufficient advertising, irregular criteria, distortion of bids, breach of equal treatment, unjustified rejection of a bid deemed irregular… The court does not reassess the merits of the bids.
Yes. Article R. 3125-2 of the Public Procurement Code requires sixteen days between the sending of the rejection notification and the conclusion of the concession contract, reduced to eleven days where it is sent electronically to all interested candidates. An unsuccessful candidate for a concession or a public service delegation therefore has the same window in which to apply to the court for pre-contractual interim relief.
Pre-contractual interim relief is no longer possible, but contractual interim relief (référé contractuel) is available to you: the court may annul or terminate the contract, shorten its term or impose a financial penalty on the buyer (Article L. 551-20 of the Code of Administrative Justice). The application must be filed within 31 days of publication of the contract award notice.
No. The standstill period runs from the date on which the buyer sends the rejection notification, not from its receipt by the unsuccessful candidate. Postal delivery time therefore eats into your window for action, which argues for reacting immediately upon receipt of the rejection letter.
No. The court may order the buyer to comply with its obligations, or suspend or annul all or part of the procedure, but it cannot award the contract in the buyer's place. However, the resumed procedure gives you a fresh chance of winning.
This is strongly recommended in order to reconstruct the buyer's reasoning and target the right grounds, but it is often necessary to apply to the court at the same time, as the information requested may arrive after the contract has been signed. The unsuccessful candidate's right to information is therefore a key step before taking action.
Since the Smirgeomes case law, the applicant may only rely on breaches that are likely to have harmed it, i.e. that may have affected its chances of winning the contract. A purely theoretical defect is disregarded. This is often what makes the difference between an admissible application and one that is dismissed.
No. The standstill period is calculated in calendar days, from date to date, without being carried over to the next working day. If it ends on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday, the buyer may sign the contract from the next working day: the application for pre-contractual interim relief must therefore be filed before that deadline.
The application must be filed before the contract is signed. Under a formal procedure, the buyer observes a standstill period of 16 days (11 days if notified electronically) between notification of the rejection and signature: this is the window for taking action. Under the adapted procedure (MAPA), this period is not guaranteed, hence the urgency. We explain the right time to act in our guide “When to act in public procurement?”

Every situation deserves a clear, pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.