Home
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy

Frequently asked questions about our services

Frequently asked questions about our services
In-depth analyses, practical guides and legal commentary: explore all the publications by Novlaw's lawyers, at the crossroads of business law, real estate law and public law.
Filters
Categories
Clear filters
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

What should you do if a building permit or other authorisation is refused?

Public law

The law on simplifying planning and housing law of 26 November 2025 has profoundly changed appeal strategy. An informal appeal (recours gracieux) or hierarchical appeal must now be lodged within one month and, above all, it no longer extends the time limit for bringing proceedings before the court (Article L. 600-12-2 of the French Planning Code): applying to the administrative court within two months of notification of the refusal has become essential. In return, the administration can no longer rely on new grounds for refusal more than two months after the appeal has been registered (Article L. 600-2), and an application for suspension (référé-suspension) of a refusal benefits from a presumption of urgency (Article L. 600-3-1), making it possible to obtain a decision within a few weeks. An unlawful refusal may also give rise to compensation for the study costs incurred and the delay suffered, following a prior claim.

Is my car park subject to the obligation to install solar panels?

Public law

Article 40 of the APER Law of 10 March 2023 requires at least half of the surface area of outdoor car parks of more than 1,500 m² to be shaded. The timetable is staggered: the obligation has applied since 1 July 2026 to car parks of at least 10,000 m², and will apply from 1 July 2028 to those between 1,500 and 10,000 m². For car parks operated under a concession or public service delegation, the deadline is linked to the conclusion or renewal of the contract. The simplification law of 26 November 2025 relaxed the implementation arrangements: the obligation is deemed to be met by mixed solutions, provided that solar canopies cover at least 35% of the half to be shaded, the remainder being planted with vegetation. It also allowed a postponement upon proof of a commitment contract and prohibited the local urban plan (PLU) from obstructing these installations. Penalties can reach €40,000 per year.

Can an industrial or infrastructure project benefit from a fast-track procedure?

Public law

Yes, through classification as a project of major national interest (Article L. 300-6-2 of the French Planning Code, introduced by the Green Industry Law of 23 October 2023). The classification is made by decree. It allows the State itself to initiate and carry out the process of bringing planning documents into line with the project, adopted by decree, with the prior agreement of the mayor or the president of the EPCI (inter-municipal body), such agreement being deemed given in the absence of a response within one month. Planning authorisations are then issued by the State rather than by the municipality (Article L. 422-2 h)). The Conseil d'État exercises full review of this classification (CE, 6 February 2026, No. 500384). The mechanism, initially reserved for industrial projects, was extended by the Law of 16 August 2026 to infrastructure projects, data centres and defence projects.

What planning rules apply to the siting of a data centre?

Public law

From a planning perspective, the Order of 22 March 2023 classifies data centres in the 'warehouse' (entrepôt) sub-category of use. This classification determines whether building is permitted under the local urban plan (PLU), without, however, making the project liable for the charge on the creation of storage premises (CE, 11 October 2022, No. 463134). In the Île-de-France region, prefectoral approval is required above 5,000 m² of floor area (Articles R. 510-1 and R. 510-6 of the French Planning Code) and must be attached to the building permit application. From an environmental perspective, there is no ICPE (classified installations for environmental protection) heading specific to data centres: classification results from the technical equipment (generators, chillers, fuel oil tanks). Since Law No. 2026-791 of 16 August 2026, data centres may also be classified as projects of major national interest, subject to enhanced scrutiny in areas where water resources are under pressure.

Above what threshold is an energy project subject to an environmental assessment?

Public law

The table annexed to Article R. 122-2 of the French Environmental Code distinguishes three situations: systematic assessment, case-by-case review, or no formality below the thresholds. For ground-mounted photovoltaic installations, case-by-case review applies from 300 kWp; the threshold for systematic assessment, long set at 1 MWp, was raised to 3 MWp by Decree No. 2026-674 of 27 July 2026, for projects submitted to the competent authority since 28 July 2026. The environmental authority has thirty-five days to rule on a case-by-case review, its silence amounting to an obligation to carry out the assessment. Even below the thresholds, the safety-net clause in Article R. 122-2-1 allows the authority examining the application to subject a project to review. The stakes are high: a missing or manifestly inadequate impact assessment may give grounds for the court to suspend the authorisation (Article L. 122-2).

How do the building permit, environmental authorisation and ICPE regime fit together?

Public law

These are three separate authorisations, issued by different authorities, and their sequencing determines the project timetable. The environmental authorisation (Article L. 181-1 of the French Environmental Code) is a single permit that incorporates, among other things, the ICPE authorisation (classified installations for environmental protection), the protected species derogation, the Natura 2000 assessment and the land clearance authorisation. It does not dispense with the need for a building permit: the latter may be issued in parallel, but it cannot be implemented before the environmental authorisation has been obtained (Article L. 181-30). In practice, the review of an environmental authorisation application frequently takes more than a year, compared with three months for an ordinary building permit. Onshore wind turbines are an exception: they are exempt from planning authorisation (Article R. 425-29-2 of the French Planning Code) and are subject only to the environmental authorisation. Poorly calibrated sequencing is one of the leading causes of schedule overruns on renewable energy and industrial projects.

What planning authorisations are needed for a ground-mounted solar farm?

Public law

The regime depends on the peak power and height of the installation, according to the grid introduced by Decree No. 2024-1023 of 13 November 2024, applicable to applications filed since 1 December 2024. Ground-mounted installations and solar canopies of less than 3 kWp whose maximum height does not exceed 1.80 m are exempt from any formality (Article R. 421-2 c) of the French Planning Code). Installations of less than 3 kWp exceeding 1.80 m, as well as all those with a power output between 3 kWp and 3 MWp, regardless of height, require a prior declaration (Article R. 421-9 h)). Above 3 MWp, a building permit is required. Note: in remarkable heritage sites, in the vicinity of historic monuments and in listed sites, a building permit is once again required regardless of power output. A rooftop installation on an existing building, for its part, requires a prior declaration (Article R. 421-17).

Is a territorial digital twin subject to the GDPR and open data obligations?

Real estate

Frequently, yes, and the two approaches must be reconciled. Where sensors, meters or counting devices make it possible to re-identify individuals (consumption at household level, journeys, images), the GDPR applies and requires an impact assessment, data minimisation and aggregation. At the same time, the data produced by the local authority constitute administrative documents that may be subject to online publication obligations. The practical challenge is therefore to define contractually, at the outset, which data may be disseminated, at what level of granularity, and which are covered by the operator's trade secrets.

Is BIM compatible with a global contract or a design-and-build contract?

Real estate

It is in fact particularly well suited to them: having a single contractor simplifies the governance of the model and the chain of responsibility. Three points require contractual vigilance. First, the definition of the need must describe the expected BIM uses without locking in the technical solution, otherwise competition may be restricted. Second, as the model serves as the basis for performance commitments, its deliverables must be aligned with the performance objectives of the global contract. Finally, the allocation of rights over the data must be set from the tender stage, since all output is concentrated with a single operator.

What is the difference between a BIM charter, BIM specifications and a BIM agreement?

Real estate

These three documents follow one another in time and do not have the same scope. The BIM charter is a strategic document internal to the project owner: it sets out its ambitions, use cases and digital organisation, before any specific project. The BIM specifications translate these requirements into a given project and form part of the tender file. Finally, the BIM agreement is drawn up by the selected contributors to organise their collaboration in practice; it evolves at each stage of the project life cycle. In practice, only the last two are intended to become contractual.

How can several local authorities pool the purchase of a hypervisor or digital twin?

Innovation

An urban hypervisor or digital twin only makes sense at the scale of a catchment area: pooling is as much a technical requirement as a budgetary one. A purchasing group (groupement de commandes, Articles L. 2113-6 et seq. of the French Public Procurement Code) allows several buyers to award a single contract together, on the basis of a founding agreement that appoints a coordinator and allocates roles, signing arrangements and the financial burden. A central purchasing body (Articles L. 2113-2 et seq.) allows a buyer — often a joint energy syndicate or a département — to acquire or award contracts on behalf of other local authorities, which benefit from them without running their own procedure. A purchasing group requires converging needs and a common timetable; a central purchasing body offers more flexibility to join but locks in the technical solution to a greater extent. An open joint syndicate (syndicat mixte ouvert) remains the most robust vehicle for supporting shared digital infrastructure over the long term.

How can a solution be trialled (POC, demonstrator) before being rolled out across the whole territory?

Innovation

Three routes coexist and can be combined. Upstream, the sourcing provided for in Article R. 2111-1 of the French Public Procurement Code allows the local authority to consult operators and carry out market studies before launching the procedure, provided that competition is not distorted: the relevant information must then be communicated to all candidates. Next, a research and development contract may, subject to conditions relating to ownership of the results and funding, fall within the exclusions of Article L. 2512-5. Finally, the demonstrator may form the first phase of an innovation partnership or a global performance contract. The classic mistake is to accept a 'free' POC offered by a manufacturer: in addition to the risk of it being reclassified as an irregular contract, the trial creates a technical dependency that distorts subsequent competitive tendering.

What is the operating permit (permis d'exploitation) for selling alcohol?

Business law

The operating permit is compulsory training for anyone declaring the opening, change of ownership, relocation or transfer of a category 3 or 4 establishment selling drinks for consumption on the premises, or of a restaurant holding a 'petite licence restaurant' or a 'licence restaurant' (Art. L. 3332-1-1 of the French Public Health Code). It covers, in particular, the prevention of alcoholism, the protection of minors, the suppression of public drunkenness and noise control. It is delivered by approved bodies such as UMIH or the Chambers of Commerce and Industry (CCI). The permit is valid for 10 years, and a refresher course extends it for a further 10 years. For takeaway sales, no training is required during the day: only the sale of alcoholic beverages between 10 pm and 8 am requires specific training, leading to the permit for the night-time sale of alcoholic beverages (Art. L. 3331-4 of the same Code).

How can a building permit be challenged?

Real estate

A building permit is challenged before the administrative court, by means of an application for judicial review (recours pour excès de pouvoir), within two months from the first day of a continuous two-month period during which the notice has been properly displayed on the site. If the notice was displayed irregularly or not at all, a challenge remains possible for six months from completion of the works. Two admissibility conditions must be met: the applicant must demonstrate standing, i.e. a direct impact on the conditions of occupation, use or enjoyment of their property; and the challenge must be notified to the author of the decision and to its beneficiary within fifteen days of being filed, by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt. An informal appeal (recours gracieux) to the mayor remains possible, within one month, but it no longer extends the time limit for bringing proceedings for decisions taken on or after 28 November 2025 (Article L. 600-12-2 of the French Planning Code, introduced by the law on simplifying planning law of 26 November 2025). You should therefore not wait for the town hall's response before applying to the court. An application for suspension (référé-suspension) may be brought alongside the action on the merits to have the works halted.

Does the buyer of the business pay the company's debts?

Business law

In principle, no. However, the buyer must pay the outstanding instalments on loans secured by a security interest over the assets taken over, such as a pledge over the business (Article L. 642-12 of the French Commercial Code).

Is a court-appointed expert assessment needed before bringing proceedings?

Business law

It is strongly recommended. Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure allows a party to ask the summary proceedings judge to appoint an expert before any trial, if there is a legitimate reason. The expert measures the nuisance, identifies its source and costs the necessary works. The expert's report then serves as the basis for the action on the merits. In the event of a manifestly unlawful disturbance, the summary proceedings judge may also directly order measures to bring it to an end (Art. 835 of the same Code).

How can the applicable planning rules be frozen before starting a project?

Public law

By means of an operational planning certificate (certificat d'urbanisme opérationnel). Issued under Article L. 410-1 of the French Planning Code, it sets out the planning rules, the administrative limitations on property rights and the taxes payable, and states whether the proposed operation is feasible. Its main advantage is crystallisation: for eighteen months from its issue, an application for authorisation filed for the same land is examined in the light of the rules in force on the date of the certificate (CE, 18 December 2017, Danglot, No. 380438). There are only two exceptions: public safety and health rules, and the entry into force of a planning document that already justified a deferral of decision (sursis à statuer). The review takes two months for the operational certificate and one month for the information certificate, and the certificate may be extended for one year on application made two months before it expires.

What ERP (establishments open to the public) rules must a restaurant or hotel comply with?

Business law

To open a restaurant in France, you must comply with the standards for Establishments Open to the Public (ERP), which guarantee the safety and comfort of customers. This includes accessibility for people with reduced mobility, with ramps, wide doors and adapted toilets, as well as fire safety, with emergency exits, fire extinguishers and compliant materials. The maximum capacity must be calculated according to the floor area and displayed at the entrance, while the kitchen and storage areas must follow HACCP rules for food hygiene. Finally, technical installations such as electricity, gas and ventilation must comply with safety standards and be inspected regularly. Meeting all these obligations is essential to obtain authorisation to open and receive the public.

What rules apply to happy hour?

Business law

Happy hour is not prohibited, but it is regulated. A licensee offering alcoholic drinks at a reduced price for a limited period must also offer non-alcoholic drinks at a reduced price (Art. L. 3323-1 of the French Public Health Code), on equivalent terms and with equivalent advertising. Failing this, they face a 4th-class petty offence (contravention) (Art. R. 3351-2 of the same Code). Open bars, on the other hand, are prohibited: offering unlimited free alcohol for commercial purposes, or selling it as the main offer for a flat fee (Art. L. 3322-9). Finally, communication around happy hour must respect the limits set by the Évin Law on alcohol advertising.

How can a refusal to grant a building permit be challenged?

Real estate

The refusal must be challenged before the administrative court within two months of notification of the rejection decision. Where the decision does not mention the available remedies and time limits, this time limit is replaced by the reasonable time limit of one year established by the Conseil d'État, running from the date on which the addressee became aware of the decision (CE, Assemblée, 13 July 2016, Czabaj, No. 387763; CE, 9 November 2018, No. 409872). The challenge takes the form of an application for judicial review (recours pour excès de pouvoir). An informal appeal (recours gracieux) to the mayor remains possible, but within a shorter time limit of one month and, for decisions taken on or after 28 November 2025, without extending the time limit for bringing proceedings before the court (Article L. 600-12-2 of the French Planning Code, introduced by the law on simplifying planning law of 26 November 2025). It therefore does not remove the need to apply to the court within two months: the amicable route can only be secured by lodging both appeals in parallel. If the court annuls the refusal, it may, at the applicant's request, order the municipality to re-examine the application and, where the project complies with planning rules, to issue the building permit.

Can a contractor refuse to return your data at the end of a public contract?

Innovation

This is a major risk if the contract has been poorly drafted! To avoid it, the special administrative clauses (CCAP) must include a reversibility clause specifying the format, timeframe and costs (ideally zero) of returning the data and the associated source code.

Does a local authority become the owner of a website it has had developed by an agency?

Innovation

Not automatically! In the absence of an explicit and detailed copyright assignment clause in the public contract documents (CCAP), the agency retains the moral and economic rights in its creation. Applying the CCAG-TIC or CCAG-PI makes it possible to regulate these assignments, hence the importance of legal support before the procurement process begins.

Can a public authority let an AI take a decision on its own?

Innovation

Yes, it is legally possible, but strictly regulated. An individual administrative decision may be taken solely on the basis of an algorithm, unless that decision involves assessing a person's behaviour (prohibition of blind profiling). In addition, the administration must ensure that a human official has command of how the algorithmic system works and can explain it to the user.

Must a user be informed that an administrative decision was taken by an AI system?

Innovation

Yes, this is an absolute legal obligation (French Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration). The administration must explicitly inform the user when an individual decision (such as the award of a grant or an allocation) is based on algorithmic processing. The user has the right to request an explanation of the criteria and weighting used by the AI. Failure to include this notice renders the decision unlawful.

Must a user be informed that an administrative decision was taken by an AI system?

Innovation

Yes, this is a strict legal obligation. The French Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration (CRPA) requires the administration to explicitly inform the user when an individual decision is taken on the basis of algorithmic processing.

Let's talk about your project or situation

Every situation deserves a clear and pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.