Home
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Real estate

Lawyer specialising in the requalification of commercial leases

Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin

How do you have a derogatory lease requalified as a standard commercial lease?

Has your derogatory (short-term) lease continued beyond its statutory term? Do you want to have a commercial lease recognised and secure your right to remain in the premises? Our Paris law firm can assist you throughout any proceedings to have a derogatory lease requalified as a commercial lease.

The requalification of a short-term lease is a major issue for retailers, restaurateurs, members of the liberal professions, craftspeople and businesses wishing to protect their activity and benefit from the protective statutory regime for commercial leases.

When should you apply for requalification?

A derogatory lease, also known as a short-term lease (bail de courte durée), allows the landlord and tenant to opt out of the commercial lease regime for a maximum period of three years.

However, this exemption is strictly regulated by law.

Where the tenant remains in the premises after the lease expires without objection from the owner for more than one month, a commercial lease governed by the statutory regime automatically comes into being.

In this situation, the tenant may ask the tribunal judiciaire to confirm the existence of that commercial lease.

Our firm regularly acts in the following situations:

  • remaining in the premises after a derogatory lease has expired;
  • the landlord refusing to recognise the existence of a commercial lease;
  • disputes over the term of the lease;
  • challenges to the right to renewal;
  • a request to vacate the premises after several years of occupation;
  • disputes over occupancy indemnities.

What are the advantages of requalification as a commercial lease?

Recognition of a commercial lease offers the tenant particularly significant protection.

In particular, it provides:

  • a nine-year lease;
  • a right to renewal of the lease;
  • a right to remain in the premises;
  • an eviction indemnity if renewal is refused;
  • a higher valuation of the business (fonds de commerce);
  • long-term security for the commercial operation.

Prompt, carefully prepared action is essential to preserve your rights.

‍

Case law now very favourable to tenants

For many years, requalification actions faced significant difficulties arising from the rules on limitation periods.

The Cour de cassation (French Supreme Court) has gradually strengthened tenants' protection.

In a decision of 25 May 2023, it established a particularly favourable position: an action seeking a declaration that a commercial lease has arisen from the tenant remaining in the premises at the end of a derogatory lease is not subject to any limitation period.

This development in case law is an important strategic lever in defending the interests of businesses.

‍

How Baptiste Robelin, a lawyer specialising in commercial leases, can assist you

Each case requires an in-depth analysis of the contractual position and the available evidence.

We act at every stage of the procedure:

Legal audit of the lease

We analyse:

  • the initial derogatory lease;
  • any successive leases;
  • the expiry dates;
  • the rent receipts;
  • the correspondence exchanged;
  • evidence that the tenant remained in the premises.

Building the body of evidence

We gather all the evidence needed to demonstrate the existence of a commercial lease.

Negotiation with the landlord

In some cases, an amicable negotiation makes it possible to avoid lengthy and costly litigation.

Proceedings before the tribunal judiciaire

Where necessary, we bring the matter before the tribunal judiciaire to have the existence of the commercial lease confirmed and to defend your rights.

‍

Examples of derogatory lease requalification cases handled by Baptiste Robelin

Baptiste Robelin regularly acts for retailers, restaurateurs, companies and investors facing issues relating to remaining in the premises after a derogatory lease has expired.

In many cases, the aim is to have the existence of a commercial lease recognised so that the tenant can fully benefit from the protective statutory regime for commercial leases.

Obtaining recognition of a commercial lease and securing the tenant's business

Most cases concern situations in which the tenant has remained in the premises after its derogatory lease expired, while the landlord continued to accept this occupation by collecting the rent or allowing the contractual relationship to continue.

In this type of situation, recognition of a commercial lease gives the tenant numerous advantages:

  • the right to remain in the premises;
  • a lease with a term of nine years;
  • a right to renewal of the lease;
  • a possible eviction indemnity;
  • a higher valuation of the business;
  • long-term security for the company's operations.

Situations that are sometimes more favourable than a commercial lease concluded from the outset

Paradoxically, some requalification cases can result in a more advantageous position for the tenant than a commercial lease signed from the start.

Where the tenant remains in the premises under the conditions laid down in Article L.145-5 of the Code de commerce, a new commercial lease automatically comes into being.

The derogatory lease ceases to exist as an autonomous legal basis.

However, certain original clauses that are compatible with the commercial lease regime remain applicable, in particular:

  • the amount of the rent;
  • the rent review arrangements;
  • certain valid termination clauses;
  • provisions complying with mandatory rules of public policy.

Conversely, clauses contrary to the commercial lease regime cease to have effect.

A major strategic issue: the allocation of service charges and taxes

Requalification of the lease can have very significant financial consequences.

The regulations now require a precise and exhaustive inventory of the charges, taxes, levies and fees that may be recharged to the tenant.

Yet many landlords continue to claim charges that are not validly provided for in the contract.

Recent case law points out that:

  • the expired derogatory lease no longer forms the legal basis of the relationship between the parties;
  • the new commercial lease becomes the only applicable contract;
  • recharging service charges and property tax (taxe foncière) requires a clear and precise contractual provision;
  • in multi-occupancy property complexes, a defined allocation key is essential.

Failing this, the sums claimed may be challenged and recovered.

A sometimes considerable financial opportunity for the tenant

In some cases, the original derogatory lease does not provide for a sufficiently precise allocation of charges.

The tenant then enjoys a double advantage:

  • it obtains the protection of the commercial lease regime;
  • it may avoid paying certain charges that were not validly provided for in the contract.

The financial stakes can be particularly high, especially for businesses operating in property complexes or office buildings.

Have your situation reviewed by a commercial lease lawyer in Paris

Every case is unique and requires an in-depth analysis of the dates, the lease clauses and the conditions under which the tenant remained in the premises.

Baptiste Robelin, a lawyer specialising in commercial leases, advises businesses and retailers in Paris and throughout France, quickly determining whether a requalification action is possible and identifying the legal and financial benefits that may result from it.

A preliminary review of the lease and of the exchanges with the landlord often reveals negotiating levers or unused rights.

‍

Frequently asked questions on the requalification of a commercial lease

Can you apply for requalification several years after the derogatory lease has ended?

Yes. Since the Cour de cassation's decision of 25 May 2023, an action seeking a declaration that a commercial lease has arisen from the tenant remaining in the premises is no longer subject to a limitation period.

Can the landlord oppose requalification?

Yes, but only if it shows that it clearly and unequivocally expressed its intention to bring the occupation of the premises to an end.

Which documents should be provided?

The initial lease, rent receipts, payment statements, letters, emails and any document showing the landlord's implied consent.

Need a lawyer specialising in commercial lease requalification in Paris?

Our firm advises retailers, businesses, investors, restaurateurs and members of the liberal professions in all their commercial lease disputes.

Contact us for a tailored legal analysis of your situation and to find out quickly whether your derogatory lease can be requalified as a commercial lease.

‍

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on

No FAQ questions yet
Explore all our resources
No items found.

Let's talk about your project or situation

Every situation deserves a clear, pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.