HomePlanning law
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Public law

Planning and Building Permit Lawyer Val-de-Marne 94 – Orly, Rungis and the Marne valley

Contents
Our specialists
Laurent Bidault
Nicolas Machet

In the Val-de-Marne, the first question is almost never about the local plan (PLU).

Before the municipal regulations are even opened, a project must pass three filters: noise from Orly airport, the flood risk from the Seine and the Marne, and the land take of major infrastructure.

Many refusals in this department are based on easements that the project owner had not identified when acquiring the land. Laurent Bidault acts both upstream, to remove these uncertainties, and in litigation, to defend or challenge the authorisation, in planning law.

Three layers of constraints that decide before the PLU

The Orly noise exposure plan

The noise exposure plan (PEB), governed by Articles L. 112-3 et seq. of the code de l'urbanisme (French Planning Code), divides the territory into noise zones and limits urbanisation within them. In zones A and B, the construction of housing is in principle prohibited; in zone C, it is only permitted under strict urban renewal conditions, without any significant increase in the exposed population.

The Orly PEB, approved on 21 December 2012, is undergoing a revision procedure whose draft extends the constrained zones: any housing scheme launched in the south of the department must factor this into both its timetable and its risk analysis.

Flood risk and ground conditions

The banks of the Seine and the Marne, hillsides, near-surface groundwater: the Val-de-Marne is covered by flood risk prevention plans (PPRI), which constitute public interest easements and are binding on planning authorisations, with requirements on floor levels, hydraulic transparency and footprint. On top of this come clay shrinkage and swelling and, in places, former underground quarries. These easements can be consulted on the Géoportail de l'urbanisme.

A refusal based on Article R. 111-2 of the code de l'urbanisme, on grounds of public safety and health, is common in these areas. It can be challenged on the basis of an error of assessment, by disputing the reality and severity of the alleged risk.

Land take and procedures for major infrastructure

Line 14 extended to Orly, line 15 South from Villejuif to Champigny, the Orly-Rungis–Seine-Amont operation of national interest, the Rungis national wholesale market: the department is living through an era of major works.

This means declarations of public utility, land take and subsoil easements, mixed development zones (ZAC), delegations of the right of pre-emption and land transfers with obligations attached. Identifying which authority grants the authorisation – the municipality, the territorial public body (EPT) or the prefect – and on what basis is often the first step in the analysis.

Four profiles, four strategies

Developers and social landlords

Around the future stations, the pressure is twofold: densifying while complying with the PEB, the PPRI and social mix easements. We audit feasibility, secure the permit against challenge – posting, bailiff's report, deadlines – and defend the authorisation against appeals.

Logistics and agri-food

Around Rungis, Orly and the A86 and A6 motorways, warehouses and platforms combine planning law, classified installations (ICPE) and environmental assessment. The challenge is to coordinate the procedures and keep the applications consistent with one another: a contradiction between the impact assessment and the permit application is an open door to an appeal.

Local authorities, territorial public bodies and developers

Securing planning documents and development operations, defending refusals or decisions to defer a ruling (sursis à statuer), planning enforcement against unlawful construction.

Local residents, co-owners and associations

Challenging a permit that affects the conditions of occupation of a property, with a prior and honest assessment of standing to bring proceedings: in a department where projects follow one another in quick succession, not every appeal is admissible, and a poorly calibrated appeal creates exposure under Article L. 600-7 of the code de l'urbanisme.

Where planning disputes in the 94 are heard

Challenges are heard by the tribunal administratif de Melun (Melun Administrative Court), whose jurisdiction covers the Val-de-Marne and the Seine-et-Marne, and then, on appeal, by the cour administrative d'appel de Paris (Paris Administrative Court of Appeal).

Here again, as most municipalities in the department are in high-pressure housing areas (zone tendue), appeal is closed until 31 December 2027 for permits for residential buildings and development permits (Article R. 811-1-1 of the code de justice administrative). The court also has ten months to rule on challenges to a permit for more than two dwellings or a housing estate (Article R. 600-6 of the code de l'urbanisme): the litigation timetable is short, so preparation must be too.

Acting in Créteil, Rungis, Ivry and throughout the Val-de-Marne

Créteil, Vitry-sur-Seine, Ivry-sur-Seine, Villejuif, Rungis, Orly, Choisy-le-Roi, Champigny-sur-Marne, Saint-Maur-des-Fossés, Nogent-sur-Marne, Vincennes and the entire department.

Orly, Rungis and the Marne valley are part of a wider regional picture: our overview of planning in Paris and the Île-de-France region sets out the framework, and our Seine-et-Marne page covers the other department within the jurisdiction of the tribunal administratif de Melun.

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on

Planning law

What is the time limit for lodging an appeal on points of law against a judgment of an Administrative Court of Appeal?

The time limit for lodging an appeal on points of law (pourvoi en cassation) against a judgment of an Administrative Court of Appeal is two months from notification of the court's decision. However, this time limit is reduced to 15 days where the case concerns summary proceedings (référé).

How can a building permit be challenged?

A building permit is challenged before the administrative court, by means of an application for judicial review (recours pour excès de pouvoir), within two months from the first day of a continuous two-month period during which the notice has been properly displayed on the site. If the notice was displayed irregularly or not at all, a challenge remains possible for six months from completion of the works. Two admissibility conditions must be met: the applicant must demonstrate standing, i.e. a direct impact on the conditions of occupation, use or enjoyment of their property; and the challenge must be notified to the author of the decision and to its beneficiary within fifteen days of being filed, by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt. An informal appeal (recours gracieux) to the mayor remains possible, within one month, but it no longer extends the time limit for bringing proceedings for decisions taken on or after 28 November 2025 (Article L. 600-12-2 of the French Planning Code, introduced by the law on simplifying planning law of 26 November 2025). You should therefore not wait for the town hall's response before applying to the court. An application for suspension (référé-suspension) may be brought alongside the action on the merits to have the works halted.

What remedies are available against a building permit or prior declaration?

Third parties with standing, such as neighbours or associations, have two months from the first day of a continuous period of proper display of the notice on the site to apply to the administrative court. Two procedural rules determine admissibility: the challenge must be notified to the author of the decision and to its beneficiary within fifteen days of being filed, and standing must be established in detail. A decisive strategic point: since the law on simplifying planning law of 26 November 2025, an informal appeal (recours gracieux) no longer extends the time limit for bringing proceedings before the court for decisions taken on or after 28 November 2025. Waiting for the town hall's response therefore exposes you to the risk of being time-barred. Alongside the action on the merits, an application for suspension (référé-suspension) can be made to have the works halted.

What remedies are available against a refusal of a building permit?

Any refusal must state its legal and factual grounds. The first step is to analyse those grounds to determine whether they can be challenged in law or whether they reveal an obstacle that could be removed by amending the project. An application for judicial review (recours pour excès de pouvoir) must be lodged with the administrative court within two months of notification of the refusal. If the refusal is annulled, the court may order the administration to re-examine the application and, where the project complies with planning rules, to grant the authorisation. A point to watch: since the law on simplifying planning law of 26 November 2025, an informal appeal (recours gracieux), which must now be lodged within one month, no longer extends the time limit for bringing proceedings before the court. For decisions taken on or after 28 November 2025, you must apply directly to the court, or lodge both appeals at the same time.

What is the time limit for appealing a decision of an administrative court?

The time limit for appealing a decision of an administrative court (tribunal administratif) is two months from notification of the judgment. This time limit is only 15 days if the decision is an interim relief order (référé).

What is the right of retrocession?

If the local authority wishes to change the purpose or use of the property within 5 years of its acquisition, it must inform the former owner and offer them priority to acquire it. If the former owner declines, the local authority must inform the ousted prospective buyer named in the declaration of intention to sell (déclaration d'intention d'aliéner), and offer them priority to acquire the property.

What is the right to compel purchase (droit de délaissement)?

The right to compel purchase (droit de délaissement) is the right given to the owner of a property subject to a public utility easement (a reserved site in the local urban plan or PLU, an expropriation zone) to require the public authority to purchase the property. This right enables the owner to escape a deadlock caused by the public constraint weighing on their property. The authority then has one year in which to decide on the acquisition.

What is a carte communale?

The carte communale (municipal land-use map) is the equivalent of the PLU (local urban plan) for small municipalities that have chosen not to adopt one. It defines the areas where building is permitted, as well as the public utility easements affecting land use.

What is the commercial pre-emption right?

The commercial pre-emption right is a tool available to municipalities to combat the decline of town centres and ensure that local shops are maintained. The purpose of this pre-emption right is therefore to maintain or reintroduce diversity in local economic activity.

What is a prior declaration of works?

The prior declaration of works (déclaration préalable de travaux) is a planning authorisation that must be obtained before smaller-scale works begin. It is less demanding than a building permit and covers less significant construction and works. This declaration is mandatory and largely shares the procedural requirements of the building permit.

What is a building permit?

A building permit is a planning authorisation that must, in most cases, be obtained before works begin, whether to build, demolish or alter a structure, regardless of the type of owner or structure. It generally concerns new constructions and major alterations to existing buildings.

What is a SCOT?

The SCOT (Schéma de cohérence territoriale, territorial coherence scheme) is a long-term strategic inter-municipal planning document covering an urban area or a large living or employment area. It incorporates all higher-level planning documents; PLUs, PLUis and cartes communales therefore refer directly to the SCOT.

Can the municipality exercise its right of pre-emption?

Yes. If your property is located in a pre-emption zone (DPU), the municipality can take the place of the buyer when the Declaration of Intention to Sell (Déclaration d'Intention d'Aliéner, DIA) is signed. However, this decision must be strictly justified by a genuine development project in the general interest. We can assist you in challenging the lawfulness of the pre-emption or in negotiating the sale price before the expropriation judge.

Is a building permit required for a relay antenna?

A relay antenna requires a prior declaration where its footprint and floor area exceed 5 m² but do not exceed 20 m². A building permit is required if the antenna's footprint or floor area exceeds 20 m², or if the antenna is located within the boundaries of remarkable heritage sites (sites patrimoniaux remarquables) or in the vicinity of historic monuments and listed sites.

How can you ensure that a project complies with the PLU?

Before submitting an application, our firm carries out a thorough audit of your project against the rules of the Local Urban Plan (PLU) (zoning, height, footprint, parking). We can also apply for a planning certificate (certificat d'urbanisme, either detailed or informational) to freeze the rules applicable to your land.

What are the requirements for displaying a building permit?

Display on the site is mandatory whatever the operation, and whether the permit was granted expressly or tacitly. It takes the form of a rectangular sign visible from the public road, the content of which is set by the French Planning Code: identity of the beneficiary, date and number of the permit, nature of the project, area of the land, authorised floor area, height of the building, address of the town hall where the file can be consulted, and details of the means and time limits for challenging it. What is at stake is triggering the time limit for third-party challenges, which runs from the first day of a continuous two-month display period. Incomplete or interrupted display does not start that time limit running and leaves the project exposed to a late challenge: it is strongly advisable to have a commissaire de justice (judicial officer) draw up official reports at the beginning, during and at the end of the period.

What is the time limit for challenging a building permit?

Third parties have two months from the first day of a continuous two-month period of proper display of the sign on the site. Where the display was irregular or did not take place, this time limit does not run: a challenge remains possible for six months from completion of the works. Two points are decisive in practice. The challenge must be notified to the author of the decision and to its beneficiary within fifteen days of being lodged, failing which it will be inadmissible. And, for decisions taken on or after 28 November 2025, a request for reconsideration (recours gracieux) no longer extends the time limit for bringing court proceedings: you must therefore not wait for the town hall's response before applying to the administrative court.

What is the right of pre-emption?

The right of pre-emption is the power given to a local authority (or to a dedicated body) to acquire, as a priority and within certain previously defined areas, property being disposed of, with a view to carrying out operations in the public interest.

Is it compulsory to use an architect for a building permit?

Using an architect is the rule for any building permit application. The only notable exemption applies to individuals who build, or have built, for themselves a building whose floor area does not exceed 150 m², a threshold raised to 800 m² for agricultural buildings. A point often overlooked: this exemption does not apply to legal entities. A property holding company (SCI), including a family one, a property development company or a local authority must use an architect whatever the size of the project, failing which the application will be inadmissible.

Do you need a building permit for a conservatory (véranda)?

It depends on the area created and the location of the land. A conservatory is an extension: in an urban zone of a municipality covered by a PLU (local urban development plan), a prior declaration is sufficient up to 40 m² of floor area or footprint, and a building permit becomes mandatory above that. Everywhere else, the threshold is lowered to 20 m². Please note: in an urban zone, a building permit is again required from 20 m² where the extension brings the total floor area of the building above 150 m².

Do you need a building permit for a garage?

It depends on the size of the garage and its location. If it is attached to the existing building, it is an extension: prior declaration up to 40 m² in an urban zone of a municipality covered by a PLU, up to 20 m² elsewhere, and a building permit above that. If it is a detached garage, it is a new construction: no formalities up to 5 m², prior declaration from 5 to 20 m², building permit above 20 m². In an urban zone, a building permit is also required from 20 m² if the works bring the total floor area above 150 m².

Do you need a building permit to convert an attic?

Converting an attic is only subject to authorisation if it creates floor area or alters the external appearance of the building, for example by adding a roof window or a dormer. Where this is the case, a prior declaration is sufficient up to 40 m² of floor area created in an urban zone of a municipality covered by a PLU, and up to 20 m² elsewhere; above that, a building permit is required. In an urban zone, a building permit is also required from 20 m² if the works bring the total floor area of the building above 150 m².

How much does a building permit cost?

Filing the application is free: the town hall does not charge any processing fee. The real cost of a building permit lies in three items. First, planning taxes, chief among them the development tax (taxe d'aménagement), assessed on the taxable area using a flat-rate value per square metre revised each year, to which the rates voted by the municipality and the département apply; in Île-de-France, an office, retail or warehouse project is also subject to the charge for the creation of premises (redevance pour création de locaux). Second, design and project management fees, which vary according to the nature and complexity of the project. Finally, where applicable, the preventive archaeology levy. These items must be costed from the outset in the development appraisal: the development tax often represents an amount out of all proportion to the application costs.

What is the PLU?

The local urban development plan (Plan local d'urbanisme, PLU) sets the planning and building rules by dividing the territory into plots and zones with distinct legal regimes. For each plot, it shows the applicable planning rules as well as easements, access to utility networks and to the public road, and whether or not the plot can be built on.

Do you need a building permit for a swimming pool?

No, in most cases. A pool with a surface area of 10 m² or less is exempt from any formalities, except in a protected area. Between 10 m² and 100 m², a prior declaration is sufficient. A building permit is only required for a pool of more than 100 m². It is also required, whatever the surface area of the pool, where the pool is covered by a shelter more than 1.80 metres high. These thresholds do not exempt the project from complying with the PLU, which may lay down its own rules on siting, setbacks and footprint.

How can the designated use (destination) of a property be changed?

A change of designated use requires, at a minimum, a prior declaration. If the accompanying works alter the load-bearing structures or the façade of the building, a building permit is required. Two useful points. The French Planning Code distinguishes five uses and twenty sub-uses: moving from one sub-use to another within the same use is not, in itself, a change of use requiring authorisation, although the PLU may regulate it. In addition, certain changes of use are subject to a binding opinion, in particular that of the CDPENAF (commission for the preservation of natural, agricultural and forest areas) for a building located in an agricultural zone.

How can a pre-emption decision be challenged?

The owner and the ousted buyer may attempt to challenge the pre-emption decision. Before bringing litigation, it is possible to lodge a prior informal appeal (recours gracieux) with the holder of the pre-emption right within 2 months of notification of the decision. If the informal appeal is rejected by the holder, a contentious appeal must then be lodged with the administrative court within 2 months.

Explore all our resources
No items found.

The countdown starts when the permit is posted

Two months of continuous posting on site, and the deadline for third-party appeals runs from the first day of that period. In the Val-de-Marne, a poorly completed sign or one removed too early is enough to reopen the deadline. Have the posting checked before starting works.