

Estate agencies regularly face situations in which their commission is disputed or remains unpaid despite the work they have done. Refusal to pay after a preliminary sale agreement has been signed, the agency being bypassed, breach of a sole agency mandate, a seller or buyer wrongfully pulling out: disputes over fees are numerous.
Novlaw assists estate agencies, franchise networks, agents and property managers in recovering their fees and defending their rights throughout France.
With recognised experience in real estate law and contract law, Maître Baptiste Robelin acts both at the pre-litigation stage and in proceedings before the civil and commercial courts.
The remuneration of estate agents is strictly governed by the loi Hoguet of 2 January 1970 (the French law regulating estate agents).
However, contrary to a common misconception, an estate agency can sometimes obtain compensation even when the sale ultimately did not go through.
Several situations arise regularly:
Where the seller pulls out even though all the conditions for completing the sale are met, the agency can take action to obtain compensation for the loss suffered.
Depending on the circumstances, the courts may order the seller to compensate the estate agency.
A buyer who does not take the steps needed to obtain financing, or who wrongfully withdraws, may be held liable.
The estate agency can then claim compensation for the loss of the opportunity to receive its commission.
Sellers who complete a sale directly without going through the agency holding a sole agency mandate expose themselves to substantial awards against them.
The agency can seek enforcement of the penalty clause in the mandate or claim damages.
It is not unusual for a seller or buyer to try to finalise a transaction directly after being introduced by the agency.
Such conduct may render them liable and enable the agency to obtain compensation.
Fee disputes require a thorough command of:
The success of a claim often depends on technical details:
A thorough analysis of the file is therefore essential before bringing any proceedings.
Depending on the circumstances of the case, several routes may be considered.
Where the statutory conditions are met, the agency can claim payment of its fees in full.
The agency can hold the seller liable where the seller wrongfully prevented the transaction from going ahead.
The buyer may also be ordered to pay compensation where it has abusively obstructed the sale.
Sole agency mandates often include clauses allowing the agency to claim a fixed indemnity if the principal breaches its commitments.
Disputes over estate agency fees give rise to extensive and evolving case law.
A poorly brought claim can lead to dismissal, even where the agency's claim appears legitimate in principle.
Instructing a lawyer makes it possible in particular to:
For more than fifteen years, Maître Baptiste Robelin has been assisting property professionals with their transactions and disputes.
He regularly acts for:
In particular, he has obtained several favourable decisions enabling estate agencies to recover their fees or obtain compensation after a seller or buyer wrongfully defaulted (a recent decision before the tribunal judiciaire de Chartres, and before the cour d’appel de Bordeaux (Bordeaux Court of Appeal), among others).
His expertise in contract law, real estate law and commercial litigation is a major asset in effectively defending the interests of property intermediaries.
Can an estate agency be paid if the sale is not signed?
Yes, in certain situations. Where a party has wrongfully prevented the sale from going ahead, compensation may be obtained before the courts.
Can the seller sell directly despite a sole agency mandate?
No. Doing so may render the seller liable and lead to an indemnity being paid to the agency.
Is a penalty clause valid in an estate agency mandate?
Yes, provided it is properly drafted and complies with the statutory requirements.
What is the time limit for taking action?
Claims relating to estate agency fees are subject to limitation periods that should be analysed promptly to avoid any claim becoming time-barred.
Is your estate agency facing a refusal to pay commission, breach of a sole agency mandate or attempts to bypass your involvement?
Novlaw assists you in analysing your file, serving formal notice on the parties concerned and conducting the proceedings needed to obtain payment of your fees or compensation for your loss.
Maître Baptiste Robelin acts throughout France to defend the interests of estate agencies and transaction professionals.
Baptiste Robelin has worked alongside real estate professionals for many years. His practice covers in particular: - disputes relating to real estate mandates; - the recovery of commissions; - disputes under the Hoguet Act (loi Hoguet); - liability claims against defaulting sellers or buyers; - proceedings before the judicial courts and the economic activity courts (tribunaux des activités économiques). This dual expertise in real estate law and contract law makes it possible to build effective strategies to maximise the chances of recovering fees.
No. Many disputes can be resolved through a formal notice drafted by a lawyer or through amicable negotiation. A lawyer's involvement often makes it possible to obtain prompt payment without court proceedings.
No. The court retains the power to reduce or increase a penalty clause where it considers the amount to be manifestly excessive or derisory. The mandate should therefore be reviewed before bringing any proceedings.
The applicable time limit depends on the nature of the action brought. In most cases, civil liability actions become time-barred five years from the day on which the agency knew or should have known the facts enabling it to bring its action. It is nevertheless advisable to act quickly in order to preserve evidence.
The real estate agency must keep all the evidence demonstrating its involvement: - sale mandate; - viewing slips (bons de visite); - emails; - text messages; - purchase offers; - viewing reports; - preliminary sale agreement (compromis de vente); - any witness statements. These documents are often decisive before the courts.
Yes. Where an agency played a decisive role in bringing the parties together and they then try to bypass its involvement, they may be held liable. The courts regularly penalise such practices aimed at avoiding payment of the commission.
Breach of an exclusive mandate may result in the seller being ordered to pay damages or the penalty clause provided for in the mandate being applied. The amount of compensation depends on the contractual terms and the circumstances of the case.
Yes. Where a buyer's wrongful conduct has prevented the sale from going through, the agency may bring a liability claim. This may be the case, in particular, where the buyer fails to take the steps necessary to obtain their loan or withdraws unfairly after having expressed their agreement.
Yes. Where a seller accepts an offer on the property and the price and then refuses to proceed with the sale without legitimate reason, they may incur liability. In some cases, the courts have ordered the seller to compensate the real estate agency for the loss of the chance to receive its fees.
In principle, Article 6 of the Hoguet Act (loi Hoguet) prohibits an estate agent from receiving a commission until the transaction has actually been concluded and recorded in a deed containing the parties' commitment. However, where the sale fell through due to the fault of the seller or the buyer, the real estate agency may obtain compensation on the basis of civil liability. This compensation is not a commission but redress for the loss suffered.
