Home
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Real estate

Lawyer for changing the permitted use of a commercial lease

Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin

Would you like to carry on a new activity in your commercial premises? Add a complementary activity? Turn your shop into a restaurant, medical practice, gym or dark kitchen?

Changing the permitted use of a commercial lease is strictly regulated by the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce). A procedural error can have serious consequences: refusal by the landlord, a claim to terminate the lease, a rent increase or court proceedings.

Baptiste Robelin assists retailers, entrepreneurs, investors and companies in all procedures for changing the permitted use of a commercial lease.

Why instruct a lawyer to change the permitted use of your commercial lease?

The commercial lease specifies exactly which activities are authorised in the premises.

This is known as the “permitted use” of the lease (destination du bail).

In principle, the tenant may not carry on an activity other than that provided for in the lease without following a specific procedure.

A lawyer can help you to:

  • analyse the clauses of the commercial lease;
  • determine whether the change is a partial or a full change of use (déspécialisation partielle or plénière);
  • secure the notices served on the landlord;
  • negotiate an amicable agreement;
  • anticipate the financial consequences;
  • represent you in the event of a dispute.

The aim is simple: to obtain the necessary authorisation while securing your business.

‍

Partial change of use: adding an activity to your business

A partial change of use allows the tenant to add a related or complementary activity to the activity already carried on.

Some examples:

  • a bakery that develops a tea room;
  • a shop that adds online sales with in-store collection;
  • a restaurant that develops a delicatessen;
  • a practice that adds professional training.

Partial change of use is provided for by Article L. 145-47 of the Code de commerce, which states that:

“The tenant may add related or complementary activities to the activity provided for in the lease.”

The tenant must notify the landlord of their intention by extrajudicial act served by a judicial officer (commissaire de justice), or by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, stating the activities they intend to carry on.

This notice serves as formal notice to the landlord to state, within two months and on pain of forfeiture, whether they dispute the related or complementary nature of those activities. Once that period has expired without any challenge, the landlord can no longer dispute it.

Note, however: at the first three-yearly rent review following the notice, the landlord may ask for the added activities to be taken into account in setting the rent, if they have in themselves changed the rental value of the premises.

This is why it is advisable to seek a lawyer's advice in order to negotiate with the landlord so that they waive any request for a rent increase. This undertaking must be recorded in writing or in a contract.

To draft the notice, use our template letter for a partial change of use.

Good to know: an activity may already fall within the permitted use of the lease, given changing commercial practice; in that case no change of use is required. The Cour de cassation (French Supreme Court) accepted this for a café-brasserie near the Palace of Versailles that sold admission tickets to the palace, a service offered to customers by all the neighbouring bar-restaurants (Cass. 3e civ., 16 septembre 2015, n° 14-18.708, published in the Bulletin). By contrast, turning a traditional restaurant into a dark store or dark kitchen is in principle a full change of use requiring the landlord's consent and, where applicable, authorisation from the town hall.

‍

Full change of use: changing activity entirely

A full change of use concerns more significant changes. It applies where the tenant abandons the activity originally provided for in favour of a new one.

For example:

  • turning a clothing shop into a restaurant;
  • turning commercial premises into a medical practice;
  • converting a restaurant into a dark kitchen;
  • replacing a craft activity with a service activity.

This procedure is more complex.

A complete change of the activity provided for in the lease is governed by Article L. 145-48 of the Code de commerce. It is known as a “full change of use” (déspécialisation plénière):

“The tenant may, at their request, be authorised to carry on in the leased premises one or more activities different from those provided for in the lease, having regard to the economic situation and the requirements of the rational organisation of distribution, where those activities are compatible with the use, character and location of the building or property complex.”

As can be seen, it is more difficult to request, since the tenant is expected to give specific reasons relating to the economic situation, while checking that the activity is compatible with the use of the building and, of course, with the co-ownership regulations.

It is, however, possible to avoid the cumbersome formalities laid down in the Code de commerce by reaching an amicable agreement with the landlord (also known as a change-of-use amendment).

To start the statutory procedure, see our template request for a full change of use.

Here again, the tenant will need to anticipate the financial consequences of such a request: in addition to an increase in the commercial rent, the landlord may also claim a change-of-use indemnity (i.e. a sum intended to compensate them for the change of activity).

A lawyer experienced in commercial leases will be useful in negotiating with the landlord to convince them that the change of activity is also in their interest. Allowing the tenant to adapt their business to the economic situation also means avoiding a defaulting tenant unable to pay the rent.

‍

What are the risks of an unauthorised change of activity?

Carrying on an activity not provided for in the lease is a breach of contract.

The landlord may, in particular:

  • demand that the new activity cease;
  • seek termination of the lease;
  • refuse to renew the lease;
  • claim damages;
  • bring court proceedings.

Before making any change, it is therefore essential to check that the project complies.

‍

Can the landlord increase the rent?

Yes. A change of activity can have significant economic consequences.

The landlord may seek:

  • a rent increase;
  • a change-of-use indemnity;
  • the renegotiation of certain clauses of the lease.

Early negotiation often helps to avoid deadlock.

What if the landlord refuses to change the permitted use under the lease?

If the landlord refuses to change the permitted use, judicial authorisation can be sought by summoning the landlord before the competent court (the tribunal judiciaire where the property is located). Representation by a lawyer is mandatory for this type of procedure. These are also proceedings on the merits (summary proceedings are not available in this situation) that may take several months, which the tenant must plan for.

Can the landlord be forced to accept a change of activity under a commercial lease?

It is indeed possible to compel the landlord to accept a change to the activity provided for in the lease, in particular when the tenant retires.

This is known as “cession-déspécialisation” (assignment with change of use), provided for by Article L. 145-51 of the Code de commerce.

This provision is designed to help tenants assign their lease on the best possible terms when they wish to bring their business to an end (whether on retirement or in the event of disability).

If the new activity is compatible with the use of the building, the landlord cannot oppose the tenant's request to change the activity provided for in the commercial lease. The landlord may, however, exercise a right of pre-emption over the lease and acquire it in place of the proposed assignee.

To start the procedure, see our template notice of assignment with change of use on retirement.

For landlords wishing to challenge the proposed activity, see our template summons opposing an assignment with change of use.

‍

How Baptiste Robelin can help you change the permitted use of a commercial lease

Baptiste Robelin, a lawyer specialising in commercial leases, regularly assists retailers, entrepreneurs, restaurateurs, healthcare professionals, investors and business owners who wish to change the activity provided for in their lease.

He acts both on partial changes of use (adding a related or complementary activity) and on full changes of use (a complete change of activity).

Each case requires a thorough analysis of the commercial lease, the constraints of the building and the financial consequences the landlord may raise.

Full support at every stage of the procedure

Baptiste Robelin supports his clients throughout the matter in order to secure the proposed change of activity legally.

His work includes:

  • analysing the commercial lease and the permitted use clauses;
  • preparing the supporting documents;
  • drafting the requests for a change of activity;
  • preparing the notices to the landlord, by registered letter or served by a judicial officer;
  • negotiating with the landlord;
  • negotiating any amendment to the commercial lease;
  • challenging unjustified demands for a rent increase or a change-of-use indemnity.

The aim is to enable the tenant to develop their business while limiting legal and financial risks.

Preliminary analysis of the commercial lease

Before taking any steps, Baptiste Robelin carries out a full review of the commercial lease in order to identify:

  • the permitted use of the premises;
  • the activities already authorised;
  • contractual restrictions;
  • specific clauses;
  • constraints relating to the building or the co-ownership regulations;
  • the legal risks specific to the case.

This analysis determines the applicable procedure and anticipates any difficulties.

Implementing the change-of-activity procedure

Baptiste Robelin prepares and secures all the necessary steps, including:

  • the mandatory notices;
  • exchanges with the landlord;
  • draft amendments to the commercial lease;
  • the legal arguments justifying the change of activity.

Particular attention is paid to the economic consequences of the change of activity in order to limit the risk of an abusive renegotiation of the rent.

Negotiating with the landlord to avoid litigation

In most situations, a negotiated solution can be found.

Baptiste Robelin favours a pragmatic approach that quickly secures the tenant's position while preserving the relationship with the landlord.

He acts in particular where the landlord:

  • refuses the change of activity;
  • seeks an excessive rent increase;
  • claims a disproportionate change-of-use indemnity;
  • imposes unjustified conditions.

Challenging an unreasonable refusal by the landlord before the tribunal judiciaire

Where negotiations fail, Baptiste Robelin can represent his clients before the tribunal judiciaire (civil court).

He acts in particular to:

  • challenge an unjustified refusal to change the activity provided for in the commercial lease;
  • seek judicial authorisation;
  • challenge an unjustified rent increase;
  • defend the tenant's interests in litigation relating to a change of use of the commercial lease.

Each case is handled with a strategy tailored to the economic stakes and the specific constraints of the proposed activity.

‍

Frequently asked questions about changing the activity of a commercial lease

Can I add an activity without the landlord's consent?

Not always.

It all depends on the wording of the lease and the nature of the new activity.

How long does the procedure take?

A few weeks if an amicable agreement is reached, several months in the event of litigation.

Can the landlord refuse?

Yes, in certain situations provided for by law.

Each case requires a preliminary analysis.

Should the commercial lease be amended?

In many cases, signing an amendment is recommended to secure the position definitively.

Would you like to change the permitted use of your commercial lease?

Every project involves significant financial stakes.

A preliminary analysis makes it possible to anticipate risks, secure the procedure and negotiate effectively with the landlord.

Contact NOVLAW to review your situation and implement the strategy best suited to your project.

‍

‍

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on

No FAQ questions yet
Explore all our resources
No items found.

Let's talk about your project or situation

Every situation deserves a clear and pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.