HomeCommercial lease
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Real estate

Dispute with a commercial landlord: get support from a commercial lease lawyer

Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin

A dispute with a commercial landlord can jeopardise the running of your business, strain your cash flow and threaten the long-term future of your business (fonds de commerce).

Whether it concerns a disagreement over rent, service charges, works, lease renewal, termination or eviction proceedings, commercial lease disputes require a swift and effective legal strategy.

Instructing a commercial lease dispute lawyer allows you to defend your interests, secure your business and limit financial and legal risks.

Why use a lawyer in a dispute with a commercial landlord?

A commercial lease is a complex contract governed by strict rules under the Code de commerce.

In a dispute with the owner of the premises, a lawyer can help you:

  • analyse your rights and obligations;
  • negotiate an amicable solution;
  • challenge unjustified claims;
  • avoid termination of the lease;
  • preserve the value of your business;
  • defend you in court.

Commercial lease dispute lawyer: our areas of work

Disputes over payment of rent and service charges

Disputes over commercial rents are frequent, particularly in cases of:

  • excessive rent increases;
  • unjustified service charge adjustments;
  • disagreement over indexation;
  • financial difficulties on the tenant's part.

Your lawyer can:

  • analyse the commercial lease;
  • challenge unjustified sums;
  • negotiate a payment schedule;
  • seek an amicable solution;
  • defend your interests in court.

Disputes over works and repairs

A commercial lease may provide for a complex allocation of works between landlord and tenant.

The firm can assist you in particular with disputes concerning:

  • compliance works;
  • major repairs;
  • the dilapidated condition of the premises;
  • the landlord's obligations;
  • co-ownership charges;
  • works affecting the running of the business.

Commercial lease termination proceedings

The landlord may bring termination proceedings, in particular for:

  • unpaid rent;
  • failure to maintain insurance;
  • breach of the lease clauses;
  • a change of business activity;
  • disturbances linked to the business.

Your lawyer can:

  • challenge a termination clause;
  • negotiate time to pay;
  • avoid eviction;
  • defend your business before the tribunal judiciaire.

Refusal to renew the commercial lease

Lease renewal is an essential issue in preserving the value of the business.

The firm can assist you in cases of:

  • refusal to renew;
  • disagreement over the eviction indemnity;
  • negotiation of the new lease;
  • challenges to a notice to quit served by the landlord.

Disputes on the sale of a business

Some landlords try to block or complicate the sale of a business (fonds de commerce).

Your lawyer secures:

  • the assignment of the commercial lease;
  • the necessary authorisations;
  • relations with the landlord;
  • the transfer of the business.

Dedicated expertise for retailers and the hospitality sector

The firm regularly advises:

  • restaurants;
  • bars;
  • cafés;
  • hotels;
  • bakeries;
  • franchises;
  • food retailers;
  • local shops;
  • businesses in the hospitality sector (hotels, cafés, restaurants).

Each case benefits from a strategy tailored to the economic stakes of the business concerned.

Why act quickly in a dispute with a landlord?

Preventing the dispute from escalating

A dispute that is not dealt with quickly can lead to:

  • court proceedings;
  • financial penalties;
  • termination of the lease;
  • loss of customers;
  • deterioration of cash flow.

Acting quickly often makes it possible to favour an amicable resolution.

Preserving the value of the business

The commercial lease is an essential component of the value of the business.

Badly managed proceedings can jeopardise:

  • the resale of the business;
  • a future sale;
  • the profitability of the business;
  • the stability of operations.

Defending your interests effectively

Support from a lawyer makes it possible to put in place a suitable strategy:

  • amicable negotiation;
  • mediation;
  • court proceedings;
  • interim relief (référé);
  • court-ordered expert assessment.

Baptiste Robelin's expertise in commercial lease disputes

For almost 15 years, Baptiste Robelin has advised retailers, restaurateurs and hospitality professionals in commercial lease disputes.

The firm acts in particular in:

  • commercial tenancy litigation;
  • termination proceedings;
  • rent disputes;
  • disputes over works;
  • lease renewals;
  • litigation relating to the sale of businesses.

This expertise is built on a thorough understanding of the operational issues faced by retailers and operators.

Related document templates

Have you been served with an eviction order and lodged an appeal? Use our template summons in summary proceedings to stay provisional enforcement, ready to copy and paste and annotated by our lawyers. Find all our templates on our free document templates page.

Fees for a commercial lease dispute

Fees depend in particular on:

  • the complexity of the dispute;
  • the negotiations to be conducted;
  • any court proceedings;
  • the financial stakes;
  • the urgency of the matter.

A clear and transparent fee agreement is always drawn up before any work begins.

FAQ – Disputes with a commercial landlord

Can you challenge a commercial rent increase?

Yes, where it does not comply with the statutory or contractual rules. On a three-yearly review, the increase is in principle capped at the change in the index (Article L.145-38 of the Code de commerce); on renewal, the rent is also capped, subject to exceptions (Article L.145-34).

How can you avoid eviction from commercial premises?

By reacting as soon as you receive the order to pay (commandement de payer). Since the Law of 26 May 2026, the court may only grant time to pay and suspend the termination clause if the tenant shows that it is able to pay its debt and has resumed full payment of current rent before the first hearing. You should therefore resume payment without delay and prepare supporting documents.

The landlord refuses to renew the lease: what are my rights?

Save in particular for serious and legitimate grounds, the landlord must pay an eviction indemnity covering the loss caused by the failure to renew (Article L.145-14 of the Code de commerce). A tenant entitled to it cannot be required to leave the premises before receiving it (Article L.145-28).

Who has to pay for major works?

Major repairs within the meaning of Article 606 of the Code civil cannot be charged to the tenant (Article R.145-35 of the Code de commerce). The landlord also remains bound to deliver premises fit for the use provided for in the lease.

Can the landlord object to the sale of my business?

A clause prohibiting the assignment of the lease to the buyer of the business is deemed unwritten (Article L.145-16 of the Code de commerce). The lease may, however, provide for formalities, such as the landlord's participation in the deed, which must be complied with.

What is the time limit for taking action against the landlord?

Actions based on the commercial lease regime are in principle time-barred after two years (Article L.145-60 of the Code de commerce). It is therefore important to seek advice quickly.

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on

Commercial lease

Can the landlord object to the assignment of the commercial lease?

The lease may prohibit the assignment of the leasehold right on its own. However, the landlord cannot prohibit the assignment of the lease together with the business (art. L. 145-16 C. com.), although it may make it subject to its approval or to formalities. An irregular assignment exposes the tenant to termination of the lease without eviction compensation.

Which court has jurisdiction over commercial lease matters?

The judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) for the place where the premises are located. Disputes over the amount of revised or renewed rent fall to the commercial rent judge. Urgent measures, such as an expert assessment or an interim payment, are sought from the interim relief judge.

What can be done about unpaid commercial rent?

The landlord has a formal demand for payment served, referring to the termination clause. If payment is not made within one month, the landlord applies to the interim relief judge to have the termination of the lease recorded, obtain an interim payment and secure the tenant's eviction. The landlord may also call on the guarantees provided for in the lease.

Can the landlord increase the rent during the lease?

Yes, within a specific framework. Every three years, the revision is in principle capped at the change in the ILC or ILAT index. The cap no longer applies if a material change in local commercial factors has caused the rental value to vary by more than 10% (Art. L. 145-38 C. com.). A sliding-scale clause may also index the rent annually.

How is eviction compensation calculated?

In principle, it corresponds to the market value of the business, plus removal and relocation costs and transfer duties (Art. L. 145-14 C. com.). Where the tenant can relocate nearby without losing its customers, it is instead calculated on the basis of the value of the leasehold right (droit au bail).

Can a commercial lease be terminated early?

Yes. The tenant may give notice at the end of each three-year period, unless there is a valid clause to the contrary. The parties may also agree to an amicable termination at any time, and a tenant who retires has a specific right of termination. Otherwise, rent remains payable until the end of the term.

How much does it cost to have a commercial lease drafted by a lawyer?

The cost depends on the complexity of the lease: simple premises or a property complex, regulated activity, lengthy negotiation or not. It is set on a fixed-fee or time-spent basis, always with a prior quote. Landlord and tenant are free to share these costs between them.

Which lawyer should you choose for a commercial lease?

Choose a lawyer who handles commercial leases on a daily basis, in both advisory and litigation work, and who knows the courts where the premises are located. Check that they act for landlords as well as tenants, that they can be reached quickly and that they give you a quote before starting work.

Explore all our resources
No items found.

Contact a commercial lease dispute lawyer

Are you in dispute with your commercial landlord? Baptiste Robelin can help you defend your interests, secure your business and find a solution suited to your situation. Contact the firm for tailored support in commercial lease disputes and commercial law.