HomeHospitality (hotels and restaurants)
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Real estate

Lawyer for challenging a co-ownership's refusal to install kitchen extraction

Restaurateur face aux copropriétaires opposés à l'installation d'une gaine d'extraction, avec un marteau de juge symbolisant le recours en justice
Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin

Has the co-ownership refused your kitchen extraction system? There are remedies.

Are you planning to open a restaurant, bakery, pâtisserie, dark kitchen or food production unit, or to develop a business that requires a fume extraction system, only for the co-ownership to reject your project?

This refusal is not always final, nor always legally justified.

Our firm assists restaurateurs, retailers, investors and operators in challenging a co-ownership's refusal and, where necessary, in obtaining court authorisation to install an extraction duct.

A refusal by the general meeting does not necessarily prevent the works from going ahead.

To find out more, watch the video on Baptiste Robelin's YouTube channel about the remedies available to restaurants when the co-ownership refuses to allow an extraction system :

A co-ownership's refusal is not always justified

Installing an extraction system usually affects the common parts of the building (drilling, a duct on the façade or in an inner courtyard, passing through the roof) and must therefore be authorised by the general meeting. But the co-ownership does not have a right of veto: its refusal must be based on objective grounds, such as incompatibility with the co-ownership rules, insufficiently controlled nuisance or an incomplete technical file.

We analyse these grounds and recent case law in our article When can a co-ownership refuse the installation of an extraction duct?. A purely arbitrary refusal, on the other hand, can be challenged in two ways.

First remedy: having the refusal annulled for abuse of majority

A co-owner who voted against the decision, or who was neither present nor represented, may apply to the tribunal judiciaire to have it annulled. They have two months from notification of the minutes of the general meeting to do so (Article 42 of the Law of 10 July 1965). After this period, the refusal becomes final.

The decision may be annulled where it amounts to an abuse of majority, that is, where it was taken:

  • for a purpose other than preserving the collective interest of the co-owners (Civ. 3e, 8 February 1989, No. 87-14.322);
  • in breach of equality between co-owners, to the benefit of the majority (Civ. 3e, 17 December 2014, No. 13-25.134; Civ. 3e, 9 June 2016, No. 15-17.529);
  • or with intent to cause harm (Civ. 3e, 29 November 2011, No. 10-28.146).

The Pau Court of Appeal thus upheld the annulment of a refusal to install an extraction duct, on the grounds that it was not based on legitimate reasons, was not justified by the collective interest and prevented works necessary for a unit whose business was authorised by the co-ownership rules (CA Pau, 4 September 2018, No. 16/01469). However, a refusal cannot be annulled merely because it is unfair or inappropriate.

Second remedy: obtaining court authorisation for the works

Independently of any annulment, Article 30, paragraph 4, of the Law of 10 July 1965 allows a co-owner to ask the tribunal judiciaire for authorisation to carry out works that the general meeting has refused. The court then sets the conditions under which they are to be carried out.

In particular, it checks:

  • that the project complies with the intended use of the building and the co-ownership rules;
  • that it does not infringe the rights of the other co-owners;
  • its aesthetic impact, particularly for protected buildings;
  • that noise and odour nuisance is controlled;
  • the structural soundness of the building.

The court will refuse authorisation if the conditions for carrying out the works remain undetermined, in particular as regards the nuisance they cause (Civ. 3e, 20 July 1999, No. 98-11.663). The success of the application therefore depends first and foremost on the quality of the technical file, prepared with an architect or an engineering consultancy.

Both remedies can be pursued together. In any event, installing an extraction system despite the refusal, without a court decision, exposes you to an order to remove it.

Which businesses are concerned?

We regularly act on projects involving:

  • restaurants;
  • bakeries;
  • pâtisseries;
  • food retailers;
  • food production units;
  • dark kitchens;
  • fast-food outlets;
  • professional kitchens.

How do you challenge a co-ownership's refusal?

1. Analyse the co-ownership rules

The first step is to check:

  • the clauses on the use of the units;
  • the intended use of the building;
  • any restrictions on commercial activities;
  • the rules applicable to works.

2. Put together a robust technical file

An incomplete file very often leads to a refusal.

We work with the relevant professionals to gather:

  • the project plans;
  • acoustic studies;
  • odour studies;
  • technical specifications;
  • the proposed locations.

3. Check that the refusal was validly made

We analyse:

  • the conditions of the vote;
  • the applicable majorities;
  • the reasons given for the refusal;
  • whether there may have been an abuse of majority.

4. Bring court proceedings if necessary

Where the refusal appears unjustified, we bring the matter before the court to obtain judicial authorisation to carry out the works.

The aim is to secure your project legally before the business starts operating.

Is the landlord required to provide an extraction system for a restaurant?

Yes, in principle. Where the lease authorises a restaurant business, the landlord must provide a compliant extraction system as part of its obligation to deliver the premises fit for purpose, and it is for the landlord, as co-owner, to challenge the co-ownership's refusal. If it fails to do so, the tenant can take action against it. We explain this point in detail in our article Restaurant extraction: must the landlord install it?.

Baptiste Robelin: recognised expertise in restaurant extraction cases in co-owned buildings

Baptiste Robelin regularly advises restaurateurs, bakeries, pâtisseries, food retailers and hospitality operators (hotels, cafés, restaurants) faced with a co-ownership's refusal to authorise the installation of an extraction system.

Depending on the situation, his work involves:

  • holding the landlord liable where it has breached its obligation of delivery by letting premises unsuitable for the authorised business;
  • obtaining court authorisation to install an extraction system despite the co-ownership's refusal;
  • negotiating directly with the landlord, the managing agent and the co-owners to reach an amicable solution.

An integrated technical and legal approach

Disputes over extraction ducts are not won on legal arguments alone.

The success of the case depends above all on the quality of the project presented.

For this reason, Baptiste Robelin works with a network of partners specialising in the café, hotel and restaurant (CHR) sector, in particular architects and engineering consultancies able to design effective and legally secure installation solutions.

The projects presented to co-ownerships and to the courts include in particular:

  • precise plans showing where the extraction duct will be installed;
  • integration that respects the appearance of the building;
  • measures limiting noise and odour nuisance;
  • technical solutions adapted to the constraints of older co-owned properties and urban buildings.

The aim is to present an extraction system that is robust, objectively verifiable and difficult to challenge.

Regular experience of co-ownership litigation

Baptiste Robelin regularly appears before the tribunaux judiciaires and the chambers specialising in co-ownership law.

This experience enables him to anticipate the arguments frequently raised by co-owners' associations, in particular:

  • harm to the appearance of the building;
  • the risk of nuisance;
  • technical constraints;
  • the intended use of the building;
  • the preservation of the common parts.

A strong negotiation culture

Not every case requires court proceedings.

A significant part of the work consists of negotiating with landlords, managing agents and co-ownerships to reach an agreement allowing the extraction system to be installed within a timeframe compatible with the business's economic constraints.

The aim is always to avoid, wherever possible, lengthy and costly proceedings that may delay the opening of the establishment.

Experience of court-appointed expert assessments

Where the court appoints an expert, Baptiste Robelin assists operators throughout the expert assessment.

These assessments make it possible to verify that the proposed extraction system does not generate excessive nuisance and complies with the building's technical constraints.

Expertise also shared in his publications

In his book Guide pratique pour ouvrir, gérer et céder un café, hôtel, restaurant (a practical guide to opening, running and selling a café, hotel or restaurant), Baptiste Robelin sets out the legal issues relating to extraction systems, relations with co-ownerships and practical solutions for securing operators' projects.

‍

Frequently asked questions on challenging a co-ownership over extraction systems

What is the time limit for challenging a co-ownership's refusal?

To seek annulment of the refusal, within two months of notification of the minutes of the general meeting. An application for court authorisation of the works is not subject to this time limit, but it is advisable to act quickly.

Can the tenant challenge the refusal themselves?

In principle, no: only a co-owner, in this case the landlord, can challenge a general meeting decision or apply for court authorisation. The tenant can, however, take action against their landlord to make it pursue these remedies.

Can I install the extraction system while waiting for the court's decision?

No. Works carried out without authorisation constitute a manifestly unlawful disturbance and expose you to an order to remove the duct.

How long do proceedings take?

The duration varies depending on the complexity of the case, whether a court-appointed expert assessment is ordered and the competent court.

Need to challenge a co-ownership's refusal?

Have you received a refusal concerning the installation of an extraction system?

The firm can help you analyse the lawfulness of that decision, secure your project and pursue the appropriate remedies.

 

‍

‍

‍

‍

To bring the matter before the court after a refusal by the general meeting, use our template writ of summons for obtaining court authorisation to install an extraction duct, annotated by our lawyers.

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on

Hospitality (hotels and restaurants)

What rules apply to a restaurant located in a shopping centre?

The same as for any restaurant: safety standards for establishments open to the public (ERP), food hygiene and a licence to sell alcohol. The health pass, which required checks at the entrance, was abolished in 2022. What sets a shopping centre restaurant apart is above all contractual: the lease often imposes opening hours aligned with those of the centre, a contribution to common service charges and to the traders' association, and sometimes a variable rent based on turnover. These clauses should be negotiated before signing.

What is the operating permit (permis d'exploitation) for selling alcohol?

The operating permit is compulsory training for anyone declaring the opening, change of ownership, relocation or transfer of a category 3 or 4 establishment selling drinks for consumption on the premises, or of a restaurant holding a 'petite licence restaurant' or a 'licence restaurant' (Art. L. 3332-1-1 of the French Public Health Code). It covers, in particular, the prevention of alcoholism, the protection of minors, the suppression of public drunkenness and noise control. It is delivered by approved bodies such as UMIH or the Chambers of Commerce and Industry (CCI). The permit is valid for 10 years, and a refresher course extends it for a further 10 years. For takeaway sales, no training is required during the day: only the sale of alcoholic beverages between 10 pm and 8 am requires specific training, leading to the permit for the night-time sale of alcoholic beverages (Art. L. 3331-4 of the same Code).

What ERP (establishments open to the public) rules must a restaurant or hotel comply with?

To open a restaurant in France, you must comply with the standards for Establishments Open to the Public (ERP), which guarantee the safety and comfort of customers. This includes accessibility for people with reduced mobility, with ramps, wide doors and adapted toilets, as well as fire safety, with emergency exits, fire extinguishers and compliant materials. The maximum capacity must be calculated according to the floor area and displayed at the entrance, while the kitchen and storage areas must follow HACCP rules for food hygiene. Finally, technical installations such as electricity, gas and ventilation must comply with safety standards and be inspected regularly. Meeting all these obligations is essential to obtain authorisation to open and receive the public.

What rules apply to happy hour?

Happy hour is not prohibited, but it is regulated. A licensee offering alcoholic drinks at a reduced price for a limited period must also offer non-alcoholic drinks at a reduced price (Art. L. 3323-1 of the French Public Health Code), on equivalent terms and with equivalent advertising. Failing this, they face a 4th-class petty offence (contravention) (Art. R. 3351-2 of the same Code). Open bars, on the other hand, are prohibited: offering unlimited free alcohol for commercial purposes, or selling it as the main offer for a flat fee (Art. L. 3322-9). Finally, communication around happy hour must respect the limits set by the Évin Law on alcohol advertising.

What should you do if your restaurant receives numerous fake negative reviews?

You must act quickly. Under civil law, the restaurant owner may seek compensation for the loss suffered (loss of custom, damage to reputation, non-pecuniary harm) on the basis of Article 1240 of the French Civil Code. Under criminal law, it is possible to have the author of the fake review convicted if the review is accompanied by criticism of the restaurant owner personally, which brings it within the offence of defamation. Website hosts (Google, TripAdvisor) must promptly remove reported fake reviews or face a fine of up to €75,000.

What are the rules for opening a shisha bar?

To open a shisha bar in France, you must first declare the establishment as an ERP (establishment open to the public) and comply with safety, accessibility and hygiene standards. Smoking is prohibited in all enclosed and covered places open to the public, including bars (Art. L. 3512-8 and R. 3512-2 of the French Public Health Code). Indoors, shisha may therefore only be smoked in a designated smoking area: an enclosed room, fitted with independent mechanical ventilation and automatic closing doors, which is not a thoroughfare and does not exceed 20% of the establishment's floor area or 35 m². No service of any kind may be provided there: neither table service nor preparation (Art. R. 3512-3 and R. 3512-4). Otherwise, shisha must be smoked on an open terrace, i.e. one that is not enclosed and covered. If the bar serves alcohol, it needs the corresponding licence and the operating permit (permis d'exploitation). Finally, opening hours and the ban on sales to minors must be observed, and the playing of music must be declared to SACEM where necessary.

What are the different hotel classifications in France?

In France, hotels are classified under an official system of 1 to 5 stars, based on several criteria relating to quality, comfort and services. 1 star: a simple hotel offering basic services (bed, private or shared bathroom, minimum cleanliness). 2 stars: a higher level with more comfort, a more spacious room and some additional services. 3 stars: a standard hotel, comfortable rooms, a range of services (Wi-Fi, TV, open reception, breakfast). 4 stars: a superior-quality hotel, spacious rooms, full services (restaurant, room service, gym, multilingual welcome). 5 stars: a luxury hotel, a very high level of comfort, top-of-the-range facilities, personalised services and exclusive amenities. The classification is awarded by Atout France, the official tourism agency, after an inspection and assessment of the criteria.

What are the different licences for selling alcohol in France?

In France, the sale of alcohol is governed by several licences depending on the type of drinks and the way they are sold. The licence III allows the sale of fermented drinks such as wine, beer or cider, but not spirits. The licence IV authorises the sale of all alcoholic drinks, including strong drinks such as whisky, vodka or rum. Restaurants may obtain a small restaurant licence (petite licence restaurant, for light alcoholic drinks) or a restaurant licence (licence restaurant, for all alcoholic drinks), solely for consumption with a meal. Finally, to sell alcohol to take away, you need a takeaway licence (licence à emporter), and the operator must also complete compulsory training known as the operating permit (permis d'exploitation).

How do you sell a hotel?

Selling a hotel is a complex transaction: the business must be valued according to its location, its classification, and its current and future potential. It is necessary to review the commercial lease and audit the accounts, as well as all the safety and compliance standards for receiving the public. The hotel may be sold by way of a sale of the business (fonds de commerce) or a sale of the company. Where the shares are sold, the parties are advised to provide for an asset and liability warranty. In all cases, it is essential to be assisted by a lawyer specialising in hospitality law, and by a notary if the building itself is sold.

How do you sell a restaurant?

It is possible to sell either the business (fonds de commerce) or the shares in the company that operates the restaurant. The key components of the business (accounts, commercial lease, customer base, any licences) must first be audited, and the business or company then valued (based on turnover and operating profit). It is strongly recommended to use a notary or a lawyer to draft the deed of sale.

Is mandatory training required to open a restaurant in France?

Yes, certain training courses are mandatory to open a restaurant in France, even though no cooking qualification is required. The main mandatory course is the operating permit (permis d'exploitation), which applies to restaurateurs who wish to sell alcohol. This training lasts around 20 hours (3 days) and covers alcohol regulations, the protection of minors and the operator's responsibilities. It is offered, for example, by organisations such as UMIH or CCI France and is valid for 10 years. Another mandatory course is HACCP food hygiene training, required for at least one person in the establishment who handles foodstuffs. It generally lasts 14 hours (2 days) and helps to ensure food safety. In short, to open a restaurant you mainly need HACCP training for hygiene and the operating permit if you sell alcohol.

Can a lawyer assist with a hotel project in Paris and throughout France?

Yes. Baptiste Robelin assists hospitality professionals in Paris and throughout France with hotel openings, business takeovers, lease negotiations and company formations.

What are the legal costs of opening or taking over a hotel?

Legal costs depend in particular on the size of the establishment, the commercial lease, the audits to be carried out, the sale transactions and the administrative formalities.

Do you need to comply with ERP standards to open a hotel?

Yes. Hotels are establishments open to the public (ERP) and must comply with strict rules on fire safety, accessibility, evacuation and technical installations.

Can a lawyer assist with the takeover of an existing hotel?

Yes. Baptiste Robelin regularly assists with acquisitions of hotel businesses, hotel takeovers, legal audits and lease negotiations.

What type of company should you choose to open a hotel?

The choice of legal structure depends in particular on the number of shareholders, the amount of investment, the method of financing, the development strategy and the desired tax treatment. In the hotel sector, the most commonly used structures are generally the SAS, SARL, SASU and EURL, as well as holding companies and SCIs (property companies) in certain arrangements.

Why secure the commercial lease before opening a hotel?

The commercial lease is often one of the most important assets of a hotel business. Certain clauses must be negotiated carefully: the amount of rent, the allocation of service charges, works, the term of the lease, renewal and eviction compensation.

Why instruct a lawyer to open a hotel?

Opening a hotel involves numerous legal issues: hotel commercial lease, company formation, ERP compliance, employment law, tourism regulations, supplier contracts and administrative authorisations. A lawyer's assistance makes it possible to secure your project legally from the outset and to avoid difficulties that could jeopardise the operation of the establishment.

Restaurateur face aux copropriétaires opposés à l'installation d'une gaine d'extraction, avec un marteau de juge symbolisant le recours en justice
Explore all our resources
No items found.

Let's talk about your project or situation

Every situation deserves a clear, pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.