HomeDebt recovery
We use cookies to measure our website's audience. You may object at any time to processing based on legitimate interest by clicking 'Decline'. For more information: Privacy policy
Business law

Recovering unpaid fees for freelancers and consultants

Consultant indépendant préoccupé lisant une facture impayée à son bureau, devant son ordinateur portable
Contents
Our specialists
Baptiste Robelin

Are you a freelancer, independent consultant or service provider whose client is slow to pay your fees?

An unpaid invoice can quickly strain your cash flow and cost you valuable time: repeated reminders, broken promises of payment, belated disputes over the invoice or, sometimes, no response at all from the client.

Novlaw helps freelancers and consultants with the recovery of their unpaid fees, from the first formal notice through to court proceedings when they become necessary.

Developers, designers, copywriters, strategy, IT or marketing consultants, trainers, translators, project managers: whether you operate as a micro-entrepreneur, an EURL or a SASU, our aim is to help you recover the sums owed to you quickly and effectively, with a strategy tailored to the value of the assignment, your client's situation and what is at stake in your business relationship.

Your client won't pay for your assignment?

The work has been done. The deliverables have been handed over. Your invoice is due. Yet, despite your reminders, payment does not arrive.

This is a common situation for freelancers and consultants. It may involve, for example:

  • unpaid consulting fees;
  • an outstanding balance on an assignment, even though the client is already using your deliverables;
  • monthly time-and-materials invoices piling up over several months;
  • additional services requested by email and never paid for;
  • a daily-rate package disputed on the grounds that the time spent was “excessive”;
  • a client who ends the assignment midway and refuses to pay for the work already done;
  • a client who no longer responds, or keeps promising a bank transfer that never arrives;
  • a client who suddenly claims to be “not satisfied” once the invoice is overdue;
  • late-payment penalties or compensation still owed.

When amicable reminders are no longer enough, a lawyer's involvement makes it possible to formalise the demand for payment and promptly initiate the appropriate recovery procedure.

A freelancer's rights against a client who won't pay

An independent professional has neither a legal department nor a collections team. The balance of power seems uneven. It is not: the law protects service providers, whatever their status.

A client cannot make you accept payment at 90 days

Between businesses, unless otherwise agreed, your fees are payable thirty days after the service is performed. Even if negotiated, the payment term cannot exceed sixty days from the invoice date, or forty-five days end of month if the parties have expressly agreed so (article L. 441-10 of the Code de commerce, the French Commercial Code). A clause in a large client's purchasing terms providing for a longer period is unlawful and exposes that client to an administrative fine.

Late-payment penalties: micro-entrepreneurs are entitled to them too

Many freelancers are unaware of this: late-payment penalties apply to any service provider invoicing a business, micro-entrepreneurs included. They are payable without any reminder from the day after the due date. If no rate is set in your quote, the European Central Bank rate plus ten percentage points applies; a contractual rate cannot be lower than three times the statutory interest rate (article L. 441-10 of the Code de commerce).

In addition, for each invoice paid late, fixed compensation of €40 is due (article D. 441-5 of the Code de commerce). On time-and-materials work invoiced monthly for a year, that means twelve fixed compensation payments. Against a private individual client, interest at the statutory rate runs from the date of the formal notice (article 1231-6 of the Code civil, the French Civil Code).

Your copyright: the lever specific to creatives and developers

Logos, brand guidelines, websites, illustrations, texts, photographs, source code: much of what freelancers deliver is protected by copyright. Yet the assignment of these rights is subject to strict formal requirements: each right assigned must be mentioned separately, and the scope of exploitation must be defined in terms of extent, purpose, territory and duration (article L. 131-3 of the Code de la propriété intellectuelle, the French Intellectual Property Code).

Paying for a service therefore does not automatically transfer the rights in the work. If your quote does not provide for a compliant assignment, or makes the assignment conditional on full payment of the price, a client who puts your website online or prints your logo without paying you is exposed to an infringement action. Pointing out this risk in the formal notice often changes the outcome of the discussion.

A recovery service designed for freelancers and consultants

Recovering your fees does not always mean going to court. Novlaw favours a step-by-step approach, proportionate to the value of the assignment and focused on results.

1. Review of your case

We examine what establishes your claim: commercial proposal, quote, engagement letter, purchase order, general terms, timesheets, approval emails, deliverables sent. This review lets us assess the strength of the case, anticipate the client's objections, check that you are still within the time limits and choose the most suitable strategy.

2. Formal notice to pay sent by a lawyer

When your own reminders have had no effect, a formal notice sent by a law firm gives your demand new weight. For a freelancer, it has a particular effect: the client realises that its service provider will not be facing it alone.

It quantifies your fees, the penalties and the €40 compensation payments, refers where relevant to the copyright at stake, sets a deadline for payment and announces the next steps envisaged. Where appropriate, we negotiate a signed payment schedule, which has the advantage of serving as an acknowledgement of debt.

3. Court recovery of fees

If the client refuses to pay or does not respond, Novlaw initiates the procedure offering the best balance between speed, cost and likelihood of recovery. The choice depends mainly on how your assignment was invoiced:

  • Fixed-price assignment, quote accepted and not disputed: an order for payment (injonction de payer) is often the simplest route, since the amount is set by the quote itself.
  • Deliverables approved or already used by the client: summary proceedings for an interim payment (référé-provision) make it possible to obtain a judgment quickly, as the debt cannot be seriously disputed.
  • Time-and-materials or daily-rate work where the time is disputed, or quality of work challenged: proceedings on the merits are generally required, before the tribunal judiciaire (civil court) or the commercial court, depending on the status of the parties.
  • Small invoice and a willing but slow client: the simplified procedure for recovering small claims, conducted by a commissaire de justice (judicial officer) without a judge, may be enough (article L. 125-1 of the Code des procédures civiles d'exécution, the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures).

4. Enforcement and recovery of the sums awarded

Obtaining a judgment is not always enough. Working with a commissaire de justice, we support you until payment is actually made. When a client shows signs of financial weakness, a protective attachment of its accounts may even be sought before any judgment.

My client disputes my invoice: can I still take action?

Yes. A dispute does not mean your client can legitimately refuse all payment. It is in fact the most common scenario in intellectual services: the client who had approved the mock-ups, the report or the code discovers, once the invoice is overdue, that they do not suit it.

  • A difference in taste is not non-performance. A client may only withhold payment if the non-performance is sufficiently serious (article 1219 of the Code civil). An aesthetic preference or a minor correction does not justify blocking the entire invoice.
  • A price reduction cannot be imposed unilaterally. A client who considers itself wronged may seek a proportionate price reduction, after a formal notice (article 1223 of the Code civil). It cannot withhold the full amount while using your work.
  • What the client has done with your deliverables matters. An email saying “approved”, a development put into production, the publication of a text or the presentation of your report to the executive committee weigh heavily in your favour.
  • A consultant is not required to guarantee results. A consulting assignment in principle commits the consultant to applying their expertise, not to guaranteeing a commercial outcome. The client cannot refuse to pay solely because the recommended strategy did not produce the hoped-for effects, unless otherwise agreed.

Novlaw analyses the agreed scope, the services performed, the approvals given and the grounds put forward, then claims the sums still owed, if need be starting with the part of the invoice the client does not dispute.

Assignment started without a signed quote: can you get paid?

Yes, in many cases. An assignment started after a call and a confirmation email, additional services requested on Slack or by message: the order can be proved by written exchanges, deliverables sent, deposits paid or meeting minutes.

Evidence may be adduced by any means against a client who is a trader (article L. 110-3 of the Code de commerce). Against a private individual or a non-trader client, written evidence is in principle required above €1,500 (article 1359 of the Code civil), but emails or partial performance may constitute prima facie written evidence (commencement de preuve par écrit).

The client ends the assignment early?

The work done up to the termination remains payable. Depending on the contract (fixed term, notice period, termination fee clause), compensation may also be claimed. For a consultant who has worked with the same client for several years, termination without sufficient notice may also amount to an abrupt termination of an established commercial relationship (article L. 442-1, II, of the Code de commerce), subject to an analysis of your status and of the relationship.

How long should you wait before acting against a client who won't pay?

As little as possible. Freelancers often tend to wait in order to preserve the relationship, and keep working while the invoices pile up. After the due date and a few unsuccessful reminders, formal action quickly clarifies the client's position before the outstanding amount becomes hard to absorb.

Your right to act is also limited in time. Against a business client, you have five years (article L. 110-4 of the Code de commerce; article 2224 of the Code civil). Against a private individual – coaching, training, a showcase website ordered for personal purposes – the limit drops to two years (article L. 218-2 of the Code de la consommation, the French Consumer Code).

This period in principle runs from performance of the service, not from the sending of the invoice (Cass. 3e civ., 1er mars 2023, n° 21-23.176): waiting until the end of a long assignment to invoice everything does not extend it. Reminders, even by registered letter, do not interrupt it either; an acknowledgement of debt or a court claim does (articles 2240 and 2241 of the Code civil).

Specific situations for independent professionals

Assignment obtained through a matchmaking platform

First, identify your contracting party (the end client or the platform) and read the platform's general terms: escrow of funds, internal dispute procedure, jurisdiction clause. These determine whom to act against and before which court.

Freelancer working through an umbrella company (portage salarial)

Under portage salarial, it is the umbrella company that enters into the service contract with the client company and issues the invoices. In principle, therefore, it is the umbrella company that must take recovery action. We can help you assert your rights if it fails to act diligently.

Client based abroad

Remote work makes foreign clients common. Within the European Union, the European order for payment procedure (Regulation (EC) No 1896/2006) makes it possible to obtain an enforceable title valid in all Member States. Outside the Union, the strategy depends on the country, the contract terms and where the client's assets are located.

Start-up or client in financial difficulty

Repeated delays by a young client company are sometimes the first sign of forthcoming insolvency proceedings. If an opening judgment is published in the BODACC (the official bulletin of civil and commercial notices), your fees must be declared to the court-appointed creditors' representative (mandataire judiciaire) within two months (article R. 622-24 of the Code de commerce), failing which they cannot be asserted in the proceedings. Hence the value of acting beforehand, and of not continuing the assignment without a payment guarantee.

Why entrust the recovery of your fees to Novlaw?

As a freelancer or consultant, your time should be devoted to your assignments and to growing your business, rather than to chasing bad payers.

Entrusting your case to Novlaw gives you:

  • a legal analysis of your claim before incurring further costs;
  • a formal notice drafted by a lawyer, quantifying penalties and compensation;
  • a strategy tailored to the value of the assignment, the client's solvency and the future of your relationship with them;
  • support in both amicable and court-based recovery, with a single point of contact;
  • experience in commercial litigation and in the levers specific to intellectual services: proof of the order, approval of deliverables, copyright;
  • an approach aimed at securing payment while keeping recovery costs under control;
  • fully remote case handling, with electronic signature, wherever you are in France.

Which documents should you send to recover your fees?

To allow an initial review of your case, you can send us, in particular:

Your contract or quote
Commercial proposal, accepted quote, engagement letter, purchase order, general terms or any other document establishing the client's agreement. If the assignment came through a platform, its general terms.

Your unpaid invoices
With their issue date, due date and the amount outstanding. For time-and-materials work, timesheets or activity reports.

Proof that the assignment was carried out
Deliverables, successive versions, approval emails, go-live or production release, meeting minutes.

Your exchanges with the client
Reminders, replies, requests for extra time, promises of payment or any disputes, including via instant messaging.

Even an incomplete file can be reviewed.

How can you avoid unpaid invoices on future assignments?

  • Have a quote or engagement letter accepted specifying the scope, the number of revision rounds included, the price, payment terms and the procedure for approving deliverables.
  • Ask for a deposit at the outset and invoice by milestones on long assignments.
  • Adopt general terms and conditions suited to intellectual services: penalties, €40 compensation, termination, ownership of deliverables.
  • Make the assignment of copyright conditional on full payment of the price.
  • Confirm by email every out-of-scope request before carrying it out.
  • Suspend the assignment when several invoices remain unpaid, rather than letting the outstanding amount grow.

How much does recovering your fees cost?

For an independent professional, this question is decisive: incurring costs that exceed the recoverable amount makes no sense. We therefore start by assessing with you what the action can reasonably yield.

At Novlaw, fees start from €250 excl. VAT for a formal notice and from €950 excl. VAT for certain straightforward court procedures. A quote is provided before any work begins. The late-payment penalties and fixed compensation claimed from the client, as well as any order against the client under article 700 of the Code de procédure civile (legal costs), offset all or part of these costs. To find out more: how much do commercial proceedings cost?

Do you have unpaid fees?

You have completed your assignment but your client won't pay you?

Send Novlaw your invoice and the main documents in your file.

We analyse your situation to identify the most suitable recovery solution: formal notice, negotiation, order for payment or court proceedings.

Entrust the recovery of your fees to Novlaw and focus on your business.

Are you a tradesperson or construction company? See our dedicated service for unpaid construction invoices. Estate agent? Discover our service for recovering estate agency fees.

For an overview of the procedures, see our guide to debt recovery.

FAQ – Unpaid fees for freelancers and consultants

My client won't pay for my freelance assignment: what should I do?

Gather what proves the order and the delivery: quote, emails, deliverables, approvals. After a few reminders, a lawyer's formal notice quantifying your fees, penalties and compensation is often enough. Failing that, a procedure suited to how you invoiced can be initiated.

Can fees be recovered without going to court?

Yes. Going to court is not automatic. A lawyer's formal notice or a structured negotiation often secures payment or a payment schedule without court proceedings.

Can a micro-entrepreneur claim late-payment penalties?

Yes. Late-payment penalties and the fixed compensation of €40 per invoice apply to any service provider invoicing a business, whatever its status (articles L. 441-10 and D. 441-5 of the Code de commerce).

Can a client impose payment at 90 days on me?

No. Between businesses, the agreed term cannot exceed sixty days from the invoice date, or forty-five days end of month (article L. 441-10 of the Code de commerce). Absent agreement, it is thirty days after the service.

I started the assignment without a signed quote: can I get paid?

Often, yes. Emails, messages, deliverables sent, deposits paid or meeting minutes can prove the order. Evidence may be adduced by any means against a client who is a trader; against a private individual, written evidence is in principle required above €1,500, but written exchanges may serve as prima facie evidence.

The client is not satisfied with my work: can it refuse to pay?

Not automatically. It may only withhold payment if the non-performance is sufficiently serious, and any price reduction must be proportionate. Approval or use of the deliverables by the client weighs heavily in your favour. A consultant is in principle not required to guarantee the results of their recommendations.

The client is using my creations without paying me: what can I do?

If the assignment of your copyright was not formalised in accordance with article L. 131-3 of the Code de la propriété intellectuelle, or if it was conditional on full payment, use of your creations may constitute infringement. This is a lever to raise from the formal notice stage.

How long do I have to claim my fees?

Five years against a business client, two years against a private individual (article L. 218-2 of the Code de la consommation), in principle from performance of the service. Reminders do not interrupt this period.

My client is abroad: can I take action against them?

Yes. Within the European Union, the European order for payment procedure makes it possible to obtain an enforceable title valid in all Member States. Outside the Union, the strategy depends on the country and the contract terms.

Ils ont fait appel à NOVLAW avocats

Chargement…

Frequently asked questions on

Debt recovery

What means are available to recover an unpaid debt between businesses?

Several routes are available to recover a debt between businesses: formal notice by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt (the starting point for late-payment interest); an order for payment (injonction de payer: a rapid procedure, initially without the debtor being heard, for debts that are certain and due); a summons for an interim payment in summary proceedings (référé-provision) before the president of the commercial court (for debts that cannot seriously be disputed); and a summons on the merits if the debt itself is disputed.

What is an order for payment (injonction de payer) and how does it work?

The order for payment (injonction de payer) is a simplified procedure enabling a creditor to obtain an enforceable title quickly against a defaulting debtor. The application is filed with the registry of the competent court. If the judge grants it, he or she issues an order for payment, which must be served on the debtor by a bailiff. The debtor has one month to lodge an objection. If no objection is lodged, the order is endorsed with the enforcement formula and allows the creditor to carry out seizures.

Can a bailiff be used to recover a debt without going to court?

Yes. Since 2012, a commissaire de justice (formerly huissier de justice, or bailiff) can be instructed to carry out an amicable recovery procedure for small debts (up to €5,000) owed by individuals, without first going to court. If the debtor agrees to pay, an agreement is formalised. This procedure is quick (less than 3 months) and inexpensive. If it fails, it is still possible to bring ordinary court proceedings.

Consultant indépendant préoccupé lisant une facture impayée à son bureau, devant son ordinateur portable
Explore all our resources
No items found.

Have your unpaid fees reviewed

Send us your quote or engagement letter, your invoices and your exchanges with the client: we will quickly tell you the most effective way to get paid for your assignment, amicably or in court.