

In brief: a public energy or energy performance contract (operation and maintenance, heating, lighting, energy retrofitting, charging points, global performance contracts) binds the buyer and the contractor to quantified targets, consumption levels and availability over long periods. Disputes arise from the gap between promised performance and measured performance. Novlaw Avocats advises public buyers as well as companies, consortia, maintenance providers and operators.
In public energy contracts, risk does not arise only from a delay or a disagreement over price. It often arises earlier, when the contract sets performance targets, consumption assumptions, availability indicators, operating commitments or variable remuneration mechanisms that will then weigh on the whole life of the contract.
In other words, in this sector the real issue is not only launching or winning the tender. It is avoiding being locked, a few months later, into a contract that is technically ambitious but legally unbalanced.
Novlaw Avocats advises local authorities, public bodies and social landlords, as well as companies, consortia, maintenance providers, operators, integrators and service providers involved in public contracts for energy, utilities, energy retrofitting, lighting, heating, charging points and energy performance.
For a public buyer, a successful energy contract is one whose targets are measurable, verifiable and enforceable against the contractor. This is prepared before the tender.
Further reading: local authority law, project management assistance (AMO) in public procurement, abnormally low tenders and the mandatory environmental criterion.
In public contracts, anticipation is a decisive factor in profitability. An incomplete reading of the requirement, poorly calibrated performance targets, an imprecise allocation of responsibilities or an insufficiently secure price formula can weaken the contract before it even starts.
We advise operators as soon as the tender is published in order to identify risks upstream, particularly when analysing the tender documents (DCE), the award criteria, the financial clauses, the performance targets and the penalty mechanisms. In the same way, we help buyers make their tender documents robust before publication.
Further reading: How to respond to a public tender.
The performance of a public energy contract is a particularly sensitive area. The difficulty lies not only in installing or delivering equipment: it also lies in the duration, availability, expected performance, contract monitoring and traceability of unforeseen events.
Our role is to prevent technical, operational or regulatory constraints from being recast, after the event, as contractual breaches attributed to the contractor, and to enable the buyer to enforce its requirements on solid grounds.
In energy contracts, disputes often arise from the gap between promised performance and measured performance.
Availability rates, consumption levels, energy saving targets, response times, quality of service, continuity of supply, preventive or corrective maintenance: these obligations must be read in the light of the contract, the input data, the technical assumptions and the actual operating conditions.
In the energy sector, contractual structures can be particularly technical, especially where the buyer uses a global performance contract or a global energy performance contract.
We assist our clients in analysing the structure, defining quantified targets, interpreting performance indicators, framing contractual sanctions and managing difficulties during performance.
Further reading: The global performance contract.
See also: The global energy performance contract with deferred payment.
Some projects also involve questions of energy value, energy savings certificates (CEE), structuring of financial flows or the inclusion of specific mechanisms in the contract.
We advise operators and buyers on the legal risks associated with these structures, whether concerning the monetisation of CEE, how they are taken into account in remuneration, or the consequences of failing to obtain them.
Further reading: Energy savings certificates and public contracts.
Our support does not end when the installation starts up or the services are accepted.
Public energy contracts are long-term. Difficulties often appear after commissioning: performance drift, equipment unavailability, technical defects, failure to maintain, default by a specialist subcontractor, disputes over compliance with contractual targets.
The end of an energy contract is often the point at which tensions crystallise.
Disagreements frequently concern the application of delay or performance penalties, price reductions, payment for services not originally provided for, price revision, the financial consequences of a change in scope or the restoration of the economic balance of the contract.
Further reading: Assistance with dispute resolution and litigation in public contracts.
See also: Drafting a compliant statement of claim.
Litigation before the administrative courts is not always the most effective solution, particularly where the contract is ongoing, operating relations must continue or the main priority is the swift resumption of service.
Whenever appropriate, we favour amicable methods of dispute resolution: structured negotiation, mediation, settlement agreements and amicable handling of disputed accounts.
Further reading: Using mediation.
Risk is not limited to performance of the contract. Upstream, an operator may need to challenge an irregular award procedure before the contract is signed, and the buyer must be able to defend its choice and comply with the standstill period.
Further reading: Lawyer for pre-contractual interim relief (référé précontractuel).
By starting from a reliable baseline, defining precise indicators and a measurement and verification method in the contract, and providing for proportionate penalties with clear grounds for exemption. Inaccurate input data undermines any penalty applied later.
Yes, where the performance gap results from external causes, inaccurate input data, a change in scope or a decision by the buyer. A manifestly excessive penalty may also be reduced by the court: see the guide to penalties in public contracts.
The first step is to check the revision, indexation and review clauses. If an external and unforeseeable event temporarily upsets the balance of the contract, a contractor that continues performance may claim compensation (Article L. 6, 3°, of the Code de la commande publique): see unforeseeability (imprévision) in public contracts.
Choosing Novlaw Avocats means working with a legal partner who understands the technical, operational and financial imperatives specific to energy contracts, on the buyer's side as well as the contractor's.
Discover our broader expertise in this field: public procurement lawyer.
The time limit for lodging an appeal on points of law (pourvoi en cassation) against a judgment of an Administrative Court of Appeal is two months from notification of the court's decision. However, this time limit is reduced to 15 days where the case concerns summary proceedings (référé).
The term 'public buyer' covers the contracting authorities and contracting entities subject to the French Public Procurement Code. Examples include the State, local authorities and municipalities.
The innovation partnership differs from a conventional R&D contract in that it covers, within a single contract, both the research and development phase AND the acquisition of the solution developed, without any need to launch a new procedure for the purchase. By contrast, a pure R&D contract covers only the research phase, and the buyer must then organise a new procedure to acquire the solution. The innovation partnership is therefore better suited where the buyer has a clearly identified need but no existing solution.
The time limit for appealing a decision of an administrative court (tribunal administratif) is two months from notification of the judgment. This time limit is only 15 days if the decision is an interim relief order (référé).
The French Public Procurement Code (Code de la commande publique) imposes three so-called formalised procedures where the value of the public contract exceeds the procedural thresholds: the call for tenders (open or restricted), the negotiated procedure, or the competitive dialogue.
A public contract is a contract for pecuniary interest concluded by a public buyer with an economic operator to meet its needs for works, supplies or services. Depending on its value or subject matter, the public contract must be awarded following an advertising and competitive tendering procedure.
A global contract (marché global) is a public contract with a composite subject matter, whereby a buyer entrusts an economic operator with an overall assignment comprising services of different kinds (design/construction/operation/maintenance) in return for payment of a price.
Where the estimated value of a contract is below the thresholds for formalised procedures, the buyer may use an adapted procedure contract (marché à procédure adaptée, MAPA). The terms of the advertising and competitive tendering procedure are freely determined by the buyer.
Acceptance of works under a public contract is the act by which the project owner accepts the works carried out, with or without reservations. It marks the starting point of the statutory guarantees (completion, two-year and ten-year) and transfers custody of the works to the project owner. Acceptance may be granted subject to reservations, which must be lifted within an agreed period, or refused if the works have significant defects.
Yes, up to €140,000 excluding VAT since 1 July 2026, provided that the innovative nature of the solution acquired can be demonstrated. This threshold derives from Article 16 of Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on the simplification of economic life, which does not set any amount but refers to the European threshold applicable to supply and service contracts awarded by central government authorities: it will therefore change with each biennial revision, and Article R. 2122-9-1 of the French Public Procurement Code still refers to the former amount of €100,000 excluding VAT. The innovative nature must be documented before the contract is awarded, as it is the condition for using the mechanism and the first point of vulnerability in the event of a challenge. Above this threshold, the innovation partnership under Article L. 2172-3 or the negotiated procedure under Article R. 2124-3 of the same Code offer suitable routes.
Incorporating BIM into a public works contract involves drafting specific contractual documents: a BIM agreement defining the rules of collaboration, a BIM protocol specifying the expected levels of development (LOD), and specific clauses in the CCAP (special administrative terms and conditions) governing the uses of the model, liability in the event of errors and the arrangements for delivering data at the end of the works.
An unsuccessful bidder may apply to the administrative court for “pre-contractual interim relief” (référé précontractuel), before the contract is signed by the buyer, to have a breach of the advertising and competitive tendering obligations sanctioned. Once the contract has been signed, other remedies exist (contractual interim relief or référé contractuel, and actions challenging the validity of the contract). Your lawyer's responsiveness is decisive here (very short time limits of 11 or 16 days).
The estimated value of a public contract is based on the total amount payable, excluding VAT, as estimated by the contracting authority. The value is calculated over the entire term of the contract, including renewals and options. It is this estimated value that determines the applicable procedural thresholds and the advertising and competitive tendering obligations.
Yes, through routes that differ depending on the nature of the scheme. Where the procedure falls within public procurement, pre-contractual interim relief (référé précontractuel) is available before the contract is signed. In other cases, the rejection is an administrative decision that may be challenged by an action for annulment (recours pour excès de pouvoir), the court's review then focusing in particular on compliance with the rules of the call for projects, equal treatment of candidates and the absence of any manifest error of assessment.
In public construction, the public project owner may be held liable for failing to meet its obligations: inadequate preliminary studies, poor definition of needs, or failings in the management and supervision of the works. Liability may also arise towards third parties (local residents, users) for damage caused by the public works. These disputes fall within the jurisdiction of the administrative court.
Yes, the innovative procurement scheme was specifically designed to make it easier for SMEs and start-ups to access public procurement. The exemption threshold, raised to €140,000 excluding VAT since 1 July 2026 by Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on simplifying economic life, allows public buyers to deal directly with a young company without organising a lengthy and costly procedure. Buyers can also use sourcing and calls for projects to identify innovative SMEs before launching their procedure.
A framework agreement is a contract whose purpose is to establish the rules governing the purchase orders to be issued or the terms governing the subsequent contracts to be awarded during a given period, in particular with regard to prices and, where applicable, the quantities envisaged. It is subject to the same award rules as public contracts.
No. The standstill period runs from the date on which the buyer sends the rejection notification, not from its receipt by the unsuccessful candidate. Postal delivery time therefore eats into your window for action, which argues for reacting immediately upon receipt of the rejection letter.
No. The standstill period is calculated in calendar days, from date to date, without being carried over to the next working day. If it ends on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday, the buyer may sign the contract from the next working day: the application for pre-contractual interim relief must therefore be filed before that deadline.

Every situation deserves a clear and pragmatic analysis. Novlaw helps you secure your decisions, anticipate risks and defend your interests.