

Are you a partner or shareholder in a SARL, SAS, SA or SCI, and has your relationship with your fellow partner broken down? Blocked decisions, accounts left unapproved, a director running the company alone, a partner developing a competing business, a sale of shares that never goes through: a dispute between partners can paralyse a company and erode its value within a few months.
Novlaw advises partners, shareholders and directors on resolving their disputes, from reviewing the articles of association through to negotiating an exit or bringing court proceedings. Our aim is not to multiply proceedings, but to achieve the outcome you are seeking: regaining control, restoring the proper running of the company, stopping wrongful conduct or selling your shares at a fair price.
The situations we deal with most often are the following:
In a dispute between partners, you should first define the objective, then review the articles of association and the shareholders' agreement, gather the evidence before revealing your strategy, and only then choose between negotiation, an evidence-gathering measure, interim relief or proceedings on the merits. Acting in the wrong order, for example by sending a detailed formal notice before securing the evidence, often weakens the position of the partner who takes action.
These key steps are set out in detail in the 7 tips from Baptiste Robelin for disputes between partners.
Being in the minority does not mean being without rights. Depending on the form of the company, you have a right to inspect corporate documents (in particular Article L. 223-26 of the Code de commerce for SARLs), the option of requesting a management audit (expertise de gestion) (Articles L. 223-37 and L. 225-231 of the Code de commerce) and the right to challenge decisions taken solely in the interest of the majority on the grounds of abuse of majority, which may lead to the decision being set aside and damages being awarded.
Where the director has mismanaged the company, you may also bring a derivative action (action sociale ut singuli) in the name and on behalf of the company (Articles L. 223-22 and L. 225-252 of the Code de commerce). Any clause in the articles making such an action subject to the authorisation of the general meeting is deemed unwritten.
A partner who refuses to vote for a decision essential to the company's survival, solely to further their own personal interests, may be committing an abuse of minority. The court may then appoint a representative to vote in their place and hold them liable. We first check whether the articles offer a quicker solution: suitable majority thresholds, an exclusion clause or an exit procedure.
In an equally held company, neither partner can impose a decision. Depending on the situation, several routes are available: mechanisms provided for in the shareholders' agreement, mediation, sanctioning an abuse of equality through the appointment of a representative, a provisional administrator where the deadlock exposes the company to imminent danger, a negotiated sale of one partner's shares or, as a last resort, judicial dissolution for just cause (Article 1844-7, 5° of the Code civil), which is reserved for disagreements that genuinely paralyse the running of the company. All these solutions are explained in our guide company held 50/50: how to break a deadlock between partners.
A director incurs personal liability for mismanagement and for breaches of the articles or the law. Before taking action, evidence can be obtained through an investigative measure under Article 145 of the Code de procédure civile. We also review transactions between the company and its directors under the rules on related-party agreements (conventions réglementées).
Being a partner does not, in principle, in itself prohibit running a competing business. However, a partner bound by a non-compete clause, or a director owing a duty of loyalty to the company, incurs liability if they compete with the company or divert its customers. See our analysis: can a partner set up a competing business?
In a SARL, the manager (gérant) may be removed by a decision of the partners taken under the conditions of Article L. 223-29 of the Code de commerce, unless the articles require a higher majority: more than half of the shares, then, failing that and unless otherwise provided, a majority of the votes cast at a second consultation. The manager may also be removed by the court for legitimate cause, at the request of any partner; removal without just cause gives rise to a right to damages (Article L. 223-25 of the Code de commerce). In a SAS, the conditions for removing the president are set by the articles (Article L. 227-5 of the Code de commerce). We secure the procedure both for the company and for the director being removed. For details of the rules and case law, see our guide on the removal of the manager of a SARL or the director of a SAS.
A partner can exit through a sale of shares, a buy-back by the other partners or by the company, or by exercising a right of withdrawal where one exists. Where the price is disputed, the value of the shares may be set by an expert in the cases provided for by Article 1843-4 of the Code civil. Well-constructed proceedings can also unblock stalled negotiations, as in this case where a derivative action enabled a minority partner to sell their shares.
A blocked property sale, a disputed manager, heirs in disagreement, a partner who no longer pays their share of the costs: family SCIs are governed by specific rules of the Code civil (Articles 1848 to 1869). See our guide on disputes between partners in a family SCI.
Most disputes between partners end in an agreement. But that agreement still has to be negotiated from a position of strength. Our approach, developed by Baptiste Robelin, founding partner and head of the business law practice, rests on four principles:
Holding company of five restaurants held 50/50. Our client accused his partner, the managing director, of mismanagement, suspicious cash movements and a parallel activity for a competitor. An investigative measure under Article 145 of the Code de procédure civile made it possible to gather probative evidence. The negotiation that followed led to the sale of the partner's shares at a price reflecting the breaches identified, without proceedings on the merits.
Deadlocked minority partner. Faced with a majority partner who refused to negotiate the price of his shares, our client brought a derivative action based on documented mismanagement. The writ of summons reopened discussions and led to a settlement allowing him to sell his shares. Read the case study.
These cases have been anonymised. Their outcome depended on their own particular circumstances and does not prejudge the result of any other matter.
Disputes between partners in a commercial company (SARL, SAS, SA, SNC) fall within the jurisdiction of the commercial courts: the tribunal de commerce or, in the relevant districts, the tribunal des activités économiques (economic activities court). Disputes between partners in a civil company, such as an SCI, are in principle heard by the tribunal judiciaire. The articles or the shareholders' agreement may also provide for prior mediation or arbitration. Novlaw acts from its offices in Paris, Lyon and Lille, and before courts throughout France.
Your file can be reviewed even if it is incomplete. Do not take documents to which you do not normally have access: using them could backfire on you.
The cost depends on the strategy chosen: structured negotiation, an investigative measure or proceedings on the merits do not require the same resources. From the outset, we assess with you what each option can reasonably achieve in view of its cost and duration. A quote is provided before any work begins. To find out more: how much do commercial proceedings cost?
First check the articles and the shareholders' agreement: they sometimes provide for specific majorities, an exclusion clause or an exit procedure. Failing that, a deadlock contrary to the company's interest, motivated solely by the partner's personal interest, may amount to an abuse of minority. The court may then appoint a representative to vote in their place.
The possible routes are a negotiated sale of one partner's shares, the exit mechanisms in the shareholders' agreement, mediation, sanctioning an abuse of equality, the appointment of a provisional administrator if the company faces imminent danger and, as a last resort, judicial dissolution for just cause (Article 1844-7, 5° of the Code civil).
Yes. They have a right to inspect corporate documents and, subject to holding a minimum share of the capital, may apply to the court for a management audit (Articles L. 223-37 and L. 225-231 of the Code de commerce). They may also bring a liability action against the director on behalf of the company (derivative action, or action ut singuli).
Not as a rule. A forced exit is only possible if the articles or the shareholders' agreement provide for it, for example through an exclusion clause in a SAS (Article L. 227-16 of the Code de commerce) or a promise to sell. In practice, a sale is most often achieved through negotiation, once leverage has been established. See our guide on the exclusion of a partner from a SAS.
It all depends on their status and commitments. If they are bound by a valid non-compete clause, or are a director owing a duty of loyalty, they incur liability. Interim relief may make it possible to stop the disputed activity quickly, and a bailiff's report or a measure under Article 145 of the Code de procédure civile can be used to gather evidence.
An investigative measure on ex parte application or interim relief can be obtained within a few weeks. Proceedings on the merits before the commercial courts generally take more than a year at first instance. That is why the strategy often aims for a negotiated agreement as soon as the evidence has shifted the balance of power.
A liability action against the manager of a SARL or the directors of a SA is in principle time-barred after three years from the harmful act or, if it was concealed, from its discovery (Articles L. 223-23 and L. 225-254 of the Code de commerce). It is therefore best not to wait.
It is not always mandatory at the out-of-court stage, but the stakes (control of the company, value of the shares, personal liability) and the technical nature of the procedures make the assistance of a company law lawyer strongly advisable from the first signs of deadlock, particularly to secure the evidence.
The SARL (Société à Responsabilité Limitée, a private limited liability company) is a corporate form closely governed by statute, with relatively rigid rules on governance and the transfer of shares. The SAS (Société par Actions Simplifiée, a simplified joint-stock company) offers considerable freedom in drafting the articles of association, allowing shareholders to organise management and the terms of entry into and exit from the share capital as they see fit. The SAS is generally preferred for projects requiring fundraising or flexible governance, whereas the SARL is often chosen for its simplicity and clarity.
A shareholder can only be excluded if this is provided for in the articles of association or a shareholders' agreement. Failing that, the other shareholders may offer to buy back their shares at an agreed price or at a price set by an expert. In the event of a serious disagreement paralysing the company's operations, judicial dissolution may be sought. To avoid such situations, it is advisable to include exclusion, pre-emption and compulsory buy-out clauses in the articles of association or shareholders' agreement from the moment the company is set up.
A company director may be held personally liable for mismanagement (decisions contrary to the company's interest), breach of the articles of association or of the law, or a fault separable from their duties. In insolvency proceedings (judicial reorganisation or judicial liquidation), an action for liability for insufficiency of assets may be brought if the director's management errors contributed to the company's insufficiency of assets.

Send us your articles of association, your shareholders' agreement and a summary of the situation: we will identify your options and the most effective strategy to break the deadlock, protect your rights or organise your exit.